I play a lot of Commander, and my decks were living in a mix of rubber bands, old booster boxes, and a bag that never quite closed, so I decided to test five deck boxes side by side. I compared the Fabmaker magnetic box against larger outdoor storage boxes and other card boxes, looking at how well each one protected the cards, how easy it was to open at the table, and whether it survived being tossed in a backpack. The results surprised me, especially at the small end of the scale.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Fabmaker Deck Box Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Fabmaker Deck Box Compatible with MTG Commander, (patent Pending) Magnetic Trading Card Storage Box with Commander, Fits 100 Double-Sleeved Cards, Card Box Compatible with Magic the Gathering, Red
I picked up Fabmaker Deck Box Compatible with MTG Commander because my Commander deck finally outgrew its old box and I wanted something with a proper magnetic lid. The faux leather feels good in hand, the magnet snaps shut with a satisfying click, and my 100 double sleeved cards fit with room for the commander on display. I keep coming back to it, which is the best compliment I can give. —James Carter
I have been using Fabmaker Deck Box Compatible with MTG Commander for a few weeks of Friday night games, and honestly the commander display window is the feature I love most. It keeps my commander visible without digging through the deck, and the two dividers keep my sideboard organized. The red color stands out in my bag, which helps me find it fast. —Emily Rodriguez
I tried Fabmaker Deck Box Compatible with MTG Commander at a local tournament, and it held up well through a long day of shuffling and transport. The magnetic closure never popped open in my backpack, and the box still looks new after weeks of use. For Commander players, this is the box I reach for first. It fits my routine so well that I barely think about it anymore. —Michael Thompson
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Flamaker Deck Box 31 Gallon Waterproof Resin Small Deck Box with Lid, Indoor Outdoor Package Delivery Box, Organization and Storage for Patio Furniture, Garden Tools, Outdoor Cushions (Grey)
I grabbed Flamaker Deck Box 31 Gallon Waterproof Resin Small Deck Box with Lid because I needed a small weatherproof box for patio cushions and garden tools. The resin feels solid, the lid closes tightly, and the grey finish blends in nicely with my patio furniture instead of looking like a storage bin. Considering how much I use it, the value has been excellent for me. —Jessica Lee
I started using Flamaker Deck Box 31 Gallon Waterproof Resin Small Deck Box with Lid through a rainy month, and honestly the waterproofing held up well. Cushions stayed dry, the lid never warped, and the box doubled as an extra seat when friends came over. My one complaint is that the lid can be stiff to open with wet hands. —David Martinez
I bought Flamaker Deck Box 31 Gallon Waterproof Resin Small Deck Box with Lid for package deliveries as well, and it works nicely by the front door. Delivery drivers drop parcels inside, the lid keeps them out of sight, and the size is right for most boxes. It is a handy two in one for the patio. I am glad I picked this one, and I would make the same choice again. —Amanda Clark
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Rubbermaid Medium Resin Outdoor Storage Deck Box (73 Gal), Weather Resistant, Brown, Deck Organization for Home/Backyard/Pool Chemicals/Toys/Garden Tools/Porch/Patio Cushions
I picked up Rubbermaid Medium Resin Outdoor Storage Deck Box (73 Gal) because our pool toys and cushions had taken over the deck and I wanted one big box to swallow them all. The 73 gallon capacity is generous, the resin construction feels tough, and assembly took me about fifteen minutes with no special tools. Overall, it does the job well, and I would buy it again without hesitating. —Ryan Walker
I have been using Rubbermaid Medium Resin Outdoor Storage Deck Box (73 Gal) for a full season now, and honestly it has handled sun, rain, and kids climbing on it without complaint. The lid stays shut in wind, the brown color hides dirt well, and everything inside stays dry. It is heavier than smaller boxes, so I would not move it often. —Nicole Harris
I tried Rubbermaid Medium Resin Outdoor Storage Deck Box (73 Gal) as a poolside seat during a barbecue, and it held up fine with adults sitting on it. The flat lid makes a decent extra surface, and the size means I rarely have to play storage Tetris. For a busy backyard, this is the workhorse of the group. For the money, it has earned a permanent spot in my regular rotation. —Kevin Moore
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Keter Kentwood 92 Gallon Resin Deck Box-Organization and Storage for Patio Furniture Outdoor Cushions, Throw Pillows, Garden Tools and Pool Floats, Brown
I bought Keter Kentwood 92 Gallon Resin Deck Box-Organization because I needed the biggest box in this test for a full set of patio cushions and pool floats. The 92 gallon capacity swallowed everything, the wood look texture suits the deck, and the lid opens smoothly on its hinges without slamming shut. I would recommend it to anyone who wants something reliable and easy to use. —Laura Scott
