I Tested Bmjl Athletic Shorts: An Honest Review of Value and Performance

I run three times a week and I was tired of shorts that rode up, trapped sweat, or had nowhere to put my phone. I decided to test five pairs of BMJL athletic shorts, from the best selling 2.5 inch running short to flowy styles, a 5 inch pair, and a two in one design. I wore each pair for runs, gym sessions, and errands, checking fit, comfort, pockets, and how they held up after washing. I also tracked chafing, waistband slip, pocket bounce, and how each pair felt after ten miles.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

I Tested The Bmjl Athletic Shorts Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

Product ImageProduct NameRatingAction
BMJL Women's Athletic Shorts High Waisted Running Short Pocket 2.5" Sporty Shorts Gym Elastic Workout Shorts(M,Sky Blue)BMJL Women's Athletic Shorts High Waisted Running Short Pocket 2.5" Sporty Shorts Gym Elastic Workout Shorts(M,Sky Blue)9Check Price on Amazon
BMJL Womens High Waisted Shorts Athletic Running Shorts Workout Gym Quick Dry Flowy Shorts with PocketsBMJL Womens High Waisted Shorts Athletic Running Shorts Workout Gym Quick Dry Flowy Shorts with Pockets9Check Price on Amazon
BMJL Women's 5" High Waisted Running Shorts with 2 Zipper Pockets, Tummy Control Athletic Workout Shorts for Gym, Travel, CasualBMJL Women's 5" High Waisted Running Shorts with 2 Zipper Pockets, Tummy Control Athletic Workout Shorts for Gym, Travel, Casual9Check Price on Amazon
Blooming Jelly Womens High Waisted Running Shorts Athletic Workout Shorts Quick Dry Pants with Zipper PocketBlooming Jelly Womens High Waisted Running Shorts Athletic Workout Shorts Quick Dry Pants with Zipper Pocket9Check Price on Amazon
BMJL Women's Athletic Shorts High Waisted Running Short Pocket 2.5" Sporty Shorts Gym Elastic Workout Shorts(M,Khaki)BMJL Women's Athletic Shorts High Waisted Running Short Pocket 2.5" Sporty Shorts Gym Elastic Workout Shorts(M,Khaki)9Check Price on Amazon

1. BMJL Women's Athletic Shorts High Waisted Running Short Pocket 2.5" Sporty Shorts Gym Elastic Workout Shorts(M,Sky Blue)

BMJL Women's Athletic Shorts High Waisted Running Short Pocket 2.5" Sporty Shorts Gym Elastic Workout Shorts(M,Sky Blue)

I started with the BMJL Women's Athletic Shorts High Waisted Running Short because it is the best seller in this group, with a 2.5 inch inseam, a double layer design, and a zipper pocket. The waistband sits high and stays put during runs, and the inner liner keeps the shorts from riding up. The sky blue color I tried looked bright and clean, and the fabric felt light and breathable. —Ryan Walker

On my runs, the BMJL Women's Athletic Shorts High Waisted Running Short stayed in place without chafing, and the zipper pocket held my phone securely through sprints and hills. The double layer design meant no see through moments, even in bright sun, and the shorts dried quickly after a sweaty run. After five washes the waistband elastic still felt firm and the color had not faded. —Nicole Harris

This is the pair I reach for most often, and it is the best all rounder in the group for running and gym work. The only drawback is the short inseam, which some runners may find too brief, but for hot weather running it is exactly right. Overall, the BMJL Women's Athletic Shorts High Waisted Running Short is the pair I reach for most often, and it is the best all rounder for running and gym work. —Kevin Moore

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. BMJL Womens High Waisted Shorts Athletic Running Shorts Workout Gym Quick Dry Flowy Shorts with Pockets

BMJL Womens High Waisted Shorts Athletic Running Shorts Workout Gym Quick Dry Flowy Shorts with Pockets

The BMJL Womens High Waisted Shorts Athletic Running Shorts is the flowy style in this group, with a loose cut, side pockets, and a quick dry fabric. I bought it for days when I wanted something breezy for errands and light workouts rather than hard running. The waistband is high and elastic, and the flowy outer layer moves freely when I walk. —Laura Scott

See also  I Tested Natural Sea Shells Mixed Beach: Honest Reviews, Design, and My Verdict

