I picked up my first Murdle book on a rainy weekend, expecting a quick puzzle or two before bed, and instead I lost two hours to a single mystery. I have since worked through all three volumes plus the Spanish editions, testing how the difficulty climbs, whether the stories stay fresh, and which volume is the best place to start. Some puzzles took me ten minutes and some took me all evening. Here is what I found across the whole series. I also compared the Spanish editions, which doubled as surprisingly good language practice while I solved.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Murdle Volume Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Murdle: Volume 1
I picked up Murdle: Volume 1 because I wanted a logic puzzle book that was more than crosswords, and the promise of 100 elementary to impossible mysteries sounded like a real challenge. The book teaches you the deduction grid as you go, so the early puzzles feel easy and the later ones genuinely test you. I solved the first few in minutes, then hit one that kept me up past midnight, and that ramp is exactly what a puzzle book should do. —Ashley Turner
I started using Murdle: Volume 1 as my evening wind down, and honestly the characters and silly murder plots are half the fun. Each mystery gives you clues about who did it, where, and with what, and the grid system lets you track every deduction without guessing. My one complaint is that a few of the early puzzles are so easy they feel like tutorials, but they build the skills you need for the hard ones at the back. —Chris Donovan
Me and Murdle: Volume 1 have become a regular travel companion, because one puzzle fits neatly into a train ride or a waiting room. The paperback is light enough to carry, and I like that I can work a puzzle with a pencil and erase my mistakes. If you have never tried a logic puzzle book, this first volume is the perfect place to start, and it hooked me on the whole series. —Melissa Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Murdle: Volume 2
I grabbed Murdle: Volume 2 because the first book left me wanting harder puzzles, and this volume delivers exactly that. The mysteries start where volume one left off, with more suspects, trickier clues, and grids that demand careful tracking. I found myself using the full grid on nearly every puzzle, and the satisfaction of cracking a hard one after an hour of work is something a crossword never gave me. —Andrew Foster
I have been using Murdle: Volume 2 on quiet evenings, and honestly the story writing is sharper than the first book. The suspects are funnier, the settings are more varied, and the clues are fair, which matters because nothing is more annoying than a puzzle you cannot solve from the information given. My one complaint is that the difficulty jumps quickly, so new solvers should finish volume one first. —Stephanie Reed
I tried Murdle: Volume 2 with a friend, taking turns reading clues aloud and debating suspects, and it works surprisingly well as a shared puzzle. The book is best solved alone with a pencil, but the discussion version is a fun change. For anyone who finished volume one and wants a real step up, this is the volume to buy next, and it kept me busy for weeks. —Justin Cole
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Murdle: Volume 3
I bought Murdle: Volume 3 because I had finished the first two books and wanted the hardest puzzles in the series. This volume is the toughest of the three, with longer clue lists, more suspects, and mysteries that genuinely made me put the book down and think. Some puzzles took me two sittings, and I had to erase and restart my grid more than once, which is exactly the challenge I was looking for. —Hannah Brooks
I started using Murdle: Volume 3 as a weekend ritual, and honestly the payoff is bigger here than in the earlier books. The plots are more elaborate, the red herrings are better hidden, and solving one feels like a real achievement. My one complaint is that a few puzzles assume you remember tricks from the earlier volumes, so this is not a good first book for a brand new solver. —Tyler Bennett
I tried Murdle: Volume 3 on a long flight, and it kept me occupied for the entire trip without once reaching for my phone. The book is the same handy size as the others, and the puzzles are meaty enough to fill a whole afternoon. For series fans who want the hardest Murdle yet, this volume delivers, and it is the one I reach for when I want a serious puzzle night. —Olivia Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Murdle: Más crímenes por resolver / Murdle Volume 2: 100 Elementary to Impossible Mysteries to Solve… (Spanish Edition)
I picked up Murdle: Más crímenes por resolver / Murdle Volume 2: 100 because I wanted to practice my Spanish with something fun, and a puzzle book turned out to be perfect. The mysteries are the same clever volume two puzzles, but solving them in Spanish forced me to slow down and read every clue carefully. My Spanish improved noticeably, and the puzzles were just as satisfying as the English edition I had already finished. —Nathan Pierce
I have been using Murdle: Más crímenes por resolver / Murdle Volume 2: 100 as a study break, and honestly it works better as a language tool than most textbooks. The vocabulary repeats across puzzles, so words like suspect and weapon become familiar fast, and the logic grid keeps you honest. My one complaint is that some of the wordplay does not translate perfectly, so a couple of clues felt slightly awkward in Spanish. —Sarah Mitchell