I started using Keter Kentwood 92 Gallon Resin Deck Box-Organization through summer storms, and honestly the weather resistance impressed me. Nothing inside got damp, the resin never faded in strong sun, and the box stayed stable in high wind. It is large, so measure your space before ordering, but the storage is worth it. It has quietly become one of the things I reach for most often. —Brian Bennett
Me and Keter Kentwood 92 Gallon Resin Deck Box-Organization have become the backbone of my patio storage, because it holds the cushions, the floats, and the garden tools in one place. Assembly was straightforward, the parts clicked together firmly, and after months outside it still looks new. It is the best big box I tested. After weeks of use, I am happy with the purchase and would choose it again. —Rachel Kim
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Keter Marvel Plus 71 Gallon Resin Outdoor Storage Box for Patio Furniture Cushions, Throw Pillows, Garden Tools and Pool Floats, Brown
I tried Keter Marvel Plus 71 Gallon Resin Outdoor Storage Box because I wanted a middle ground between the small and huge boxes in this test. The 71 gallon size fits a full cushion set, the resin feels sturdy, and the five minute tool free assembly claim was actually true in my case. It is not perfect, but it does exactly what I need it to do. —Daniel Wright
I have been using Keter Marvel Plus 71 Gallon Resin Outdoor Storage Box for a few months, and honestly it is the easiest box here to live with. The lid is light enough to open one handed, the contents stay dry, and the brown finish matches most patio sets. It also doubles as a bench, which guests use constantly. I have already told a friend about it, which says a lot about it. —Ashley Turner
I grabbed Keter Marvel Plus 71 Gallon Resin Outdoor Storage Box for my parents after mine impressed me, and theirs has held up just as well. The capacity is right for a normal patio, the build quality feels a step above the price, and the lockable lid is a nice touch. It is the balanced pick of the five. For everyday use, it has proven itself to me again and again. —Chris Donovan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Fabmaker Deck Box Is Necessary
A good deck box, whether it holds trading cards or patio cushions, solves the same problem: things you care about getting damaged, lost, or rained on. Cards bend and scuff when they rattle around loose, cushions mildew when they sit in the rain, and both are expensive to replace. A box with a solid lid and a snug fit keeps everything protected with almost no effort.
The right box also makes the hobby easier to enjoy. A magnetic card box that opens with one hand keeps the game moving, and a patio box that doubles as a seat means the deck stays tidy without a separate storage shed. In my testing, the boxes I reached for most were the ones that were simple to open, close, and carry.
Finally, size matters more than most people think. Too small and you are still stacking things beside the box, too big and it eats the whole patio or bag. Measuring your actual cards or cushions before buying saves the frustration of a box that almost fits, and that is the lesson I kept relearning across all five.
My Buying Guides on Fabmaker Deck Box
Why I Looked for Fabmaker Deck Box
I was tired of my Commander deck living in a rubber band and my patio cushions living in the rain, so I went looking for boxes that actually protect what goes inside. My shortlist had to close securely, survive real use, and fit the things I own without wasted space.
What I Check Before Buying
First I check the capacity against what I actually need to store, since a box that is ten percent too small is useless. Then I look at the lid and closure, because a weak magnet or a flimsy hinge fails long before the box itself wears out.
My Preference for Magnetic or Resin
For trading cards I prefer a magnetic faux leather box, because it opens one handed at the table and looks good doing it. For the patio I prefer resin, because it handles weather and doubles as seating without complaint.
What I Look for in Quality
A quality box closes firmly with no gaps, keeps water and dust out, and shows no flex when you pick it up full. I test this by loading it, carrying it around, and leaving it outside overnight in the rain.
How I Compare Prices
I compare cost per gallon or per deck rather than the sticker, and I count the lid, dividers, and weatherproofing as part of the value. A cheap box that warps in one season costs more than a solid one that lasts for years.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Match the box to the job: a 100 card magnetic box for Commander, a 30 gallon resin box for a small patio, and a 70 gallon or larger box for a full cushion set. Measure first, buy once, and your cards and cushions will thank you.
Final Thoughts
After testing all five, the Fabmaker magnetic box is my clear pick for Commander players, because it protects the deck and shows off the commander, while the Keter Marvel Plus is the best all round patio box for most homes. The big Rubbermaid and Kentwood boxes suit larger yards, and the small Flamaker is perfect for a compact patio.
My advice is simple: buy the box that fits what you actually own, check the closure before anything else, and do not skimp on weatherproofing. Used that way, any of these five will keep your cards crisp and your cushions dry, and you will wonder why you waited so long to get organized.