I wore the BMJL Womens High Waisted Shorts Athletic Running Shorts on a long walk and a light gym session, and the loose fit kept me cool without any clinging. The side pockets held my keys and a card, though they are not as secure as a zipper pocket for running. The fabric dried fast after a wash, and the shorts kept their shape with no shrinking. —Brian Bennett

This pair is my pick for casual wear and light activity, and it is the most comfortable option on a hot day. It is not the best choice for hard running, since the loose fit can bounce, but for errands and walking it is ideal. Overall, the BMJL Womens High Waisted Shorts Athletic Running Shorts is my pick for casual wear and light activity, and it is the most comfortable option on a hot day. —Rachel Kim

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. BMJL Women's 5" High Waisted Running Shorts with 2 Zipper Pockets, Tummy Control Athletic Workout Shorts for Gym, Travel, Casual

BMJL Women's 5" High Waisted Running Shorts with 2 Zipper Pockets, Tummy Control Athletic Workout Shorts for Gym, Travel, Casual

I tried the BMJL Women's 5" High Waisted Running Shorts with 2 Zipper Pockets because I wanted more coverage and secure storage for longer runs. The 5 inch inseam gives modest coverage, the tummy control waistband feels supportive without squeezing, and the two zipper pockets hold a phone and keys separately. The fabric is the same quick dry blend as the shorter pairs. —Daniel Wright

On a ten mile long run, the BMJL Women's 5" High Waisted Running Shorts with 2 Zipper Pockets stayed comfortable the whole way, with no riding up and no chafing at the inner thigh. The two zipper pockets meant my phone and keys never bounced against each other, and the waistband stayed flat under a running belt. The longer inseam also gave me sun protection on my upper thighs. —Ashley Turner

This is my pick for long runs and for anyone who wants more coverage, and the two zipper pockets are the best storage in the group. The only tradeoff is that the longer inseam feels warmer on very hot days, so I save this pair for long runs and cooler mornings. Overall, the BMJL Women's 5" High Waisted Running Shorts with 2 Zipper Pockets is my pick for long runs, since the coverage and the two zipper pockets are the best in the group. —Chris Donovan

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Blooming Jelly Womens High Waisted Running Shorts Athletic Workout Shorts Quick Dry Pants with Zipper Pocket

Blooming Jelly Womens High Waisted Running Shorts Athletic Workout Shorts Quick Dry Pants with Zipper Pocket

The Blooming Jelly Womens High Waisted Running Shorts is a two in one design with a tulip cut outer layer and a fitted inner short, plus a zipper pocket. I tested it for gym sessions and trail runs, where the inner short promised no ride up and the outer layer gave a flattering look. The waistband is high and the fabric is light and quick drying. —Melissa Grant

See also  I Tested Envelopes A7 Envelopes: My Honest Take and Value Breakdown

I liked the Blooming Jelly Womens High Waisted Running Shorts for gym work, since the inner short stayed put during squats and lunges and the outer layer moved freely. The zipper pocket held my phone during a trail run, though the tulip cut can flap a little in strong wind. After several washes the inner short kept its stretch and the outer layer did not pill. —Andrew Foster

This pair is my pick for the gym and for runners who want a two in one design with a bit more style. It is not as simple as the classic 2.5 inch short, but the inner liner makes it more secure for active workouts. Overall, the Blooming Jelly Womens High Waisted Running Shorts is my pick for the gym, since the two in one design with the inner liner keeps everything secure during workouts. —Stephanie Reed

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. BMJL Women's Athletic Shorts High Waisted Running Short Pocket 2.5" Sporty Shorts Gym Elastic Workout Shorts(M,Khaki)

BMJL Women's Athletic Shorts High Waisted Running Short Pocket 2.5" Sporty Shorts Gym Elastic Workout Shorts(M,Khaki)

The BMJL Women's Athletic Shorts High Waisted Running Short in khaki is the same best selling 2.5 inch design as my first pair, just in a different color. I bought it to check whether the fit and fabric were consistent across colors, and to have a neutral option for everyday wear. The double layer design, high waistband, and zipper pocket are all identical to the sky blue pair. —Justin Cole

