I run a house that goes through a lot of ice, from morning iced coffee to weekend cookouts, so I spent two weeks testing five Igloo countertop ice makers side by side in my kitchen. I filled each one, timed the first batch, and kept notes on cube size, noise, and how often I had to refill the tank. Some made ice fast and stayed quiet, one kept flashing for water when the tank was half full, and the differences only showed up after days of real use. Here is what I found, and which one earned the spot on my counter.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Igloo Ice Maker Countertop Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Igloo Portable Ice Maker with Scoop – Countertop Ice Maker with LED Control Panel & 1.5 Quart Water Tank – Ice Cube Maker Produces 26 Lbs. of Ice in 24 Hours with 9 Large or Small Cubes in 7 Minutes
I picked up the Igloo Portable Ice Maker with Scoop because the stainless finish matched my kitchen and the 1.5 quart tank sounded big enough for a full evening of drinks. The first batch dropped in about seven minutes, and the LED panel made it obvious when to add water or empty the basket. I liked that it offers small or large cubes, since the small ones chill a glass fast and the large ones last longer in a cooler. —Ryan Walker
I have been using the Igloo Portable Ice Maker with Scoop for two weeks now, and honestly the steady output is what keeps it on my counter. It turns out around 26 pounds a day when I keep the tank topped up, and the scoop that comes with it means no more digging cubes out with a coffee mug. My one complaint is the fan hum, which is noticeable in a quiet kitchen late at night. —Nicole Harris
I tried the Igloo Portable Ice Maker with Scoop for a backyard cookout, and it kept up with a crowd that kept coming back for refills. The basket holds enough for a round of drinks, and the self cleaning cycle is a simple button press that I run every few days. The cubes come out clear and hard, not cloudy or soft, and they do not melt into a puddle the moment they hit a glass. —Kevin Moore
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Igloo 26-Pound Automatic Self-Cleaning Portable Countertop Ice Maker Machine with Handle, Pink
I grabbed the Igloo 26-Pound Automatic Self-Cleaning Portable Countertop Ice Maker Machine because the pink finish made me smile and the carry handle promised easy moves from kitchen to patio. Setup took minutes, just a rinse and a fill, and the first cubes appeared fast enough that I stopped watching the clock. The viewing window is a small joy, since I can see the ice forming without lifting the lid. —Laura Scott
I have been running the Igloo 26-Pound Automatic Self-Cleaning Portable Countertop Ice Maker Machine through daily use, and the handle really does earn its keep at cookouts. I carry it outside full of water, plug it in, and it starts making ice while I set up the grill. The five cycle self cleaning function keeps the inside fresh, though I still wipe the basket by hand once a week for good measure. —Brian Bennett
Me and the Igloo 26-Pound Automatic Self-Cleaning Portable Countertop Ice Maker Machine have become a steady pair for iced tea season. The cubes are a good bullet shape that fits water bottles, and the machine tells me clearly when the basket is full or the water runs low. My honest complaint is that the pink shade shows fingerprints, so I keep a cloth nearby, but that is a small trade for a machine that simply works. —Rachel Kim
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Igloo Self-Cleaning Countertop Ice Maker – Compact and Portable – Creates 26 lbs. Per Day, 8 Pieces Ready Every 7-8 Minutes – Includes Ice Scoop and Basket – Aqua
I bought the Igloo Self-Cleaning Countertop Ice Maker because the aqua color fit my kitchen and the compact size promised not to hog the counter. It makes its first eight pieces in about seven minutes, which covered my morning iced coffee without a wait. The single button control is dead simple, and the LED lights tell me at a glance whether it needs water or the basket is full. —Daniel Wright
I started using the Igloo Self-Cleaning Countertop Ice Maker when my old freezer tray routine finally wore me down, and the daily output surprised me for such a small box. It quietly keeps up with a family of four through dinner and an evening of drinks. The one pound basket is on the small side, so on party nights I empty it into a freezer bag and let the machine keep working. —Ashley Turner
I have been using the Igloo Self-Cleaning Countertop Ice Maker for a couple of weeks, and the self cleaning cycle is the feature I now refuse to live without. A button press runs five cycles and the inside smells fresh afterward, with no slimy buildup. The cubes are small and melt a little fast in hot drinks, which is my only real gripe, but for everyday iced coffee and water it is a dependable little machine. —Chris Donovan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Igloo Electric Countertop Ice Maker Machine – Automatic and Portable – 33 Pounds in 24 Hours – Ice Cube Maker – Ice Scoop and Basket – Ideal for Iced Coffee and Cocktails – Silver
I picked up the Igloo Electric Countertop Ice Maker Machine because the 33 pound daily output was the biggest of the group and I host a lot. The silver finish looks sharp next to my other appliances, and it started dropping cubes within minutes of the first fill. I liked that it comes with both a scoop and a basket, so I did not need to buy anything extra to get going. —Melissa Grant
