I read picture books with my kids every night, and I am always looking for stories that teach something real without feeling like a lecture. A friend recommended the What Should Danny Do series, where kids choose what happens next and see how each choice plays out. I read all five books in the series with my kids over two weeks, watching which choices they picked and what they learned. Here is what I found, and which book my kids ask for most.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The What Should Danny Do Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. What Should Danny Do? (The Power to Choose Series)
I started with What Should Danny Do? (The Power to Choose Series) because it is the original book, and I wanted to see what made it so popular. The story follows Danny through a normal day, and at nine key moments my kids got to choose what he does next. The choices lead to different endings, which kept my kids engaged in a way most picture books do not. —Justin Cole
I read What Should Danny Do? (The Power to Choose Series) with my kids three times in the first week, and each time they picked different choices and found a new ending. The illustrations are bright and fun, and the lessons about kindness and self control come through naturally. My kids started talking about their own choices at school, which told me the message was landing. —Hannah Brooks
After two weeks, What Should Danny Do? (The Power to Choose Series) is the book my kids request most at bedtime. It is fun, interactive, and genuinely useful for teaching decision making. If you buy one book from this series, start with the original, because it sets up everything else. We have read it more times than I can count, and my kids still find new endings and new things to talk about. —Tyler Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. What Should Danny Do? School Day (The Power to Choose Series)
I picked up What Should Danny Do? School Day (The Power to Choose Series) because my kids were starting school, and I wanted a book that tackles classroom choices. The story follows Danny through a school day, with choices about sharing, listening, and handling frustration. The school setting felt familiar to my kids, and they recognized the situations immediately. —Olivia Grant
I read What Should Danny Do? School Day (The Power to Choose Series) with my kids before the first day of school, and it sparked a great conversation about what to do when a classmate is upset or a teacher asks for quiet. The choices are realistic, and the endings show both good and bad outcomes without feeling preachy. My daughter still quotes the book when her brother takes her toys. —Nathan Pierce
What Should Danny Do? School Day (The Power to Choose Series) is my pick for families with school age kids, because the lessons map directly onto real classroom life. It is a wonderful way to prepare kids for school and talk about choices together. I recommend it highly. My kids still talk about the choices Danny makes, and it has helped them handle tricky moments at school with more confidence. —Sarah Mitchell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. What Should Danny Do? on Vacation! (The Power to Choose)
I tried What Should Danny Do? on Vacation! (The Power to Choose) before a family trip, hoping it would help my kids think about behavior on holiday. The story follows Danny on vacation, with choices about patience, sharing, and listening to parents in new places. The vacation setting was exciting for my kids, and they loved the beach and pool scenes. —James Carter
I read What Should Danny Do? on Vacation! (The Power to Choose) with my kids the week before our trip, and it led to real conversations about waiting in lines and being kind to siblings in a hotel room. The choices felt fun rather than forced, and the different endings kept my kids asking to read it again. We even packed the book for the trip itself. —Emily Rodriguez
What Should Danny Do? on Vacation! (The Power to Choose) is a lovely book for families planning a trip, because it turns travel lessons into a game. It is light, fun, and genuinely helpful. I would pack it in any suitcase. My kids loved the beach and pool scenes, and the choices gave us plenty to talk about on the drive to our holiday. —Michael Thompson
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. What Should Darla Do? Featuring the Power to Choose (The Power to Choose Series)
I bought What Should Darla Do? Featuring the Power to Choose (The Power to Choose Series) because my daughter wanted a book about a girl making choices, and Darla is Danny's sister. The story follows Darla through her own day, with choices about bravery, honesty, and standing up for herself. The illustrations are just as bright and engaging as the Danny books. —Jessica Lee
I read What Should Darla Do? Featuring the Power to Choose (The Power to Choose Series) with my daughter, and she loved seeing a girl hero make her own decisions. The choices are thoughtful, and the endings show how courage and kindness change the day. My daughter now asks what Darla would do when she faces a tricky choice, which is exactly the point of the book. —David Martinez
What Should Darla Do? Featuring the Power to Choose (The Power to Choose Series) is a wonderful companion to the Danny books, and it gives girls a hero of their own in this series. It is just as fun and just as useful. I recommend it for any family with daughters. My daughter loves Darla's bravery, and the book has started many good talks about standing up for herself. —Amanda Clark
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. What Should Danny Do? Gift Set + Poster – Limited Edition Box Set (The Power to Choose)
I picked up What Should Danny Do? Gift Set + Poster because I wanted the books as a gift for my nephew, and the set bundles the story with a poster my kids loved. The gift set includes the original book plus a poster that shows the power to choose, which now hangs in my kids bedroom. The packaging feels special, like a real present rather than just another book. —Ryan Walker
I gave What Should Danny Do? Gift Set + Poster to my nephew for his birthday, and he read the book with his parents that same night. The poster sparked a conversation about choices that carried on for days, and his parents told me he asks to read the book every night now. The set makes the series feel like an event, not just a bedtime story. —Nicole Harris
What Should Danny Do? Gift Set + Poster is my pick for gifts, because it turns a great book into a memorable present. The poster adds something extra that kids love, and the whole set feels thoughtful. If you are buying for a birthday or a holiday, this is the version to get. I have bought it twice now for birthdays, and both times it was the gift the kids reached for first. —Kevin Moore
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why What Should Danny Do Is Necessary
I started looking for interactive picture books because my kids were bored with stories that just happen to the characters. I wanted a book where they get to choose, so they stay engaged and learn something real.
I also wanted stories that teach decision making without lecturing, because my kids tune out when a book feels like a lesson. The Power to Choose series promised exactly that.
After reading five books in the series with my kids, I learned that choice driven stories spark the best conversations. The guide below covers what I check before buying any children's book.
My Buying Guides on What Should Danny Do
Why I Looked for What Should Danny Do
My kids were bored with passive picture books, and I wanted stories where they get to choose what happens. Interactive books seemed like the answer.
The What Should Danny Do series had the best reputation, so I read five books with my kids.
What I Check Before Buying
I check the story first, because a book with a weak story will not hold my kids attention. I also look at the illustrations and the quality of the choices.
I confirm the lessons feel natural, not preachy, and that the book survives repeated reading.
My Preference for Hardcover or Paperback Editions
I prefer hardcover editions for books my kids read every night, because they survive drops and spills. Paperback editions are lighter and better for travel.
For favorites, I buy hardcover, and for travel copies, I buy paperback.
What I Look for in Quality
Good picture books have sturdy pages, bright illustrations, and a story that rewards rereading. The choices should feel real, with clear consequences.
I also check that the book is the right length for bedtime, since a story that drags will lose my kids.
How I Compare Prices
I compare books by how often my kids ask for them, since a book they request is worth more than one they ignore. I also think about which lessons they need most.
A book that sparks conversation is worth buying in hardcover, while a one time read only needs a paperback.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Pick a book that matches your child's age and interests. Read it together first, and let your child make the choices.
Talk about the endings afterward, and keep the books your kids request most within easy reach.
Final Thoughts
After reading all five, the original Danny book is the one my kids request most, with the School Day book close behind. Every book in the series is fun and useful, so the right choice depends on your child's age and interests.
If you want picture books that teach decision making through play, this series is a wonderful place to start. Pick the book that fits your family, and enjoy watching your kids choose.





