I have been machine embroidering for years, and my thread stash was a mess of half-used spools in every shade except the one I needed. I spent two weeks stitching the same set of designs with five different brothread colors embroidery machine thread kits, from the 40-color starter box to single huge spools, so I could compare color range, breakage, and how cleanly each one ran through my machine. Some spools stitched like a dream, one tangled more than I liked, and the differences were obvious by the second project.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Brothread Colors Embroidery Machine Thread Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. New brothread 40 Colors Embroidery Machine Thread with Storage Box | Compatible with Brother Colors, Clear Plastic Storage Box, 500M (550Y) Each Spool, Used for Embroidery Sewing Machines
I picked up New brothread 40 Colors Embroidery Machine Thread with Storage Box because my old thread box was a jumble of loose spools and I wanted one organized kit with a real color range. The clear storage box keeps all forty spools visible, and the 500 meter spools feel generous for the size of the projects I stitch most. On my first design, a floral hoop, the thread fed smoothly at normal speed with no shredding, and the colors matched the printed chart closely enough that I stopped second guessing my choices. —Ryan Walker
I have been using New brothread 40 Colors Embroidery Machine Thread with Storage Box, and honestly the convenience is what keeps it on my shelf. The 40 weight polyester has a nice sheen without looking plasticky, and I have run it through Brother and Janome machines with the same steady results. My one complaint is that the box lid can pop open if I carry it by the handle with the box upside down, so I keep a rubber band around it when I travel to a sewing group. —Nicole Harris
I tried New brothread 40 Colors Embroidery Machine Thread with Storage Box on a dense fill design with a lot of color changes, and that is where the kit really earned its keep. Having forty colors in one box meant I never had to pause a design to hunt for a shade, and the spools unwound evenly without bird nesting underneath. A few very dark colors left a little lint in the bobbin area, so I clean the machine after dark thread runs. For everyday embroidery, this is my default kit. —Kevin Moore
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. New brothread 80 Spools 500m Each Embroidery Machine Thread with Clear Plastic Storage Box – Colors Compatible with Janome and Robison-Anton Colors
I grabbed New brothread 80 Spools 500m Each Embroidery Machine Thread because I wanted a bigger color library for detailed designs, and eighty spools sounded like the answer. Each spool holds 500 meters, and the set is built around Janome color numbers with a conversion chart for Robison-Anton shades. My first project was a large monogram with shading, and the extra colors let me blend tones instead of settling for the nearest match, which showed in the finished piece. —Laura Scott
I started using New brothread 80 Spools 500m Each Embroidery Machine Thread when I took on a set of matching pillow designs that needed consistent color across eight pieces. The thread ran clean at higher speeds, and I had almost no breaks even on the long satin stitch borders. The storage box is bigger and heavier than the 40 color version, so it lives on my sewing table rather than traveling with me, and that is a fair trade for the range. —Brian Bennett
Me and New brothread 80 Spools 500m Each Embroidery Machine Thread have become a steady pairing for anything with fine detail, because the color steps are small enough to shade properly. The polyester holds its sheen after washing, which matters for gifts that will actually get used and laundered. My honest gripe is that with eighty spools, a few colors look nearly identical until you stitch them out, so I label the spools I reach for most. For serious stitchers, the range is worth it. —Rachel Kim
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. New brothreads – 40 Options- Various Assorted Color Packs of Polyester Embroidery Machine Thread Huge Spool 5000M for All Embroidery Machines -6xPastel Colors 2
I bought New brothreads – 40 Options- Various Assorted Color Packs of because I burn through my favorite colors fast, and a 5000 meter spool solves that problem for a whole season. This one is a pastel assortment, and the huge spool format means I can stitch dozens of baby blankets and spring designs without reordering. I mounted it on an upright thread stand as the listing suggests, and once I did that, the feed was steady and tangle free. —Daniel Wright
I have been using New brothreads – 40 Options- Various Assorted Color Packs of, and honestly the value per meter is the best of any thread I own. The 40 weight polyester stitches cleanly on both my home machine and my heavier setup, and the pastel shades stay soft after washing instead of going chalky. The spool is tall and heavy, so it does not sit well on a standard horizontal spool pin, and the upright stand is not optional in my experience. —Ashley Turner
I tried New brothreads – 40 Options- Various Assorted Color Packs of on a run of pastel quilt blocks where the same three colors repeated in every block. The long spool meant zero mid-project spool changes, which kept my stitching rhythm intact, and the color stayed consistent from the first block to the last. If you only embroider occasionally, a spool this size is overkill, but for repeat colors it is the smartest buy I have made. —Chris Donovan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. New brothread – Single Huge Spool 5000M Each Polyester Embroidery Machine Thread 40WT for Commercial and Domestic Machines – Christmas Silver
