Nothing stops a workday like a printer flashing an ink warning at deadline time, so I stocked up and tested hp tri-color ink cartridges across the printers my family actually owns. I rotated the standard HP 67, the combined HP 63/65 cartridge, the newer HP 68, the high yield HP 64XL, and the HP 67XL through school projects, photo prints, and a month of office documents. I judged each cartridge on setup ease, color quality on plain paper and photos, how honest the page yield felt, and whether the printer accepted it without complaint. Here is the short version.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Hp Tri-color Ink Cartridges Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. HP 67 Tri-Color Ink Cartridge | Works with DeskJet 1255, 2700, 4100 Series, Envy 6000, 6400 Series | Eligible for Instant Ink | 3YM55AN | Packaging May Vary
I picked up HP 67 Tri-Color Ink Cartridge because it is the standard color cartridge for my DeskJet at home, and I wanted a baseline before trying the XL and newer options. Setup was the usual painless HP routine: pop the old cartridge, click this one in, and the printer aligned without any error lights. The rated yield is about 100 pages, and for school worksheets and the odd photo, the colors came out clean and even. —Tyler Bennett
I've been using HP 67 Tri-Color Ink Cartridge for a month of mixed printing, and honestly the quality is exactly what a home printer needs. Colors on my kids' project posters looked bright without banding, and skin tones in a test photo were believable rather than orange. The cartridge is also Instant Ink eligible, which matters if you prefer the subscription route, though I ran this one the old fashioned way to watch the levels myself. —Olivia Grant
I tried HP 67 Tri-Color Ink Cartridge on a run of birthday invitations with heavy color blocks, and that is where the 100 page yield shows its limits. Big graphics drink ink fast, and I could watch the estimate drop in the app. For everyday documents and light photo use it is perfectly matched to a DeskJet or Envy, but heavy color printers in the family should start with the XL version instead. —Nathan Pierce
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. HP 63/65 Tri-Color Ink Cartridge (Replaces Both 63 & 65), Compatible with DeskJet 1100, 2100, 2600, 3600, Envy 4500, 5000, OfficeJet 3800, 4600, 5200 Series, B7RT2AN
I grabbed HP 63/65 Tri-Color Ink Cartridge because our older DeskJet has taken both 63 and 65 cartridges over the years, and a single combined replacement simplifies the supply drawer. It clicked into the printer and was recognized immediately, no firmware complaints, and the first test page printed with the same color balance I got from the separate cartridges. The yield is rated around 100 pages, matching the standard cartridges it replaces. —Sarah Mitchell
I started using HP 63/65 Tri-Color Ink Cartridge in the kids' homework printer, which lives on worksheets, coloring pages, and the occasional permission slip. Colors stayed consistent from the first page to the last warning, and having one cartridge number to remember for a printer that historically accepted two different ones removed a real point of confusion in our house. It also works across a long list of DeskJet, Envy, and OfficeJet models. —James Carter
Me and HP 63/65 Tri-Color Ink Cartridge have become a peace treaty with an aging printer that I refuse to replace while it still works. The honest limitation is the same as every standard cartridge here: heavy photo printing drains it quickly. For keeping an older HP printing happily on documents and schoolwork, though, this combined cartridge is the most convenient option HP currently sells for those models. —Emily Rodriguez
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. HP 68 Tri-Color Ink Cartridge | Works with Envy 6100e, 6500e Series | 7FP20TN | Packaging May Vary
I bought HP 68 Tri-Color Ink Cartridge for the newer Envy in my office, since the 6100e and 6500e series moved to this cartridge family. HP rates it around 120 pages, a small step up from the 67, and the updated G5 technology is supposed to keep output consistent across the cartridge's life. Setup was instant, and the first photo prints looked sharp with smooth color transitions. —Michael Thompson
I've been using HP 68 Tri-Color Ink Cartridge for client documents with charts and logos, and honestly the consistency is what I notice. Page fifty looked like page five, with no fading in the big color blocks, which has not always been my experience near the end of a cartridge. It is also made partly with plastic recovered from the ocean, a detail I appreciated while unboxing yet another plastic cartridge. —Jessica Lee
I tried HP 68 Tri-Color Ink Cartridge on a set of family photos for a frame wall, and the colors were rich without tipping into oversaturation. My caution is compatibility: this cartridge only fits the newer Envy and select DeskJet models it lists, so check your printer model twice before ordering. If your machine takes the 68, it is a dependable, slightly longer lasting standard cartridge. —David Martinez
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. HP 64XL Tri-Color High-Yield Ink Cartridge Printers | Works with Printer Series: Envy Inspire 7950e; Envy Photo 6200, 7100, 7800; Tango | Eligible for Instant Ink | N9J91AN
I picked up the HP 64XL Tri-Color High-Yield Ink Cartridge for our Envy Photo printer because standard cartridges vanished too fast during photo season. The XL is rated around 415 pages, roughly four times the standard yield, and that changes the whole rhythm of owning the printer. Colors on photo paper were deep and clean, and the cartridge is Instant Ink eligible if you ever want to compare the subscription math. —Amanda Clark
I started using the HP 64XL Tri-Color High-Yield Ink Cartridge in the fall, when school projects, holiday cards, and photo gifts all collide in my house. It sailed through the season without a mid-project store run, which is the entire point of a high yield cartridge. Per page, it is the cheapest color ink in this test by a wide margin, even though the box costs the most on the shelf. —Ryan Walker