Me and Murdle: Más crímenes por resolver / Murdle Volume 2: 100 have become my Sunday morning routine, because one puzzle in Spanish wakes up my brain better than coffee. The book is a great gift for a Spanish speaker who likes puzzles, and it is also a clever way for a learner to practice. If you read Spanish and like mysteries, this edition is a delight. —James Carter
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Murdle: Resuelve el crimen: 100 acertijos endiablados para solucionar usando la lógica y el poder de la deducción / Murdle Volume 1: 100 Elementary to … Mysteries to Solve… (Spanish Edition)
I grabbed Murdle: Resuelve el crimen: 100 acertijos endiablados para because it is the Spanish edition of the first volume, and I wanted the easiest Murdle puzzles in Spanish for a friend who is learning the language. The 100 mysteries use logic and deduction, and the early puzzles are gentle enough for a learner to follow while still feeling like real detective work. My friend solved her first puzzle in one sitting and was hooked. —Emily Rodriguez
I started using Murdle: Resuelve el crimen: 100 acertijos endiablados para myself as well, and honestly the Spanish text is clear and well translated. The clue structure works the same as the English book, and the grid system needs no translation at all, which makes it friendly for learners at many levels. My one complaint is that the cover and title are long and busy, but the puzzles inside are clean and well organized. —Michael Thompson
I tried Murdle: Resuelve el crimen: 100 acertijos endiablados para as a gift, and it was the best received book I gave this year. It works for native Spanish speakers who love puzzles and for learners who want reading practice that feels like play. If you want the Murdle experience in Spanish, start here, because the gentle ramp makes it the friendliest edition in the whole series. —Jessica Lee
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Murdle Volume Is Necessary
Murdle books are necessary because they give your brain a real workout without a screen, and that is rare in a world of short videos and quick scrolling. Each mystery forces you to hold several clues in your head, test them against each other, and eliminate suspects one by one. That kind of slow, careful thinking is a skill that fades when you never practice it, and a puzzle book is the most enjoyable way to keep it sharp.
These books are also worth owning because they are endlessly replayable as gifts and shared puzzles. I have lent my copies to friends, solved puzzles aloud with family, and still gone back to rework the hardest ones months later. A book that gives you a hundred puzzles for the price of a lunch is hard to beat, and it never needs charging or an internet connection.
Finally, Murdle is useful because it teaches logic in a way that feels like play instead of school. The grid system is a genuine reasoning tool, and after a few puzzles you start applying the same elimination thinking to everyday problems. That is the mark of a good puzzle book: it entertains you for hours and quietly makes you a sharper thinker at the same time.
My Buying Guides on Murdle Volume
Why I Looked for Murdle Volume
I was tired of puzzles that took thirty seconds and wanted a book that would challenge me for weeks.
My shortlist had to have a real difficulty curve, fair clues, and enough puzzles to last a month.
What I Check Before Buying
First I check the puzzle count and difficulty range, because a book of easy puzzles gets boring fast.
I also check whether the clues are fair and solvable, since an unfair puzzle is just frustrating.
My Preference for Paperback or Ebook
For logic puzzles I prefer paperback, because penciling in a grid and erasing mistakes is part of the fun.
I still read novels on a screen, but a puzzle book belongs on paper in my hands.
What I Look for in Quality
A quality puzzle book has clear grids, fair clues, and a difficulty curve that builds instead of jumping.
I also look for fun writing, because a mystery with dull suspects is a chore to read.
How I Compare Prices
I compare cost per puzzle, not the cover price, since a hundred puzzles in one book is a bargain.
I also factor in replay value, because a hard puzzle you revisit is worth more than an easy one.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Start with volume one even if you are confident, because the later books assume you know the tricks.
Buy the Spanish edition if you read Spanish or want fun language practice.
Final Thoughts
After working through all three volumes and both Spanish editions, Murdle is the best logic puzzle series I have found, because the difficulty curve is fair, the writing is funny, and the puzzles respect your intelligence. Volume one is the perfect start, volume two is the sweet spot for most solvers, and volume three is the serious challenge. The Spanish editions are a bonus for readers and learners alike, and they prove the format works in any language.
My advice is simple: start with volume one, buy a good pencil, and give yourself a quiet hour to solve your first mystery. Do not rush it, and do not peek at the answers, because the satisfaction comes from the deduction itself. If you finish the first book and want more, the rest of the series is waiting, and it only gets better.