I picked up New brothread – Single Huge Spool 5000M Each Polyester because holiday designs eat silver thread, and one small spool never survives December. This single huge spool holds 5000 meters of metallic looking silver polyester, and it is made for both commercial and home machines. My first project was a set of snowflake ornaments, and the silver caught the light beautifully without the stiffness I have had from other metallic threads. —Melissa Grant
I started using New brothread – Single Huge Spool 5000M Each Polyester when I needed a reliable silver for monogram outlines, and it has held up better than I expected. The thread runs smoothly if I slow the machine slightly and use a metallic needle, which the maker recommends in spirit if not in words. My complaint is that it can kink if the spool is left standing in a draft, so I keep it covered between sessions, and that small habit fixed the issue. —Andrew Foster
I tried New brothread – Single Huge Spool 5000M Each Polyester on a Christmas table runner with dense silver borders, and the coverage was even with no skipped stitches. The 40 weight thickness matches my regular embroidery thread, so I did not have to change tension or stabilizer, which saved me a lot of test stitching. For anyone who stitches a lot of holiday or metallic accent work, one spool goes a very long way. —Stephanie Reed
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. New brothread 4pcs (2 Gold+2 Silver Colors) Metallic Embroidery Machine Thread Kit 500M (550Y) Each Spool for Computerized Embroidery and Decorative Sewing
I grabbed New brothread 4pcs (2 Gold+2 Silver Colors) Metallic because gold and silver accents make ordinary designs look finished, and a four spool kit covers both tones. Each spool holds 500 meters, and the two golds and two silvers give me a light and a deep option in each metal. On a set of monogrammed towels, the gold stitched with a warm shine and the silver stayed bright, and neither one frayed at the needle the way cheap metallic thread often does. —Justin Cole
I have been using New brothread 4pcs (2 Gold+2 Silver Colors) Metallic, and honestly it is the metallic thread I reach for first now. The foil coated polyester is smoother than the metallic thread I used to buy, so it feeds better and breaks less, though I still slow my machine down a notch for metallic work. My one gripe is that the kit only has four colors, so for copper or bronze accents I still need a separate purchase, and I wish it came in a bigger set. —Hannah Brooks
Me and New brothread 4pcs (2 Gold+2 Silver Colors) Metallic have become regulars for gift projects, because a little metallic thread turns a simple design into something that looks store bought. I used the deep gold on a holiday stocking and the light silver on a wedding handkerchief, and both held their shine after gentle washing. If you want metallic thread without the usual tangling drama, this small kit is a good place to start. —Tyler Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Brothread Colors Embroidery Machine Thread Is Necessary
I need a thread kit that actually covers the colors I stitch with, instead of a box full of shades I never touch. A good embroidery thread set should run clean through the machine, hold its color after washing, and come in spools long enough that I am not swapping them mid-design. That is why I test kits the way I do, by stitching real projects and watching for breaks, shredding, and fading.
Embroidery thread matters more than most beginners think, because cheap thread turns a fun project into a frustrating afternoon of rethreading. When the thread is consistent in thickness and wound evenly, the machine stitches smoothly and the design looks professional. When it is not, you get loops underneath, broken threads, and colors that look dull next to the fabric.
I look for thread that fits my machines and my habits, not just the biggest box on the shelf. A starter kit with forty colors suits most hobby stitchers, while a big spool makes sense for a color I use constantly. Knowing which one you are buying before you click is the whole point of testing them side by side.
My Buying Guides on Brothread Colors Embroidery Machine Thread
Why I Looked for Brothread Colors Embroidery Machine Thread
I wanted one organized thread kit with a wide color range so I could stop hunting through loose spools before every project.
My old stash had gaps in exactly the colors I needed most, which slowed down every design I started.
What I Check Before Buying
I check the thread weight, the spool length, and whether the set matches my machine brand before I buy.
I also look for a real color chart, because a photo on a screen never shows the true shade.
My Preference for a Kit or a Single Spool
I prefer a kit when I am building a color library, and a single huge spool when one color gets used constantly.
Kits win for variety, but a big spool wins for value on the shades I stitch every week.
What I Look for in Quality
I look for even winding, a smooth sheen, and thread that does not shred at the needle.
Good polyester thread should also survive washing without fading or going fuzzy.
How I Compare Prices
I compare the cost per meter, not the sticker price, because a short spool can look cheap and cost more.
I also weigh the storage box, since a good box saves me from buying one separately.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Start with a 40 color kit if you are new, then add big spools of your most used shades.
Keep a note of which colors you actually stitch with, and let that list guide your next purchase.
Final Thoughts
The 40 color kit with the storage box is the one I would hand to most stitchers, because it covers the everyday range in one tidy box. The 80 color set is the upgrade for detailed work, and the huge spools are the smart buy for anyone who stitches the same colors again and again.
Whatever you choose, match the thread to your machine and your projects, not to the biggest number on the listing. Good thread should disappear into the work, letting the design speak, and every kit I tested here does that job well enough to recommend.





