Getting my kids to brush twice a day used to be a nightly negotiation, so I spent three weeks testing five Tom's of Maine kids toothpastes with my two children, rotating flavors and watching which tube actually got picked up without a fuss. I compared the fluoride and fluoride free versions, the strawberry and orange mango flavors, and the variety pack that lets kids choose. Some tubes won on taste alone, others on how clean teeth felt after brushing, and one surprised me by becoming the tube my daughter asks for by name.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Toms Maine Natural Kids Fluoride Toothpaste Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Tom's of Maine Natural Kids Fluoride Toothpaste, Strawberry, 3 Pack, 5.1 oz | For Kids Ages 2 and Up, Anticavity Toothpaste, No Artificial Flavors, Dyes, Sweeteners, or Preservatives, Gluten Free, Vegan
I picked up Tom's of Maine Natural Kids Fluoride Toothpaste because the Silly Strawberry flavor sounded like the one thing that might end our brushing battles, and the three pack meant I could stash a tube in each bathroom. My daughter took one sniff and declared it smelled like real strawberries, which makes sense since it is made with real fruit juice. The paste foams gently without being overpowering, and she actually brushes for the full two minutes now instead of rushing through it. —Stephanie Reed
I've been using Tom's of Maine Natural Kids Fluoride Toothpaste for two weeks now, and honestly the fluoride formula is what sold me as a parent, since it gives real cavity protection while the natural flavors keep my kids happy. The tubes are sized for small hands and the flip cap is easy for my five year old to open on her own. My one complaint is that the paste can be a little runny on a wet brush, so I squeeze a pea sized amount onto a dry brush first. —Justin Cole
I tried Tom's of Maine Natural Kids Fluoride Toothpaste with my younger son, who is two, and the gentle formula worked well for a child just learning the brushing habit. He likes the sweet strawberry taste and does not fight the brush the way he did with minty adult pastes. The fact that it has no artificial dyes, sweeteners, or preservatives and is gluten free and vegan gives me peace of mind. For families with little kids, this three pack is the one I keep reordering. —Hannah Brooks
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Tom's of Maine Natural Kid's Fluoride Toothpaste, Silly Strawberry, 5.1 oz. (back in original formula)
I grabbed Tom's of Maine Natural Kid's Fluoride Toothpaste because this single tube is the original Silly Strawberry formula my kids kept asking about, and I wanted to compare it with the three pack version. The flavor is the same fruity strawberry my daughter loves, and the paste cleans gently with calcium and silica instead of harsh abrasives. It is ADA approved for anticavity protection, which matters to me since my kids are still learning to brush properly. —Tyler Bennett
I've been using Tom's of Maine Natural Kid's Fluoride Toothpaste for a week, and honestly the single tube is handy for travel or for testing whether your child likes the flavor before buying the bigger pack. The strawberry taste is strong enough that my son asks to brush, which never happened with plain mint pastes. My honest complaint is that one tube runs out fast in a house with two kids brushing twice a day, so I treat this as a trial size rather than a long term supply. —Olivia Grant
Me and Tom's of Maine Natural Kid's Fluoride Toothpaste have become a regular pairing for weekend trips, because the single tube fits easily in a toiletry bag and the recyclable tube is a nice bonus. The paste rinses clean and leaves no gritty feeling, and my kids say their teeth feel smooth afterward. With no artificial preservatives, colors, or flavors and no animal testing, it is an easy tube to feel good about packing. —Nathan Pierce
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Tom's of Maine Kids Fluoride Free Toothpaste, Silly Strawberry, 3Pk, 5.1 oz | For Kids Ages 2 and Up, Kids Natural Toothpaste, Gently Cleans, Dye Free, No Artificial Flavors, Sweeteners, or Preservatives
I bought Tom's of Maine Kids Fluoride Free Toothpaste because my youngest swallows more toothpaste than he spits out, and I wanted a fluoride free option for him while his older sister keeps the fluoride version. The Silly Strawberry flavor is the same one my kids already love, made with real fruit flavor that makes brushing feel like a treat. The calcium and silica clean gently, and his teeth look clean and bright after each brushing. —Sarah Mitchell
I started using Tom's of Maine Kids Fluoride Free Toothpaste when my dentist suggested a fluoride free paste until my son learns to spit reliably, and it has worked well for that stage. The three pack lasts a good while, and the recyclable tubes are easy to rinse and toss in the recycling bin. My one complaint is that the fluoride free formula does not offer the same cavity protection, so I plan to switch him to the fluoride version once he masters spitting. —James Carter
I picked up Tom's of Maine Kids Fluoride Free Toothpaste for our youngest, and honestly it solved the daily worry about him swallowing toothpaste during brushing practice. He enjoys the fruity taste and brushes without protest, which is half the battle with toddlers. With no artificial preservatives, colors, or flavors, it is a gentle starter paste, though parents who want cavity protection should know fluoride is what provides it. —Emily Rodriguez
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Tom’s of Maine Fruity Natural Kids Fluoride Toothpaste Variety Pack, 5.1 oz | Silly Strawberry, Orange Mango, and Watermelon Wiggle Flavors, Safe for Ages 2 and Up, Fights Cavities, Dye Free, Vegan
I grabbed Tom’s of Maine Fruity Natural Kids Fluoride Toothpaste Variety Pack because my two kids could never agree on one flavor, and this pack gives them strawberry, orange mango, and watermelon to rotate. Each tube is made with real fruit juice, so the flavors taste like actual fruit instead of candy chemicals. Letting them pick their flavor each night turned brushing from a chore into a small choice they actually enjoy making. —Michael Thompson