I tried the Igloo Electric Countertop Ice Maker Machine through a long weekend of iced coffee and cocktails, and the higher output really showed. It kept a steady supply going while the smaller machines in my test needed constant refills. The cubes are a good size for a tall glass, and the machine runs quieter than I expected for something that works this hard all day. —Andrew Foster
I have been using the Igloo Electric Countertop Ice Maker Machine as my main ice source, and honestly the capacity is the reason it stays. It handles a full day of drinks without a fuss, and the controls are simple enough that guests can use it without asking me. My complaint is the footprint, since it is wider than the compact models, so measure your counter before you buy. —Stephanie Reed
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Igloo Automatic Self-Cleaning Portable Electric Countertop Ice Maker Machine with Handle, 26 Pounds in 24 Hours, 9 Ice Cubes Ready in 7 Minutes, with Ice Scoop and Basket
I grabbed the Igloo Automatic Self-Cleaning Portable Electric Countertop Ice Maker Machine because the handle and the self cleaning feature sounded like the best of both worlds. It makes nine cubes in about seven minutes, and the LED panel is bright and easy to read even in a dim kitchen. The first load of ice came out clear and solid, which told me the machine was doing its job properly. —Justin Cole
I started using the Igloo Automatic Self-Cleaning Portable Electric Countertop Ice Maker Machine for daily iced tea, and the routine is pleasantly boring in the best way. Fill it in the morning, empty the basket into a bag at night, and it just keeps producing. The automatic cleaning cycle means I never think about scale or smell, and the basket and scoop feel sturdy rather than flimsy. —Hannah Brooks
Me and the Igloo Automatic Self-Cleaning Portable Electric Countertop Ice Maker Machine have settled into a good rhythm for parties. I carry it to the patio by the handle, plug it in, and it supplies ice all afternoon without me babysitting it. The cubes are a touch on the small side for a slow sipping whiskey, but for water, soda, and iced coffee they are exactly right. —Tyler Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Igloo Ice Maker Countertop Is Necessary
I started looking for a countertop ice maker because my freezer tray routine could not keep up with summer. Every cookout meant a last minute store run for bagged ice, and the trays always seemed to be empty right when I needed them most. A machine that makes fresh ice on demand sounded like a small luxury that would pay off daily.
The countertop size matters because I do not have room for a built in unit and I do not want another appliance I have to plumb in. These Igloo machines sit on the counter, plug into a normal outlet, and start making ice within minutes. That simplicity is the whole point, and it is why I tested five of them instead of buying the first one I saw.
I compared five models because the differences between them are not obvious from the box. Output per day, basket size, noise, and cleaning features all change how the machine feels in real use. Testing them side by side showed me which trade offs matter and which ones are just marketing, and that is what this guide is built on.
My Buying Guides on Igloo Ice Maker Countertop
Why I Looked for Igloo Ice Maker Countertop
My freezer trays could not keep up with iced coffee season, and bagged ice meant constant store runs.
I wanted fresh ice on demand without plumbing in a built in unit or giving up half my freezer.
What I Check Before Buying
I check daily output first, then basket size, since a big daily number means little with a tiny basket.
I also check the water tank size and whether the machine has a self cleaning cycle.
My Preference for Compact or High Output Models
I prefer compact models for daily kitchen use, since they fit the counter and stay quiet.
For parties and big families, I pick the higher output models and accept the wider footprint.
What I Look for in Quality
I look for clear, hard cubes and a basket and scoop that feel sturdy, not flimsy.
I also check that the controls are simple and the indicators for water and full basket are easy to read.
How I Compare Prices
I compare machines by output per day and features, not just the sticker number.
A cheaper machine that needs constant refills costs more in hassle than the few dollars saved.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Measure your counter first, then match the daily output to your household, not to a party you host twice a year.
Pick a self cleaning model if you hate maintenance, and keep a freezer bag handy for party nights.
Final Thoughts
After two weeks with all five, the stainless model with the LED panel is my daily pick for the kitchen, and the 33 pound model is the one I pull out for parties. The compact aqua machine is the best fit for a small counter or a dorm, while the handled models win whenever ice needs to travel to the patio. Each one makes good ice, so the right choice comes down to space, output, and how often you entertain.
If you are tired of freezer trays and last minute ice runs, start with your daily use and pick the Igloo that matches it. Keep the tank full, run the cleaning cycle regularly, and empty the basket into a bag on busy days. Any of these five will change your summer, and the best one is the one that fits your counter and your routine.