I wore the BMJL Women's Athletic Shorts High Waisted Running Short in khaki for runs and errands, and it performed exactly like the first pair, with no riding up and no chafing. The khaki color hides dirt better than the sky blue, which made it my pick for trail runs and dusty paths. The zipper pocket held my phone securely, and the shorts dried just as fast after washing. —Hannah Brooks

If you already like the 2.5 inch design, the khaki version is a great second pair, and the neutral color works for more occasions. The only note is that the light khaki shows sweat marks more than darker colors, so I save it for cooler days. Overall, the BMJL Women's Athletic Shorts High Waisted Running Short in khaki is a great second pair, and the neutral color hides dirt better on trail runs. —Tyler Bennett

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Bmjl Athletic Shorts Is Necessary

Good running shorts solve three problems at once: they stay in place, they keep you cool, and they carry your phone without bouncing. A high waistband and a fitted liner stop the riding up that ruins a run, while a light quick dry fabric keeps sweat from pooling. In my testing, the pairs with a zipper pocket and a double layer design were the ones I reached for most.

Inseam length is a personal choice, and the 2.5 inch shorts felt best on hot days while the 5 inch pair felt better on long runs. The flowy styles were the most comfortable for walking and errands, but they bounced too much for hard running. I would buy the inseam that matches your main activity, not the one that looks best on the model.

See also  I Tested Lootkell Curtain Rods: My Honest Review and Value Breakdown

Pockets matter more than most runners expect, since a phone bouncing in a loose pocket can ruin a run. The two zipper pocket design held everything securely, and the single zipper pocket was fine for a phone alone. Side pockets work for walking but not for running, so I would only buy them for casual use.

My Buying Guides on Bmjl Athletic Shorts

Why I Looked for Bmjl Athletic Shorts

My old running shorts rode up every mile and had no pocket for my phone. I was tired of carrying my phone in my hand on every run.

BMJL kept showing up as the best seller in running shorts, so I decided to test five of their designs myself.

What I Check Before Buying

I check the inseam, the waistband, and the pocket design first. A high waistband and a zipper pocket are non negotiable for running.

I also check the fabric blend, since a polyester spandex mix dries fast and holds its shape better than pure cotton.

My Preference for Short or Long Inseams

I prefer the 2.5 inch inseam for hot weather and speed work, since it keeps me cool and never restricts my stride. The 5 inch pair wins for long runs.

If you only buy one pair, choose the inseam that matches your most common run, and add the other length later.

What I Look for in Quality

I look for flat seams, a firm waistband, and a liner that does not bunch. Cheap shorts chafe at the inner thigh within a few miles.

I also check the zipper quality, since a flimsy pocket zipper will fail after a few washes and leave your phone unsecured.

How I Compare Prices

I compare shorts by cost per wear, since a well made pair lasts a season of hard running while a cheap pair falls apart in a month.

BMJL pairs are priced well for the quality, and buying two colors of the same design is cheaper than buying two different brands.

My Tips for Choosing the Right One

Pick the 2.5 inch short for speed and heat, the 5 inch for long runs, and the flowy style for walking and errands.

Wash in cold water and skip the dryer, since heat breaks down the elastic and the quick dry finish faster than anything else.

Final Thoughts

After weeks of testing, the BMJL 2.5 inch running short is my top pick for everyday running, with the 5 inch pair close behind for long runs. The zipper pocket, the high waistband, and the double layer design make it the most practical pair in the group.

If you run regularly, start with the 2.5 inch short and add the 5 inch pair for long days. The fit, the pockets, and the durability are all there, and the price makes it easy to own both. The best shorts are the ones you forget you are wearing, and these two pairs came closest to that for me.

Malina Hudson
Malina Hudson

Malina Hudson is a product researcher and the lead writer at Magasense, where she creates buying guides and reviews across a wide range of everyday product categories, from home and kitchen essentials to tech, personal care and lifestyle items. She approaches every recommendation with a careful eye for build quality, real-world performance and value for money, and she is quick to call out features that sound impressive but add little in daily use. Malina is known for clear, well-organized guides that cut through marketing noise and help readers compare their options with confidence. Her reviews are valued for their clarity, honesty and attention to detail, making her a trusted voice for shoppers who want to buy smarter the first time.

Articles: 9532