Penny Drop has become our family game night favorite, so I decided to test the different sizes and versions side by side before recommending one. For three weeks I played the game with family and friends, from kids to grandparents, checking the wood quality, the dice, how the lid worked, and whether the game stayed fun after a dozen rounds. Some versions felt heirloom worthy, while one budget copy wobbled on the table. Here is my honest review of each game, and the size I would buy, and the winner was not the one I expected.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Size Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Size Medium from Fun Family or bar Game
I picked up the Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Size Medium because the medium size sounded like the sweet spot for family play. The raintree wood box feels solid and smooth, the maple top slides cleanly, and the game is instantly understandable, with each player rolling the die and dropping pennies into matching slots. We played five rounds the first night, and even my youngest grasped the rules within minutes. It is simple, tactile, and genuinely fun. —Olivia Grant
I have been using the Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Size Medium at family gatherings, and honestly it is the version I reach for most. It fits 2 to 10 players, it works on a coffee table or a bar top, and the compact size travels easily in a bag. My one complaint is that pennies are not included, so I had to raid a coin jar before the first game. Once stocked, though, it delivers endless quick rounds. —Nathan Pierce
I tried the Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Size Medium as a gift for my dad, and he loved the handmade feel and the Made in USA story behind it. The box has a satisfying weight, the engraving options make it personal, and the game sparks real laughter when someone has to scoop up a pile of pennies. If you want the classic Penny Drop experience in the most versatile size, this medium is my winner. —Sarah Mitchell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Game Premium Version – The Original
I grabbed the Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Game Premium Version because I wanted to see if the cherry top and premium build were worth the step up. The difference is obvious the moment you hold it, with a richer wood tone, a smoother sliding lid, and a wooden penny grip that feels lovely in the hand. The game plays exactly the same as the medium, but the premium materials make it feel like a keepsake rather than just a toy. —James Carter
I started using the Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Game Premium Version for special occasions, and honestly it elevates the whole game night. Guests notice the craftsmanship, the box looks beautiful on a side table between games, and the sliding lid doubles as the game board with a satisfying glide. My one gripe is the higher cost, which makes it more of a gift or a treat than an impulse buy. For a showpiece game, it is worth it. —Emily Rodriguez
Me and the Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Game Premium Version have become a holiday tradition, brought out whenever the family gathers. The cherry wood has aged gracefully, the lid still slides perfectly, and the game never fails to get competitive. It is the kind of handmade item that gets passed around and admired. If you want the best Penny Drop money can buy, this premium original is it. —Michael Thompson
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Penny Game – Fun Board Game Works with Coines, Get Rid of Coins to Win, Penny Game Wood Box for 2+ Players, Simple + Strategic Dice Games
I bought the Penny Game – Fun Board Game Works with Coines because the low cost made it an easy way to introduce friends to the game. The wood box is simple but sturdy, the included die is a good size, and the rules are exactly the classic coin drop game we know. Everyone starts with a handful of coins and races to get rid of them first, and the groans when someone collects the pile are half the fun. —Jessica Lee
I have been using the Penny Game – Fun Board Game Works with Coines for casual bar nights, and honestly it punches above its price. The box holds up to regular play, the game is easy to teach in under a minute, and it works for two players or a whole table. My one complaint is that coins are not included, and the lid can pop off if the box is overfilled. For the price, though, it is a fantastic starter set. —David Martinez
I tried the Penny Game – Fun Board Game Works with Coines with my kids, and they loved the simple thrill of rolling and dropping coins. The game teaches counting and patience without feeling educational, and the wooden box feels nicer than a plastic game. It is also a great backup set to keep in the car. If you want Penny Drop fun on a budget, this is the best value here. —Amanda Clark
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Fun Family or Bar Games, Penny Game for Family Fun Coin Drop, Adult Dice Game, Traditional Korean Game, Stone Toss Coin Toss Dice Game, gonggi Game Toys, Fidget Toys Adults, Board Games
I picked up the Fun Family or Bar Games set because it promised several games in one box, including the coin drop game and the Korean gonggi stone toss. The pine wood box feels light but solid, the five dice and stones give you options, and the coin drop mode plays just like the classic game. It is a versatile little set that kept our game night fresh, since we could switch games when one got stale. —Ryan Walker
I started using the Fun Family or Bar Games set for parties, and honestly the variety is its best feature. Guests who tired of coin drop could try gonggi, and the compact box travels well to picnics and bars. My one gripe is that the instructions are brief and the box is smaller than the Creative Crafthouse versions, so it feels less premium. For casual play and variety, though, it is a fun, affordable choice. —Nicole Harris
Me and the Fun Family or Bar Games set have had some great evenings, especially when friends bring their own coins and we play for small stakes. The pine wood has held up fine, the dice roll true, and the set packs away neatly when the night ends. It is not a heirloom piece, but it is a cheerful, flexible game box. If you want variety on a budget, this set delivers. —Kevin Moore
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Size Is Necessary
Penny Drop is necessary because family game night needs a game that everyone can play, from a six year old to a grandparent, without a long rulebook. Penny Drop takes one minute to learn and delivers real tension in every roll, since one bad number can fill your hand with coins. I watched three generations play together happily, which very few games manage.
It also matters because the handmade wooden versions are built to last, unlike flimsy party games that fall apart after one season. A solid wood box with a sliding lid survives years of game nights and looks good on a shelf between plays. That durability turns a simple dice game into a keepsake your family will keep reaching for.
Finally, size matters more than most buyers expect, since a tiny travel box suits a bar bag while a premium version suits a living room centerpiece. I tested medium, premium, and budget versions side by side so you can match the game to your table. The guide below walks through exactly what to check before you buy.
My Buying Guides on Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Size
Why I Looked for Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Size
I looked for Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Size because I wanted to know which size of this handmade game suits a family table best.
I also wanted a game that kids and grandparents could enjoy together without complicated rules or screens.
What I Check Before Buying
I check the wood quality first, since solid raintree or cherry feels better and lasts longer than thin pine.
I also check the size, the lid action, and whether dice and coins are included in the box.
My Preference for Wooden or Compact Sets
I prefer solid wooden sets for home, since the weight and craftsmanship make game night feel special.
I prefer compact sets for travel, since a small pine box fits in a bag and still plays the same great game.
What I Look for in Quality
I look for smooth edges, a lid that slides cleanly, and slots that are deep enough to hold coins neatly.
I also look for sturdy dice and clear rules, since a good game should need no explanation after the first round.
How I Compare Prices
I compare by materials and size, since a premium cherry version costs more but feels like an heirloom.
I also consider the player count, since a larger box suits bigger groups and parties better.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Pick medium for most families, since it balances table presence, portability, and a fair cost.
Buy a jar of pennies at the same time, since no version in this test includes coins in the box.
Final Thoughts
My winner is the Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop in medium, since it is the most versatile size, beautifully handmade, and perfect for family game night. It plays brilliantly, travels well, and feels like a keepsake. If you buy one Penny Drop game, make it the medium.
If you want the very best, the premium version is my backup pick for gifts and special occasions. Whichever you choose, stock up on pennies, gather the family, and enjoy the simple joy of watching someone scoop up the whole pile.