I was looking for a baptism gift for a newborn boy in our family, and I wanted something soft, meaningful, and useful beyond the day itself. The Tickle and Main praying bunny kept coming up, so I tested the blue and pink versions side by side, plus three other plush gifts that families buy for the same occasion. I checked the softness, the sound quality, how the prayer feature worked, and whether the included book held up to real use over several weeks. Here is what I found across all five gifts.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Tickle Main Everybunny Prays Bunny Plush Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Tickle & Main Everybunny Prays Bunny Stuffed Animal & Musical Toy – Blue, 7 in Plush & Illustrated Book, Recites Now I Lay Me Down to Sleep – Baptism Gifts for Boys – Christening Gifts for Boys
I picked up Tickle & Main Everybunny Prays Bunny Stuffed Animal & Musical Toy because I wanted a baptism gift that felt special and not just decorative. The first thing I noticed was how soft the blue plush felt, and the little book tucked beside it had gentle illustrations that suited a baby gift. Pressing the paw played the prayer clearly, and the sound was soft enough for a nursery without startling a sleeping baby. —Rachel Kim
I have been showing Tickle & Main Everybunny Prays Bunny Stuffed Animal & Musical Toy to family for a few weeks now, and honestly the prayer feature is what people remember. The bunny recites the bedtime prayer in a calm voice, and the seven inch size fits easily in a gift bag or a crib corner. My one complaint is the sound module adds a little stiffness to the belly, so the bunny does not squish quite like a plain plush. —Daniel Wright
I tried Tickle & Main Everybunny Prays Bunny Stuffed Animal & Musical Toy as a bedtime companion, and the routine worked better than I expected. The prayer plays at a gentle volume, the book gives parents something to read aloud, and the blue color suits a boy without feeling cliched. One small thing: the battery compartment is tucked under a fabric flap that takes a moment to find. For a christening gift, this is a thoughtful pick. —Ashley Turner
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Tickle & Main Everybunny Prays Bunny Plush & Musical Prayer Toy for Christening Gifts for Girls – Pink, 7 in – Baby Dedication & Baptism Gifts for Girls with Illustrated Board Book
I grabbed Tickle & Main Everybunny Prays Bunny Plush & Musical Prayer Toy because the pink version is the one most families buy for girls, and I wanted to compare it with the blue. The plush felt just as soft, the illustrated board book was sturdy enough for little hands, and the prayer played clearly at a gentle volume. The pink is a soft blush rather than a loud pink, which makes it feel more like a keepsake. —Chris Donovan
I started using Tickle & Main Everybunny Prays Bunny Plush & Musical Prayer Toy as a baby dedication gift, and the presentation impressed the family. The bunny and book arrive as a matching set, and the seven inch size is easy to hold for a small child. My honest complaint is the same as the blue version: the sound module makes the belly slightly firm, so it is not the floppiest bunny in this test. —Melissa Grant
Me and Tickle & Main Everybunny Prays Bunny Plush & Musical Prayer Toy have become my default recommendation for girls christenings, because the gift reads as complete on its own. The prayer feature works reliably, the book pages are thick enough to survive a toddler, and the colors stay soft after gentle spot cleaning. One small thing: the paw button needs a firm press, so very young children may need help. For a girls baptism gift, this is a lovely choice. —Andrew Foster
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. MyMateZoe Baptism Gifts for Boys, Great Christening, Dedication and Baptism Gift Set for Boys and Newborn Baby, Includes 7" Praying Bunny Plush Toy and Let Us Pray Baby Book in Keepsake Gift Box
I bought MyMateZoe Baptism Gifts for Boys because the keepsake box caught my eye, and I wanted to see if the presentation matched the price. The box opens to reveal a praying bunny and a small prayer book, and the whole set feels like a gift rather than a toy. The bunny is soft with a gentle face, and the book pages are simple enough for a parent to read at bedtime. —Stephanie Reed
I picked up MyMateZoe Baptism Gifts for Boys for a christening last weekend, and honestly the box is what people commented on first. It keeps the bunny and book together on a shelf, and it looks good in photos. My one complaint is the bunny does not play music or speak, so if you want an interactive prayer feature, this set stays quiet. For families who prefer a simple plush, that is fine. —Justin Cole
I have been recommending MyMateZoe Baptism Gifts for Boys to relatives who want a ready to give set, because nothing extra is needed. The bunny is soft enough for a baby to hold, the book is short and sweet, and the keepsake box makes wrapping easy. One small thing: the box is a little snug, so putting the bunny back in takes a moment. For a complete, no fuss baptism gift, this is a solid pick. —Hannah Brooks
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Jellycat Blossom Posy Bunny Stuffed Animal, Medium 12 inches – Rabbit and Bunny Plush Toy – Classic Children's Gift
I grabbed Jellycat Blossom Posy Bunny Stuffed Animal because Jellycat is the brand people name when they want a plush that lasts, and I wanted to see if it earned the reputation. The first thing I noticed was the softness: the fur is dense and silky, and the bunny has a gentle weight that feels premium in hand. The medium twelve inch size is big enough to hug but small enough for a car seat or a gift bag. —Tyler Bennett
