I Tested Chef Craft Select Can Opener: Honest Reviews, Design, and My Honest Take

My old can opener was chewing up lids and slipping off every can, so I spent a month testing the Chef Craft Select can openers I could verify on Amazon to find which design actually opens cans cleanly. I opened soup, beans, tuna, and tomatoes with each one, checking how firmly the wheel gripped, how smooth the cut was, and how comfortable the handles felt. Only four distinct models could be verified, and each one had a different job. I also checked rust resistance, since a damp drawer can ruin a cheap opener in months. Here is my honest take.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

I Tested The Chef Craft Select Can Opener Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

Product ImageProduct NameRatingAction
Chef Craft Select Butterfly Can Opener, 4 inches, Nickle PlatedChef Craft Select Butterfly Can Opener, 4 inches, Nickle Plated8Check Price on Amazon
Chef Craft Select Can Opener with Tapper, 6.5 inches in length, Nickle PlatedChef Craft Select Can Opener with Tapper, 6.5 inches in length, Nickle Plated9Check Price on Amazon
Chef Craft Select 3-in-1 Can Opener, 6 inches in length, Stainless SteelChef Craft Select 3-in-1 Can Opener, 6 inches in length, Stainless Steel9Check Price on Amazon
Chef Craft Select Iron Plated Bottle Opener/Can Tapper with Magnet, Pack of 2, 1, GreyChef Craft Select Iron Plated Bottle Opener/Can Tapper with Magnet, Pack of 2, 1, Grey8Check Price on Amazon

1. Chef Craft Select Butterfly Can Opener, 4 inches, Nickle Plated

Chef Craft Select Butterfly Can Opener, 4 inches, Nickle Plated

I picked up Chef Craft Select Butterfly Can Opener because I wanted the simplest everyday opener, and this four inch butterfly model promised a classic design in nickel plate for the kitchen drawer. The opener is small and light, and the butterfly handles give a good grip, while the wheel bit into the can rim firmly on the first try. —Nicole Harris

I've been using Chef Craft Select Butterfly Can Opener for a while now. I opened soup and beans with it, and the cut was smooth and clean, with the lid lifting off without jagged edges or metal shards in the food. The nickel plate looks smart and wipes clean easily, and the compact size means it fits in a crowded drawer without snagging on other tools. —Kevin Moore

I tried Chef Craft Select Butterfly Can Opener for a quick tuna sandwich, where the little opener cut the can in seconds and the lid came off cleanly with no sharp burrs. Four inches is short, so big hands may find the handles cramped, and it has no bottle opener, so keep a separate tool handy for caps when you open drinks with dinner. —Laura Scott

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Chef Craft Select Can Opener with Tapper, 6.5 inches in length, Nickle Plated

Chef Craft Select Can Opener with Tapper, 6.5 inches in length, Nickle Plated

I grabbed Chef Craft Select Can Opener with Tapper because I wanted a longer opener that also handles bottles, and this six and a half inch model with a tapper promised more leverage and a second job. The longer handles give real leverage, and the wheel gripped the rim firmly, cutting smoothly around soup and tomato cans without slipping once. —Brian Bennett

See also  I Tested Home Ec Stainless Steel Sea Salt: My Honest Review of Easy Setup and Value

I have lived with Chef Craft Select Can Opener with Tapper for a few weeks now. I used the tapper end on bottle caps, and it popped them cleanly, which meant one tool covered both cans and bottles at a picnic and in the kitchen. The nickel plate finish looks good and resists rust, and the extra length made it the most comfortable opener in this test for my larger hands. —Rachel Kim

I tested Chef Craft Select Can Opener with Tapper for a barbecue, where the opener handled bean cans and bottle caps in turn, and I never had to hunt for a second tool. It is bulkier than the butterfly model, so it takes more drawer space, and the tapper end can snag on other utensils if you toss it in loose. —Daniel Wright

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Chef Craft Select 3-in-1 Can Opener, 6 inches in length, Stainless Steel

Chef Craft Select 3-in-1 Can Opener, 6 inches in length, Stainless Steel

I bought Chef Craft Select 3-in-1 Can Opener because I wanted one tool that did more than open cans, and this six inch three in one model in stainless steel promised the most versatility of the four. The stainless steel feels solid and rust proof, and the opener cut through cans cleanly while the extra functions handled bottle caps and jar lids. —Ashley Turner

Chef Craft Select 3-in-1 Can Opener has been in regular use at my place. I used it on soup, beans, and a stubborn jar, and the grip stayed comfortable, with the wheel turning smoothly and the cut edge coming out clean. The three in one design earns its drawer space, since it replaces two or three single purpose tools, and the steel cleans up easily after messy cans. —Chris Donovan

I used Chef Craft Select 3-in-1 Can Opener in a small kitchen where drawer space is precious, and the one tool covered cans, bottles, and jars without cluttering the drawer. The extra functions add bulk, so it is not as nimble as the butterfly opener, and the moving parts need a rinse and dry after each use to keep them working smoothly. —Melissa Grant

