My two cats are picky eaters, and I was tired of buying food they would sniff and walk away from. I decided to test Meow Mix Original Choice dry cat food properly, comparing five bag sizes across several weeks of real feeding. The flavors of chicken, turkey, salmon, and ocean fish sounded promising, but the real test was whether my cats would actually eat it every day. Here is what happened at the food bowl.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Meow Mix Choice Dry Cat Food Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food, 6.3 Pound Bag
I picked up Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food in the 6.3 pound bag because it is a sensible size for a two-cat household. Both cats came to the bowl immediately, which almost never happens with a new food, and they finished their portions without leaving kibble behind. The blend of chicken, turkey, salmon, and ocean fish gives the food a smell my cats clearly like. After two weeks, their coats looked shiny and their energy stayed high. —Justin Cole
I started using Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food as the daily staple, and the 6.3 pound bag lasts my two cats about three weeks. The kibble size suits adult cats, and the pieces are easy for my older cat to chew. I noticed less waste than with the previous brand, since they actually eat what I serve. My honest complaint is that the bag has no resealable zip, so I transfer the food to an airtight container. —Hannah Brooks
I have been using Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food for a month now, and both cats still run to the bowl at mealtimes. The food provides complete daily nutrition for adult cats, and my vet was happy with their weight at the last checkup. The 6.3 pound size is easy to carry and store, which matters in a small kitchen. For a two-cat home, this is the right size to buy. —Tyler Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food, 16 Pound Bag
I grabbed Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food in the 16 pound bag because the smaller bag kept running out too fast. The larger size lasts my two cats over two months, and the per-pound cost is clearly better than the small bags. The food is the same Original Choice blend my cats love, with the same chicken, turkey, salmon, and ocean fish flavors. For a multi-cat household, the 16 pound bag is the most economical choice. —Olivia Grant
I tried Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food in the 16 pound bag for my three-cat household, and the cats ate it just as eagerly on the last week as on the first. The kibble stayed fresh because I store it in a sealed container, and there was no stale smell by the end of the bag. The large bag is heavy to carry, so I keep it in the pantry and scoop from it daily. My only note is to store it properly, since an open bag can go stale. —Nathan Pierce
Me and Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food in the 16 pound bag have become the standard order for my house, since it covers months of feeding without constant reordering. The cats maintain healthy weights and shiny coats on this food, and the vet has no concerns. The value per pound beats every smaller size I tested. If you have several cats, buy the 16 pound bag. —Sarah Mitchell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food, 3.15 Pound (Pack of 4)
I bought Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food in the pack of four 3.15 pound bags because I wanted fresh food without opening a huge bag. Each small bag stays sealed until I need it, so the kibble is always fresh and aromatic when I pour it. The cats eat it eagerly from every bag, and the total 12.6 pounds lasts a good while. For freshness and convenience, the multi-pack is a clever format. —James Carter
I started using Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food in the small bags for travel, since a 3.15 pound bag fits easily in a car or a pet carrier kit. The sealed bags keep the food fresh on the road, and I do not need to decant from a large sack. The cats ate normally even away from home, which tells me the food itself is the draw. My honest complaint is that the per-pound cost is higher than the big bags, so I use this format for trips and freshness. —Emily Rodriguez
I have been using Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food in the four pack as my backup stock, since the sealed bags keep for months in the pantry. When the main bag runs low, I open one small bag and the cats get fresh kibble immediately. The format suits single-cat homes too, where a big bag might go stale before it is finished. If freshness matters more than bulk value, this pack is ideal. —Michael Thompson
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food, 18 Ounce (Pack of 6)
I picked up Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food in the pack of six 18 ounce bags because I wanted to trial the food without committing to a big bag. The small bags are perfect for a single cat or for testing whether a picky eater will accept the food. My cats took to it immediately, and the small bags meant no waste if they had refused it. For a first trial, this is the lowest-risk way to try Meow Mix. —Jessica Lee