I've been using Tom’s of Maine Fruity Natural Kids Fluoride Toothpaste Variety Pack for two weeks, and honestly the flavor rotation is the smartest thing about it, since my kids never get bored of one taste. The fluoride formula gives cavity protection, and the pastes are dye free, vegan, and gluten free. My one complaint is that the watermelon tube disappeared first, so I wish the pack let you pick the flavor mix instead of one of each. —Jessica Lee
I tried Tom’s of Maine Fruity Natural Kids Fluoride Toothpaste Variety Pack with my kids after the single flavor tubes started feeling routine, and the change worked right away. My daughter now asks for the orange mango one in the morning and strawberry at night, which means she brushes twice a day without reminders. For families with more than one child, this variety pack is the easiest way to keep everyone happy at the sink. —David Martinez
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Tom's of Maine Natural Kids Fluoride Toothpaste, Orange Mango, 3Pk, 5.1 oz | For Kids Ages 2 and Up, Anticavity Toothpaste, No Artificial Flavors, Dyes, Sweeteners, or Preservatives, Gluten Free, Vegan
I bought Tom's of Maine Natural Kids Fluoride Toothpaste in the orange mango flavor because my son was tired of strawberry and I wanted a change that still had fluoride cavity protection. The Outrageous Orange Mango taste is fruity and sweet without being sugary, and it is made with real fruit juice. He now brushes without complaining, and the three pack means I do not have to reorder for a while. —Amanda Clark
I started using Tom's of Maine Natural Kids Fluoride Toothpaste with the orange mango tubes when my daughter asked for something different, and the flavor won her over on the first brushing. The paste is gentle on young teeth and the formula has no artificial dyes, sweeteners, or preservatives, which I check on every kids product I buy. My honest complaint is that the orange color can stain a light colored washcloth if it drips, so I keep a dark towel by the sink. —Ryan Walker
Me and Tom's of Maine Natural Kids Fluoride Toothpaste have become a steady routine in our house, with the orange mango three pack sitting next to the strawberry one so the kids can switch flavors. Both are fluoride formulas for ages two and up, so I know their teeth get cavity protection either way. For parents whose kids are bored of strawberry, this orange mango version is the simplest switch that still does the job. —Nicole Harris
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Toms Maine Natural Kids Fluoride Toothpaste Is Necessary
Kids toothpaste matters more than most parents expect, because the flavor decides whether a child brushes at all. A paste can have the best cavity protection in the world, but if a child hates the taste, it sits unused in the cabinet. That is why I tested flavors, formulas, and pack sizes instead of just reading labels, so I could find the tubes my kids actually reach for twice a day.
Fluoride is the other big decision. It gives real cavity protection, and dentists recommend it once kids can spit, but younger children who swallow toothpaste need a fluoride free option until they learn. Knowing which stage your child is in makes the choice simple, and the right pack size keeps you from running out midweek when brushing habits are finally sticking.
Natural ingredients matter too, since kids swallow some toothpaste no matter how careful they are. Pastes without artificial dyes, sweeteners, flavors, and preservatives give me peace of mind, and real fruit juice flavors taste better to kids than chemical sweetness. The best kids toothpaste is the one your child likes enough to use every morning and night.
My Buying Guides on Toms Maine Natural Kids Fluoride Toothpaste
Why I Looked for Toms Maine Natural Kids Fluoride Toothpaste
My kids fought brushing every night, and I was tired of minty adult pastes they hated. I wanted a kids toothpaste with flavors they liked, fluoride protection, and ingredients I could trust.
What I Check Before Buying
I check the age range first, then whether it has fluoride or is fluoride free. I also read the ingredient list for artificial dyes, sweeteners, and preservatives before I buy.
My Preference for Fluoride or Fluoride Free Toothpaste
I prefer fluoride for kids who can spit, since it protects against cavities. For toddlers still swallowing toothpaste, I choose the fluoride free version until they learn.
What I Look for in Quality
A quality kids toothpaste cleans gently with calcium and silica, tastes like real fruit, and comes from a brand that skips artificial additives. The tube should be easy for small hands to squeeze.
How I Compare Prices
I compare cost per tube, not per pack, since pack sizes vary. A three pack usually beats single tubes, and the variety pack is worth it if your kids like different flavors.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Let your child pick the flavor, since the tube they like is the one they will use. Start fluoride free for toddlers, switch to fluoride once they spit reliably, and keep a spare tube handy.
Final Thoughts
After three weeks of testing, the Tom's of Maine kids range earned a permanent spot in our bathroom, with the strawberry three pack as our everyday tube and the variety pack for keeping things fresh. The fluoride formulas give cavity protection, the flavors get kids brushing willingly, and the natural ingredient list is one I am comfortable with for my own children.
If your child is still learning to spit, start with the fluoride free version and move to the fluoride tubes once they get the hang of it. Pick the flavor your child likes best, keep a spare tube on hand, and let them choose their tube each night. That small bit of choice is what turned brushing from a battle into a habit in our house.