I moved house last year and again helped my daughter move this spring, and both times the packing paper made the difference between unbroken dishes and a box of regrets. I decided to test five packing papers, from plain newsprint sheets to honeycomb wrap, to find out which ones actually protect fragile items and which ones just fill space. I wrapped glasses, plates, and vases, dropped boxes, and unpacked everything twice. Here is what held up and what did not. I wrapped glasses, plates, and vases to compare cushioning and durability.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Packing Paper Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. 100 Sheets Packing Paper for Moving, Newsprint Paper for Packing Wrapping, Wrapping Paper for Packaging Glasses Dishes – Must Have Packing Supplies for Moving Box Filler(12 * 24in)
I picked up 100 Sheets Packing Paper for Moving because the 12 by 24 inch size looked ideal for wrapping plates and glasses, and the 100 sheet count promised enough for a whole kitchen. The paper is thick enough to cushion a glass without tearing, and it folds neatly around plates with no ink to transfer onto dishes. I packed a full box of glasses and not one arrived chipped. —Nathan Pierce
I started using 100 Sheets Packing Paper for Moving as box filler too, and honestly it does double duty well. Crumpled sheets fill the gaps at the top of a box, and flat sheets wrap each item individually. My one complaint is that the sheets are thinner than the U-Haul paper, so I double wrap anything truly fragile like vases. —Sarah Mitchell
Me and 100 Sheets Packing Paper for Moving have packed two moves now, and the value is excellent for the count. The sheets are clean, unprinted, and easy to tear to size, and the box lasted through a whole kitchen pack. For everyday moving and storage, this is the paper I reach for first. 100 Sheets Packing Paper for Moving is now the first box I open whenever a move begins. —James Carter
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. 12 * 12 inch Packing Paper for Moving 100 Sheets Protecting Fragile China and Glasses,Small Wrapping Paper for Shipping and Moving Box Filler
I bought 12 * 12 inch Packing Paper for Moving because the smaller square size seemed perfect for cups and small dishes, and I was right. The 12 inch sheets wrap a mug in one go with no excess to tuck away, and the paper is thick and durable enough to reuse for a second move. I wrapped a full set of china cups and every one arrived intact. —Emily Rodriguez
I have been using 12 * 12 inch Packing Paper for Moving for shipping parcels as well, and honestly the small size is a plus for boxes. It cushions without taking up too much room, and the unprinted newsprint leaves no ink on anything. My complaint is that the sheets are too small for large plates, so I keep the bigger sheets for those. —Michael Thompson
I tried 12 * 12 inch Packing Paper for Moving for my daughter's dorm move, and the 100 sheets covered her whole kitchen in one box. The paper is easy to mark, easy to fold, and strong enough to scrunch into gaps. For small items and cups, this is the most convenient size I tested. 12 * 12 inch Packing Paper for Moving is perfect for mugs, and I keep a pack by the door. —Jessica Lee
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. U-Haul Newsprint Packing Paper For Moving and Shipping – 100 sheets – 5 lbs. – 24” x 30” Sheets
I grabbed U-Haul Newsprint Packing Paper because the U-Haul name promised proper moving supplies, and the large 24 by 30 inch sheets are the biggest I tested. The paper is noticeably thicker and heavier than the others, with a 5 pound pack that feels substantial. One sheet wraps a large platter or a vase with room to spare, and the cushioning is excellent. —David Martinez
I started using U-Haul Newsprint Packing Paper for the most fragile items, and honestly the thickness earns its keep. I wrapped my grandmother's porcelain with two sheets each and nothing broke, even after the movers stacked boxes. My one complaint is the size: the big sheets are awkward to handle in a small room, so I tear them in half for everyday items. —Amanda Clark
Me and U-Haul Newsprint Packing Paper have become my choice for anything irreplaceable. The paper is clean, ink free, and strong enough to double as void fill at the top of a box. It costs more per sheet than the budget options, but for fragile heirlooms the extra protection is worth it. U-Haul Newsprint Packing Paper is the one I trust with anything I could never replace. —Ryan Walker
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Packing Paper for Moving, Newsprint Packing Paper Sheets for Shipping Transportation,Wrapping, Fill the Moving Boxes and Protect Fragile Items (100 Sheets, 27”x15”)
I picked up Packing Paper for Moving in the 27 by 15 inch size because the rectangle shape looked useful for wrapping long items like vases and bottles. The sheets are a good middle size, big enough for plates but not so large they are unwieldy. I wrapped a set of wine glasses and a ceramic lamp, and both survived the move without a mark. —Nicole Harris