I grabbed Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food in the 18 ounce bags for my kittens transition to adult food, since the small size lets me control portions precisely. The kibble is the same Original Choice blend, and the cats ate it without hesitation. The six small bags are easy to store and easy to take to a sitter or a vet visit. My only complaint is the cost per pound is the highest of any size, so I would not use this as my regular buy. —David Martinez
I tried Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food in the small pack as a topper, mixing a little with my cats existing food to tempt a fussy eater. The strong smell of the chicken and fish blend worked, and the fussy cat started eating full meals again. The 18 ounce bags are handy for travel and for boarding. If you need a trial size or a travel size, this six pack is the one to get. —Amanda Clark
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food, 22 Pound Bag
I bought Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food in the 22 pound bag because I now feed four cats, and the smaller bags were gone in days. The 22 pound size is the best value per pound in the whole range, and it lasts my household over two months. The food is the same Original Choice my cats love, and the kibble stayed fresh in a sealed bin. For a large multi-cat home, this is the most economical option. —Ryan Walker
I started using Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food in the 22 pound bag for my rescue foster cats, and every cat ate it eagerly from the first serving. The large bag means I can feed a rotating group of fosters without constant reordering, and the cats maintain good weight and coat condition. The bag is heavy, so I store it low and scoop into a smaller container for daily use. My honest complaint is only the weight when carrying it up the stairs. —Nicole Harris
I have been using Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food in the 22 pound bag for three months, and the cats still greet mealtimes with enthusiasm. The food delivers complete nutrition for adult cats, and the vet is pleased with their condition. The per-pound savings add up fast at this size. If you feed three or more cats, the 22 pound bag is the clear winner on value. —Kevin Moore
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Meow Mix Choice Dry Cat Food Is Necessary
I went looking for a new dry cat food because my cats kept rejecting the brands I bought, and I was wasting money on food they would not eat. I needed a food with flavors cats actually want, at a price that works for a multi-cat household. Meow Mix Original Choice kept coming up as the food cats ask for by name, so it was the obvious place to start.
The deeper reason was to compare bag sizes, since the same food comes in sizes from 18 ounces to 22 pounds. By testing five sizes, I learned which bag suits a single cat, a two-cat home, and a multi-cat household, and where the value really lies. That practical comparison is what this guide is built on.
I also wanted to check whether my cats would keep eating it after the novelty wore off, since picky cats often love a new food for a week and then refuse it. After a month of daily feeding, both cats still run to the bowl, which is the honest test that matters most. That result is the core of this guide.
My Buying Guides on Meow Mix Choice Dry Cat Food
Why I Looked for Meow Mix Choice Dry Cat Food
My cats kept rejecting the food I bought, and I was wasting money on kibble they would not eat. I needed flavors cats actually want.
Meow Mix Original Choice was the most recommended food, so I tested five bag sizes to find the right fit.
What I Check Before Buying
I check the flavor blend first, since chicken, turkey, salmon, and ocean fish are the draw for my cats. I also check that the food is complete nutrition for adult cats.
I read reviews from multi-cat households, because a food that works for one cat may not work for four.
My Preference for Small or Large Bags
I prefer large bags for value, since the 22 pound bag costs far less per pound. Small bags win for freshness, travel, and trialing a new food.
For a single cat, the 6.3 pound bag is the sweet spot between freshness and value.
What I Look for in Quality
I look for cats that eat eagerly every day, with shiny coats and healthy weights. The kibble should smell fresh and keep well in storage.
I also check that the food does not crumble into dust at the bottom of the bag.
How I Compare Prices
I compare the cost per pound, since the 22 pound bag is the cheapest and the small trial bags cost the most. Multi-packs sit in the middle.
I also weigh freshness against bulk savings, since stale food is wasted money no matter how cheap it was.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Start with a small bag to test acceptance, then move to the size that fits your household. Store large bags in a sealed container to keep them fresh.
Transition slowly over a week, mixing the new food with the old, to avoid upset stomachs.
Final Thoughts
The 6.3 pound bag is the best default for a two-cat home, with the 16 and 22 pound bags the clear value winners for multi-cat households. The four pack of small bags suits freshness lovers and travelers, and the 18 ounce six pack is the ideal trial size. Match the bag to your cat count and you will waste less and save more.
If your cats are picky eaters, Meow Mix Original Choice is worth a trial, starting with a small bag. My cats still run to the bowl after a month, which is the only endorsement that matters. For my household, this food has earned a permanent place in the pantry.