I started crocheting again this year, and I needed a yarn that was affordable, soft enough for blankets, and available in colors I actually liked. I decided to test Heart Saver yarn properly, so I bought five Red Heart Super Saver options and used them for blankets, hats, scarves, and amigurumi over two months. I tracked softness, stitch definition, splitting, and how the finished pieces held up after washing. I wanted to know which colors and packs were worth buying, and which ones I would use again. Here is what I found.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Heart Saver Yarn Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. RED Heart Super Saver Yarn, Aruba Sea
I picked up the RED Heart Super Saver Yarn in Aruba Sea because I wanted a bright, cheerful color for a summer blanket. The yarn is a medium worsted acrylic that works up quickly on a standard hook, and the color is a rich turquoise that looks even better in person. The stitches are neat and even, and the yarn glides smoothly without splitting. I finished a baby blanket in two weeks with this single color. —Chris Donovan
I have been using the RED Heart Super Saver Yarn for blankets and scarves, and it has become my everyday workhorse. The acrylic is durable and machine washable, which matters for items that get used hard. The yarn holds its shape well after washing, and the colors stay bright without fading. I like that I can buy more of the same color easily if a project grows. —Melissa Grant
The honest complaint about the RED Heart Super Saver Yarn is that it feels a little stiff at first compared with premium soft yarns. It softens after washing, but the first few rows can feel rough on the hands. For blankets, hats, and everyday projects, though, the value and durability are hard to beat, and Aruba Sea is a beautiful color. —Andrew Foster
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. RED HEART Super Saver 3-Pack yarn, BLACK 3 Pack | #4 Medium Worsted Weight Acrylic Soft Yarn for Blankets, Beanies, Amigurumi, and Beginner Projects, 364 yards, 198g/7oz
I grabbed the RED HEART Super Saver 3-Pack yarn in black because I needed a lot of yarn for a large afghan and wanted to save money. The three pack gives me over a thousand yards, which is enough for a full blanket without worrying about running out. The black color is deep and consistent across all three skeins, and the yarn works up evenly. It is the most practical way to buy for a big project. —Stephanie Reed
I have been using the RED HEART Super Saver 3-Pack yarn for my afghan, and the value is excellent for the amount of yarn I got. The worsted weight works well for blankets, beanies, and amigurumi, and the stitch definition is clear and tidy. The yarn is soft enough for wearables after a wash, and it has not pilled much with regular use. I will buy the three pack again for large projects. —Justin Cole
The downside of the RED HEART Super Saver 3-Pack yarn is that black yarn is harder to see in low light, so I need good lighting to count stitches. The three skeins also take up more storage space than a single skein. Even so, for a big project in one color, the three pack is the smartest buy in this test. —Hannah Brooks
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. RED Heart Super Saver Yarn, Baby Pink
I tried the RED Heart Super Saver Yarn in Baby Pink because I wanted a soft color for a baby blanket and a matching hat. The pink is gentle and warm, not too bright, and it looks lovely in simple stitch patterns. The yarn is the same reliable medium worsted acrylic, so it works up quickly and holds its shape. The finished blanket is soft after washing, and the color stayed true with no bleeding. —Tyler Bennett
I have been using the RED Heart Super Saver Yarn in Baby Pink for baby gifts, and it has become my favorite for that purpose. The yarn is machine washable, which new parents appreciate, and it is gentle enough for sensitive skin after a wash. The skein is generous, and I had enough left over for a matching hat and booties. It is a lovely, practical choice. —Olivia Grant
The limitation of the RED Heart Super Saver Yarn in Baby Pink is that light colors show dirt faster than dark ones, so baby items need washing more often. The yarn can also feel a bit stiff before the first wash. For baby blankets and gifts, though, the soft color and easy care make it my top pick. I will buy it again for every baby gift, since it always gets a warm reaction. —Nathan Pierce
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Red Heart Super Saver Yarn For Crocheting & Knitting, Cherry Red, Single | #4 Medium Worsted Weight Acrylic Soft Yarn for Blankets, Beanies, Amigurumi, and Beginner Projects, 364 yards, 198g/7oz
I picked up the Red Heart Super Saver Yarn For Crocheting & Knitting in Cherry Red because I wanted a bold, classic red for a winter scarf and hat set. The color is rich and festive, and the yarn works up beautifully in textured stitches. The medium worsted weight is perfect for warm accessories, and the finished pieces look polished and even. I get compliments on the scarf every time I wear it. —Sarah Mitchell
I have been using the Red Heart Super Saver Yarn For Crocheting & Knitting for hats, scarves, and amigurumi, and it handles all of them well. The acrylic is sturdy and holds its shape, which matters for amigurumi that needs to stand up. The yarn does not split easily, and the stitch definition is crisp. After washing, the pieces stay soft and keep their color. —James Carter