Me and the HP 64XL Tri-Color High-Yield Ink Cartridge have become a set-and-forget arrangement on the photo printer. The one caution is fit: it serves the Envy Photo, Envy Inspire, and Tango families, not the DeskJet crowd, so model checking matters even more with an expensive cartridge. If your printer is on its list and you print in bursts, this is the cartridge I would buy first and think about least. —Nicole Harris
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. HP 67XL Tri-Color High-Yield Ink Cartridge | Works with DeskJet 1255, 2700, 4100 Series, Envy 6000, 6400 Series | Eligible for Instant Ink | 3YM58AN
I grabbed HP 67XL Tri-Color High-Yield Ink Cartridge as the direct upgrade for the same DeskJet and Envy printers that take the standard 67. It is rated around 200 pages, double the standard cartridge, in the same slot with the same painless setup. For my home printer, that doubling is the difference between replacing ink every school term and replacing it every few months. —Kevin Moore
I've been using HP 67XL Tri-Color High-Yield Ink Cartridge through a season of worksheets, permission slips, and birthday banners, and honestly it fades into the background, which is what I want from ink. Print quality matched the standard 67 page for page, bright on plain paper and respectable on the glossy photo sheets I fed it. The printer reported levels honestly, with no sudden drop from half to empty. —Laura Scott
I tried HP 67XL Tri-Color High-Yield Ink Cartridge alongside its standard sibling to judge whether the XL premium is real, and the math convinced me: fewer cartridges, fewer interruptions, and a lower cost per page. It will not turn a DeskJet into a photo lab, and heavy photographers should look at the 64XL's printer family instead. For the huge number of homes running a 2700 or 4100 series machine, this is the sensible default. —Brian Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Hp Tri-color Ink Cartridges Is Necessary
The right tri-color cartridge is necessary because color printing fails in the most annoying way possible: one of the three inks runs dry and every print turns into a pink-tinted negotiation. A genuine HP cartridge matched to your printer keeps the color balance the machine was calibrated for, so skin tones, logos, and school projects come out looking like the screen promised. That reliability is what you are actually buying.
Compatibility is the other half of necessity. HP's lineup is a maze of numbers, and a cartridge that physically resembles yours can still be wrong for the printer, which the machine will tell you at the worst moment. Every cartridge I tested lists its families plainly: 67 and 67XL for the common DeskJet and Envy lines, 63/65 for older models, 68 for the newest Envys, 64XL for the photo printers. Matching the number to the model is the whole game.
Finally, yield decides whether printing feels like a utility or a chore. Standard cartridges around 100 pages suit occasional printers, while the XL versions at 200 and 415 pages suit families and home offices that print weekly. Choosing the right yield up front means fewer emergency purchases, fewer half-finished print jobs, and a printer that is simply ready when someone needs it, which is all anyone asks of ink.
My Buying Guides on Hp Tri-color Ink Cartridges
Why I Looked for Hp Tri-Color Ink Cartridges
A deadline print job died on an empty color cartridge one time too many, so I set out to learn which HP tri-color options actually fit my printers and my printing volume.
I tested the standard 67, the combined 63/65, the newer 68, and both XL cartridges across the machines in my house.
What I Check Before Buying
I check the printer model against the cartridge's compatibility list before anything else, because HP numbers look similar and the wrong one is a wasted purchase.
Then I check the rated yield in pages and whether the cartridge is Instant Ink eligible, in case the subscription works out cheaper for my volume.
My Preference for Standard or High-Yield XL Cartridges
For a printer that wakes up twice a month, a standard cartridge is fine and fresher ink cycles through before it can sit too long.
For family and office printers, XL wins every time in my house: double or quadruple the pages, fewer swaps, and a lower cost per printed page.
What I Look for in Quality
Quality means even color with no banding, honest ink level reporting, and a cartridge the printer accepts instantly without error lights or alignment fights.
I also print one photo early in the cartridge's life. If skin tones look wrong on page ten, they will not improve by page ninety.
How I Compare Prices
I compare cost per page using the rated yield, never the shelf price alone, because the XL boxes look expensive until you divide.
I also price the subscription route for the same volume. Instant Ink suits steady printers, while XL cartridges suit bursty ones like mine.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Confirm your exact printer model, buy the yield that matches your real volume, and keep one sealed spare so a deadline never depends on a store run.
Store spares flat in a cool drawer, install with clean hands, and run the printer at least every couple of weeks to keep any cartridge healthy.
Final Thoughts
For most homes, the HP 67XL is the sweet spot: it fits the most common DeskJet and Envy printers, doubles the standard yield, and lowers the cost per page without changing anything about your routine. The standard 67 is fine for light use, the 63/65 keeps older printers simple, the 68 serves the newest Envys, and the 64XL is the photo printer's best friend.
Whichever number your printer takes, buy the yield honestly. Occasional printers should not pay for pages they will never use, and heavy printers should stop feeding standard cartridges into a busy machine. Match those two things and HP color ink becomes the most boring, reliable part of your desk, which is exactly what ink should be.