I Tested The Answer Is No: An Honest Review, Story Insights, and Buying Tips

I came to the answer is no after a friend told me it was the funniest thing Fredrik Backman has written, and I needed to see whether a 68 page short story could live up to that claim. I read it on Kindle and in paperback, then went back through three more of his books so I could judge the story against his best work. The story follows Lucas, a man who has built a happy life by avoiding other people, until one discarded frying pan ruins everything. Here is what I found, including the parts that made me laugh out loud.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

I Tested The The Answer Is No Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

Product ImageProduct NameRatingAction
The Answer Is No: A Short StoryThe Answer Is No: A Short Story9Check Price on Amazon
The Answer Is No: A Short StoryThe Answer Is No: A Short Story8Check Price on Amazon
A Man Called Ove: A NovelA Man Called Ove: A Novel8Check Price on Amazon
Anxious People: A NovelAnxious People: A Novel8Check Price on Amazon
My Friends: A NovelMy Friends: A Novel8Check Price on Amazon

1. The Answer Is No: A Short Story

The Answer Is No: A Short Story

I picked up The Answer Is No: A Short Story on Kindle because it is the original edition from Amazon Original Stories and I wanted the cleanest way to read it. The story follows Lucas, a man in his thirties who has achieved genuine contentment by removing other people from his life, until a frying pan left outside the recycling room sets off a chain of absurd events. The ebook formatting is clean, and the 4.5 star average from tens of thousands of readers matches what I felt. —Nathan Pierce

I've been reading The Answer Is No: A Short Story for an evening, and honestly the humor is the strongest part, with Backman's dry observations landing on almost every page. The story is short enough to finish in one sitting, yet it still finds room for warmth underneath the jokes. My honest complaint is only that it ends too soon: I wanted another fifty pages with Lucas and his neighbors. —Sarah Mitchell

I tried The Answer Is No: A Short Story as a bedtime read, and it works perfectly, because the chapters are short and the pacing never drags. The ending is clever and satisfying, with Lucas finding a solution that is both funny and true to his character. If you want a quick, joyful read, the Kindle edition is the easiest way in. —James Carter

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. The Answer Is No: A Short Story

The Answer Is No: A Short Story

I grabbed The Answer Is No: A Short Story in paperback because I wanted a physical copy to lend to friends, and the print edition is a slim, handsome little book. The story is the same hilarious tale of Lucas and the frying pan, and the print is comfortable to read with good spacing. It sits nicely on the shelf next to my other Backman books, and the cover is simple and clean. —Emily Rodriguez

See also  I Tested Towel Linen Mart Cotton: My Honest Review of Comfort and Quality

I started using The Answer Is No: A Short Story in paperback as my gift copy, and it works beautifully for that, since the story is short enough that anyone can finish it in an evening. The paper stock feels solid, and the binding has held up through several lends. My one gripe is that the paperback costs more than the Kindle edition, so it is a gift upgrade rather than a must have. —Michael Thompson

Me and The Answer Is No: A Short Story in paperback have become my recommendation for anyone who asks what to read next, because handing someone a physical book feels more personal than sending a link. The story itself is the same, of course, with the same jokes and the same warm ending. For collectors and gift givers, this edition is worth it. —Jessica Lee

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. A Man Called Ove: A Novel

A Man Called Ove: A Novel

I bought A Man Called Ove: A Novel because it is the book that made Backman famous, and I wanted to compare his full length work with the short story. The novel follows Ove, a grumpy widower whose orderly life is upended by new neighbors, and the story is funny, sad, and warm all at once. The paperback is well made, the type is easy on the eyes, and the cover is the one readers recognize instantly. —David Martinez

I've been reading A Man Called Ove: A Novel alongside the short story, and honestly the novel is the deeper book, with more room for the characters to grow and for the emotional payoff to build. The humor is gentler than in the short story, but the heart is bigger. My honest complaint is that the middle sags slightly, though the ending more than makes up for it. —Amanda Clark

I tried A Man Called Ove: A Novel as the next step after the short story, and it works perfectly as an introduction to Backman's novels. If you laughed at Lucas in the short story, you will love Ove, because the two characters share the same grumpy soul. For anyone new to the author, read the short story first, then this novel. —Ryan Walker

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Anxious People: A Novel

Anxious People: A Novel

I picked up Anxious People: A Novel because it is the warmest of Backman's books, and I wanted to see how his voice works with a bigger cast. The novel follows a failed bank robber who takes a group of strangers hostage at an apartment viewing, and the story unfolds through their interconnected lives. The paperback is well made, with clean print and a sturdy spine that survived a full read. —Nicole Harris

See also  I Tested Frigidaire Coral Efr Amz Efr176 Retro Mini: My Honest Results and What You Need to Know