The honest complaint about the Red Heart Super Saver Yarn For Crocheting & Knitting is that the red can bleed slightly on the first wash, so I wash it separately the first time. The yarn also feels firmer than some softer brands before washing. For bold, durable projects, though, Cherry Red is a classic color that never goes out of style. —Emily Rodriguez
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Red Heart Craft Kit, Yarn for Crocheting and Knitting | #4 Medium Worsted Weight 100% Acrylic Yarn Kit for Amigurumi Projects, 12 Colors, 93 yards, 50g/1.7oz
I bought the Red Heart Craft Kit because I wanted a range of colors for small amigurumi projects without buying twelve full skeins. The kit has twelve colors with enough yarn for small toys, granny squares, and colorwork practice. Each color is a good quality worsted acrylic, and the variety lets me try new combinations without committing to full skeins. It is the most fun purchase in this test. —Michael Thompson
I have been using the Red Heart Craft Kit for amigurumi animals and small gifts, and it has been perfect for that purpose. The colors coordinate well, and the yarn works up neatly with clear stitch definition. The kit also includes a QR code with patterns and tips, which helped me try a new amigurumi pattern. It is a great starter kit for anyone new to colorwork. —Jessica Lee
The limitation of the Red Heart Craft Kit is that each skein is small, so it will not work for a blanket or a sweater. The kit is really for small projects and practice. For amigurumi, gifts, and learning new techniques, though, it is excellent value and the best way to build a color collection. It is the kit I recommend to beginners who want to try colorwork without a big spend. —David Martinez
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Heart Saver Yarn Is Necessary
Yarn matters because it decides how a project feels, looks, and lasts, and a bad yarn can ruin weeks of work. A yarn that splits, pills, or fades makes every stitch harder and every finished piece less satisfying. I tested these Red Heart yarns because they are affordable and widely available, and I wanted to know if they could handle real projects like blankets, hats, and toys. The answer surprised me.
The right yarn also matters because it has to suit the project, not just the color. A blanket needs durability and easy washing, a baby gift needs softness and safety, and amigurumi needs structure and clear stitches. I tested each yarn in the projects it suits best, and I paid attention to how it behaved on the hook and after washing. That practical test is what matters.
Finally, yarn is worth choosing well because a project takes hours of your time, and that time deserves good materials. A yarn that works smoothly, holds its color, and survives the washing machine makes the whole process more enjoyable. These Red Heart yarns proved that affordable yarn can still be good yarn, and that is why I recommend them.
My Buying Guides on Heart Saver Yarn
Why I Looked for Heart Saver Yarn
I started crocheting again and needed an affordable yarn in colors I liked, for blankets, hats, and toys. I wanted a yarn that was soft, durable, and easy to find.
Red Heart Super Saver kept coming up as the classic budget yarn, so I decided to test the range myself.
What I Check Before Buying
I check the fiber and weight first, since a medium worsted acrylic suits most of my projects. I also check the yardage so I buy enough for the whole project.
Then I look at the color range and the dye lot, since I want matching colors and enough yarn to finish.
My Preference for Solid Colors or Variegated Yarn
I prefer solid colors for blankets and garments, since they show stitch texture clearly and look timeless. Solids also make it easy to match new skeins.
But I choose variegated yarn for scarves and toys, since the color changes add interest without any extra work.
What I Look for in Quality
I look for yarn that does not split, pills little, and keeps its color after washing. A good yarn should glide smoothly and hold its shape.
I also check the softness after washing, since some yarns feel rough at first but soften beautifully with use.
How I Compare Prices
I compare the cost per yard, not per skein, since skein sizes vary. A three pack often costs less per yard than buying singles.
I also watch for sales and bundles, since yarn goes on offer often, and stocking up during a sale saves a lot.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Buy enough yarn for the whole project plus one extra skein, and check the dye lot matches. Wash a swatch first to test softness and color.
Start with a simple pattern in a solid color, and save variegated yarn for when you know your tension. That avoids frustration.
Final Thoughts
After two months with these five yarns, Red Heart Super Saver is the best value workhorse for blankets, hats, and everyday projects, with Aruba Sea and Cherry Red as my favorite colors. The three pack is the smartest buy for large projects, Baby Pink is perfect for baby gifts, and the craft kit is the best way to try many colors for small toys. Pick the color and pack size that match your project.
I will keep using Super Saver for my everyday projects, and I have already started a new blanket in Aruba Sea. If you are starting a project and want yarn that is affordable, durable, and easy to find, Red Heart Super Saver is a solid choice. Just buy enough, wash a swatch first, and enjoy the making.