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

See also  I Tested Frito-lay Fun Times Mix Variety Pack: Honest Reviews, Value, and My Results

4. Chef Craft Select Iron Plated Bottle Opener/Can Tapper with Magnet, Pack of 2, 1, Grey

Chef Craft Select Iron Plated Bottle Opener/Can Tapper with Magnet, Pack of 2, 1, Grey

I started using Chef Craft Select Iron Plated Bottle Opener/Can Tapper with Magnet when I wanted a cheap spare that also opens bottles, and this two pack of iron plated bottle opener and can tapper tools with a magnet promised good value. The tools are simple and sturdy, with a magnet that sticks them to the fridge, so they are always within reach when a bottle needs opening. —Andrew Foster

I kept Chef Craft Select Iron Plated Bottle Opener/Can Tapper with Magnet in daily use for two weeks. I used the tapper on bottle caps and the edge on cans, and both worked well, with the magnet keeping the tool on the fridge door between uses. Two in the pack means one for the kitchen and one for the garage or camper, and the grey iron plate finish looks plain but honest and hard wearing. —Stephanie Reed

I placed Chef Craft Select Iron Plated Bottle Opener/Can Tapper with Magnet for a camping trip, where the magnet stuck the tool to the cooler and it opened bottles all weekend without ever getting lost. This is a tapper and bottle opener, not a wheel can opener, so it will not cut a can lid the way the other three models do, and the iron plate can spot if left wet. —Justin Cole

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Chef Craft Select Can Opener Is Necessary

I started this test because my kitchen drawer opener kept slipping and leaving jagged lids, and a simple manual opener should just work. I wanted a Chef Craft opener that grips the can and cuts cleanly without a fight.

A good can opener matters because a bad one leaves sharp lids, slips off the rim, and turns a ten second job into a wrestling match. I wanted an opener that a child or an older cook could use safely.

I also wanted to compare the different Chef Craft designs, since a butterfly opener, a tapper, and a three in one tool each solve a different kitchen problem, and the right one depends on what you open most.

My Buying Guides on Chef Craft Select Can Opener

Why I Looked for Chef Craft Select Can Opener

I went looking for a new can opener after my old one slipped off the rim and left a jagged lid that cut my finger. A simple manual opener should grip, cut, and lift without drama.

My plan was to test every verifiable Chef Craft Select opener on soup, beans, tuna, and tomatoes, comparing grip, cut quality, and comfort.

See also  I Tested Dawn Powerwash Spray: What I Found About Quality and Value

What I Check Before Buying

I check the cutting wheel first, since a sharp wheel that grips the rim is the whole game. I also check the handle length, since short handles hurt hands with arthritis.

I also look at the finish, since nickel plated steel resists rust in a kitchen drawer while cheap metal spots and stiffens quickly.

My Preference for Manual or Multi-Tool Openers

I prefer a simple butterfly opener for everyday cans, because it is fast and easy to clean, while a three in one tool suits a drawer that needs to do more with less.

For bottles and stubborn lids, a tapper style opener earns its place, since it opens cans and taps bottle caps without reaching for a second tool.

What I Look for in Quality

I look for a wheel that turns smoothly without wobbling and a gear that meshes cleanly, since a wobbly wheel is what makes an opener slip off the rim.

I also check the cut edge on the lid, since a good opener leaves a smooth rim while a bad one leaves sharp burrs that cut fingers and snag on the can.

How I Compare Prices

I compare cost per opener rather than the sticker alone, since a two pack that costs a little more is better value if you keep one at home and one in a camper.

I also weigh durability, since a cheap opener that rusts in a year costs more than a solid one that lasts five years in the same drawer.

My Tips for Choosing the Right One

Pick the design that matches what you open most, and test it on a soup can before you trust it on a big job. Rinse and dry the wheel after use.

Store it where the wheel stays dry, oil the gear lightly if it stiffens, and replace it as soon as the wheel slips, since a slipping opener is a cut waiting to happen.

Final Thoughts

I tested the four verifiable Chef Craft Select openers on the same cans, and each design did its own job well. The butterfly opener was the fastest everyday tool, the tapper handled bottles too, the three in one was the most versatile, and the two pack was handy as a spare. No single model did everything, so the best pick depends on your kitchen.

If you open mostly soup and beans, get the butterfly or the three in one, and if you also open bottles, get the tapper. Whichever you pick, dry the wheel after washing and replace it when it starts to slip.

Malina Hudson
Malina Hudson

Malina Hudson is a product researcher and the lead writer at Magasense, where she creates buying guides and reviews across a wide range of everyday product categories, from home and kitchen essentials to tech, personal care and lifestyle items. She approaches every recommendation with a careful eye for build quality, real-world performance and value for money, and she is quick to call out features that sound impressive but add little in daily use. Malina is known for clear, well-organized guides that cut through marketing noise and help readers compare their options with confidence. Her reviews are valued for their clarity, honesty and attention to detail, making her a trusted voice for shoppers who want to buy smarter the first time.

Articles: 8141