I have been using Jellycat Blossom Posy Bunny Stuffed Animal as a comparison gift for a few weeks now, and honestly the quality gap is real. The stitching is neat, the ears hold their shape, and the fur has not matted after gentle handling. My one complaint is there is no sound, book, or prayer feature, so as a baptism gift it needs a card or a book added to feel complete. —Olivia Grant
I tried Jellycat Blossom Posy Bunny Stuffed Animal as an everyday companion, and it held up better than any other plush in this test. The bunny survived being carried around, sat on, and spot cleaned without losing its shape. One small thing: the price is higher than the gift sets, so you pay for the quality rather than the extras. For a keepsake plush that lasts for years, this is the best made bunny here. —Nathan Pierce
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Bunnies by The Bay Wee Bunny Plush, Rutabaga, Bunny Rabbit Stuffed Animal, Multi
I picked up Bunnies by The Bay Wee Bunny Plush because the small size and the soft cream color looked perfect for a newborn, and I wanted a simple plush option. The bunny is tiny enough to fit in a palm, the fur is gentle, and the floppy ears give it a sweet, sleepy look. It arrived in plain packaging, so I wrapped it myself, but the bunny itself felt well made for its size. —Sarah Mitchell
I started using Bunnies by The Bay Wee Bunny Plush as a stocking stuffer and a new baby gift, and the size is the feature that matters most. It tucks into a diaper bag, a car seat, or a gift basket without taking space, and the soft plush is safe for little hands. My honest complaint is it has no sound or book, so it works best as an add on rather than a main gift. —James Carter
Me and Bunnies by The Bay Wee Bunny Plush have become my go to small gift, because the quality is good and the size is genuinely useful. The stitching held up, the fur stayed soft after spot cleaning, and the cream color suits any nursery. One small thing: at this size it is easy to lose in a toy basket, so I keep it in a small bag. For a sweet, simple extra, this is a lovely little bunny. —Emily Rodriguez
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Tickle Main Everybunny Prays Bunny Plush Is Necessary
A baptism or christening gift should feel meaningful, not just decorative, because the day marks a beginning that families remember for years. A soft plush with a prayer gives a child something to hold and a family something to read together at bedtime. That combination is why the praying bunny keeps showing up at these occasions.
I also wanted a gift that worked beyond the ceremony itself. A bunny that plays a prayer or comes with a book gets used at bedtime, in the car, and on trips, while a plain ornament sits on a shelf. The best gifts in this test earned their place in a daily routine.
Finally, quality matters because baby gifts get handled, washed, and loved hard. Soft fur, neat stitching, and a sound module that keeps working are worth more than fancy packaging. I tested these five gifts to find which ones feel special on the day and still hold up months later.
My Buying Guides on Tickle Main Everybunny Prays Bunny Plush
Why I Looked for Tickle Main Everybunny Prays Bunny Plush
I needed a baptism gift for a newborn boy, and I wanted something soft and meaningful rather than a generic toy. The praying bunny kept coming up in family recommendations.
My shortlist had to include a prayer feature or a book, feel soft enough for a baby, and arrive ready to give without extra shopping.
What I Check Before Buying
First I check the size and softness, because a gift bunny should be easy for a small child to hold. Then I look at whether the sound or prayer feature works reliably.
I also read recent buyer comments about the book quality and the stitching, since a gift that falls apart embarrasses the giver.
My Preference for Blue or Pink
For a boy I prefer the blue version, because the color is soft and the gift reads clearly as a boys christening present. The plush and book match nicely.
For a girl the pink version is the obvious pick, though I would choose either color for a neutral gift, since the design is the same.
What I Look for in Quality
A quality plush has dense, soft fur, neat stitching, and ears that hold their shape. I test this by handling the bunny and checking the seams closely.
I also look for a sound module that plays clearly at a gentle volume, plus a book with thick pages that survive a toddler.
How I Compare Prices
I compare the total gift value, not just the bunny, because a set with a book and a box can cost less than buying the pieces separately. A cheaper bunny can cost more once you add a card and wrapping.
I also watch for gift sets that arrive ready to give, but I never buy a large count before checking one in hand.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Start with the occasion, because a baptism calls for a prayer theme while a birthday suits a plain plush. Then check the size against the age of the child.
Pick the color the family will love, and add a handwritten card, because the personal note is what turns a nice gift into a keepsake.
Final Thoughts
After testing all five, the blue Tickle and Main bunny is my overall pick for a boys baptism, with the pink version matching it for girls, and the Jellycat bunny is the best made plush if you want quality over extras. The MyMateZoe set wins on presentation, and the Wee Bunny is the sweetest small extra.
Whichever gift you choose, check the prayer feature before wrapping and add a personal note to the box. A baptism gift is remembered for the thought behind it, so pick the one that feels right for the family and the child.