I have been using Packing Paper for Moving for shipping orders from my small craft business, and honestly the size is ideal for parcels. The paper cushions well, folds neatly, and looks professional in the box. My complaint is that the sheets vary slightly in thickness, with a few thinner ones in the pack, so I double up on the thinnest sheets. —Kevin Moore
I tried Packing Paper for Moving as drawer liner after the move, and it works well for that too. The 100 sheets go a long way, the paper is clean and unprinted, and the rectangular shape fits most boxes neatly. For general moving and shipping, this is a solid all rounder at a fair price. Packing Paper for Moving is now my go to for shipping, storage, and every move in between. —Laura Scott
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. METRONIC 15" x 28" Honeycomb Packing Paper Sheets for moving 100 Pcs, Wrapping Paper for Bubble Cushioning Wrap and Shipping Packaging, Biodegradable & Fully Recylable, Brown
I bought METRONIC 15" x 28" Honeycomb Packing Paper because the honeycomb design promised bubble wrap protection without the plastic, and I wanted to test that claim. The paper stretches into a mesh that grips the item and cushions it beautifully. I wrapped a set of drinking glasses and they survived a drop test from waist height with no damage at all. —Brian Bennett
I started using METRONIC 15" x 28" Honeycomb Packing Paper for shipping fragile crafts, and honestly the honeycomb is clever. It uses less paper than flat sheets for the same protection, it looks smart in the box, and it is fully biodegradable. My one complaint is the learning curve: you have to stretch it correctly or it does not open up properly. —Rachel Kim
Me and METRONIC 15" x 28" Honeycomb Packing Paper have changed how I pack fragile things. The brown kraft look is attractive, the cushioning beats plain newsprint, and the 100 sheets last well. For anything delicate or gift wrapped, this is the most impressive packing paper I tested. METRONIC 15" x 28" Honeycomb Packing Paper protects fragile gifts better than any bubble wrap I have used. —Daniel Wright
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Packing Paper Is Necessary
I have moved house twice in two years, and I learned the hard way that bad packing paper costs more than good packing paper. A chipped plate or a broken vase is worth far more than the few dollars saved on thin, flimsy sheets.
I also ship handmade crafts to customers, and the packaging is part of the product. Clean, strong paper protects the item and makes the parcel look professional, which matters when someone is opening a gift.
Most of all, I wanted paper that does more than fill space. Good packing paper wraps, cushions, and protects in one step, and the best options do it without ink, plastic, or waste.
My Buying Guides on Packing Paper
Why I Looked for Packing Paper
I was moving house and needed paper that would actually protect my dishes, not just fill the boxes. Thin paper tears and leaves items exposed.
I also ship crafts to customers, so I wanted paper that looks professional in the box as well as protecting the contents.
What I Check Before Buying
First I check the sheet size against what I pack most. Large sheets suit platters, small sheets suit cups, and a middle size covers most jobs.
Then I look at the thickness and whether the paper is unprinted. Ink transfers onto dishes, and thin paper tears when you need it most.
My Preference for Newsprint or Kraft Paper
I prefer newsprint for everyday moving because it is cheap, clean, and easy to fold around plates and glasses. It does the basic job well.
Kraft and honeycomb paper win for fragile or valuable items, since the texture grips and cushions better. I would pick honeycomb for anything I really care about.
What I Look for in Quality
A quality packing paper feels substantial in the hand, folds without cracking, and does not tear when you wrap a heavy plate. Thin paper fails on all three counts.
I also check that it is unprinted and clean. Newsprint with ink stains dishes and hands, while clean paper keeps everything spotless.
How I Compare Prices
I compare the cost per sheet, not per pack, since sheet sizes vary a lot. A pack of big sheets can be better value than a pack of small ones.
I also factor in how many sheets each item needs. Thicker paper means fewer sheets per item, which can make a dearer pack cheaper overall.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Buy two sizes: large sheets for plates and small sheets for cups. One size never covers everything, and the wrong size wastes paper.
Wrap each item individually, fill every gap with crumpled paper, and label fragile boxes clearly. Good technique matters as much as good paper.
Final Thoughts
After two moves and a lot of shipping, the U-Haul paper is the best for truly fragile items, the honeycomb paper is the cleverest for gifts, and the 12 by 24 inch sheets are the best everyday value. Any of the five will protect your dishes if you wrap them properly.
If you are moving soon, start with the 100 sheet pack in the size that matches your plates, and add honeycomb paper for anything delicate. Your dishes will arrive intact, and you will never go back to old newspapers.