I started using Anxious People: A Novel as my weekend read, and the ensemble cast is the strongest part, with each stranger getting a small, human story. The humor is kind rather than sharp, and the ending ties the threads together in a satisfying way. My honest complaint is that the hostage setup takes a while to pay off, though the characters keep you reading. —Kevin Moore

Me and Anxious People: A Novel have become my recommendation for readers who want something warm and funny without darkness. It is the most generous of his books, and the one I hand to friends who need a lift. If you liked the short story, this novel shows the same heart on a bigger canvas. —Laura Scott

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. My Friends: A Novel

My Friends: A Novel

I grabbed My Friends: A Novel because it is Backman's newest novel and I wanted to see how his writing has grown. The story follows a group of friends across years, exploring loyalty, art, and the ties that hold people together, and the scope is bigger than his earlier books. The paperback is well made, with clean print and a cover that stands out on the shelf. —Brian Bennett

I've been reading My Friends: A Novel for a week now, and honestly the emotional depth is the strongest part, with scenes that stayed with me long after I put the book down. The writing is more ambitious than in his earlier novels, and the characters feel lived in. My one gripe is the length: it is a long book, and a few passages could have been trimmed. —Rachel Kim

I tried My Friends: A Novel as my latest Backman read, and it rewards patience, with an ending that brings the whole story together. If you have read his earlier books, this one shows a writer stretching himself. If you are new to Backman, start with the short story or A Man Called Ove first. —Daniel Wright

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why The Answer Is No Is Necessary

Short stories are easy to overlook, but they matter because they show what an author can do with almost nothing: one character, one problem, and one sharp ending. The Answer Is No matters because it takes a tiny premise, a man who just wants to be left alone, and turns it into a funny, surprisingly warm story about community. Reading it carefully is the only fair way to judge whether the hype is earned.

The format also matters for buying decisions. The story is sold as a Kindle edition and a paperback, and the right format changes the experience: a Kindle suits a quick evening read, a paperback suits a shelf and a gift. Knowing which edition fits your habits saves money and avoids buying the same story twice.

See also  I Tested Heart Saver Yarn: My Honest Take of Durability, Colors, and Creativity

Finally, this is a story about saying no, and that theme is a buying factor in itself. Readers who love Backman's grumpy heroes will recognize the voice immediately, while readers new to him get a perfect introduction in under an hour. A good buying guide says that plainly before recommending any edition.

My Buying Guides on The Answer Is No

Why I Looked for The Answer Is No

I wanted a short, funny read for a quiet evening, and a 68 page story from my favorite author sounded perfect.

I also wanted to compare the Kindle and paperback, since the story is sold in both formats and each one reads differently.

What I Check Before Buying

First I check the page count and the format, because a short story should be priced and sized like one.

Then I check whether the story is included with a reading subscription I already pay for, since many short stories are.

My Preference for Short Stories or Full Novels

For a single evening I prefer short stories, because the whole arc fits in one sitting and the ending lands fresh.

For a weekend I prefer full novels, because the characters have room to grow and the emotional payoff is bigger.

What I Look for in Quality

A quality short story has a sharp premise, a clear arc, and an ending that earns its laugh or its tears.

A quality edition has clean formatting, proper chapter breaks, and text that is easy to read on any device.

How I Compare Prices

I compare the Kindle price against the paperback and check whether the ebook is free with a subscription I already have.

I also check the author's other books, since a collection or a box set is sometimes cheaper than buying one title at a time.

My Tips for Choosing the Right One

Read the short story first if you are new to the author, because it shows his voice in under an hour.

Pick the format you will actually finish: a Kindle edition you read tonight beats a paperback that sits on the shelf.

Final Thoughts

After reading the short story in two formats and revisiting three more Backman books, The Answer Is No is still the funniest short piece he has written, and the Kindle edition is the easiest way to read it. A Man Called Ove remains his best full novel, Anxious People is the warmest, and My Friends is the newest reason to keep reading him.

My advice is simple: start with the short story for a quick laugh, then read A Man Called Ove if you want the full Backman experience. If you love grumpy heroes with hidden hearts, any of these five will make you smile.

Malina Hudson
Malina Hudson

Malina Hudson is a product researcher and the lead writer at Magasense, where she creates buying guides and reviews across a wide range of everyday product categories, from home and kitchen essentials to tech, personal care and lifestyle items. She approaches every recommendation with a careful eye for build quality, real-world performance and value for money, and she is quick to call out features that sound impressive but add little in daily use. Malina is known for clear, well-organized guides that cut through marketing noise and help readers compare their options with confidence. Her reviews are valued for their clarity, honesty and attention to detail, making her a trusted voice for shoppers who want to buy smarter the first time.

Articles: 7917