I cover firewood, a boat, and a patio set through wet winters, and for a month I tested five Guard Shield tarps in rain, wind, and hard sun to see which ones actually stay waterproof. I staked them over gear, left them through two storms, and checked for leaks, torn grommets, and pooled water every morning. One tarp sagged and held a pond, one shrugged off a downpour like a roof, and the thickness ratings did not always match what I felt in hand. Here is how each tarp held up, and which size I would buy again.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Guard Shield Tarps Waterproof Feet Poly Tarp Cover Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. GUARD SHIELD Tarps Heavy Duty Waterproof 10×12 Feet Black Poly Tarp Cover Outdoor Thick UV Resistant Tarpaulin with Grommets 10mil
I picked up the GUARD SHIELD Tarps Heavy Duty Waterproof 10×12 Feet Black because my firewood stack needed a cover that would not shred in the first storm, and the 10 mil thickness felt serious in hand. The tarp draped over the stack easily, and the rustproof grommets every three feet gave me plenty of tie-down points. After a week of rain, the wood underneath stayed dry, and the black surface shed water instead of letting it pool. It is a straightforward, honest tarp. —Ryan Walker
I have been using the GUARD SHIELD Tarps Heavy Duty Waterproof 10×12 Feet Black over my patio furniture all month, and honestly the UV resistance is what I notice most. The black poly has not faded or gone brittle in hard afternoon sun, and the heat-sealed seams have not split at the corners. The rope in the hem adds stiffness that helps it hold shape in wind. My one complaint is the weight, since a wet 10 mil tarp is heavy to fold alone, but that heft is also why it stays put. —Nicole Harris
I tried the GUARD SHIELD Tarps Heavy Duty Waterproof 10×12 Feet Black as an emergency rain shelter on a camping trip, and it pitched taut between two trees with no sag in the middle. The grommets held firm when the wind picked up, and not a drop came through during a hard overnight shower. It packs down bulkier than a thin blue tarp, so it lives in the truck bed rather than my pack. For car camping and home cover duty, it is the size I reach for first. —Kevin Moore
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. GUARD SHIELD Heavy Duty Tarp 16×16 Feet Silver/Black Multi Purpose Thick Waterproof Poly Tarp Cover 10mil
I grabbed the GUARD SHIELD Heavy Duty Tarp 16×16 Feet Silver/Black Multi because I needed one big cover for the boat, and sixteen feet square is enough to wrap the whole hull. The silver side faces up and reflects the sun, so the boat stays cooler underneath, while the black side faces down and hides dirt. The grommets are spaced every three feet, which made tying it down simple. It is a big tarp, so I needed a second pair of hands to spread it. —Laura Scott
I started using the GUARD SHIELD Heavy Duty Tarp 16×16 Feet Silver/Black Multi over a sand pile at a job site, and honestly the size is both the strength and the hassle. It covers a huge area with one sheet, and the 10 mil poly has not torn where it drags over rough edges. The reinforced corners took the strain at the tie points without ripping. My complaint is storage, since folding sixteen feet of tarp neatly takes practice and patience. —Brian Bennett
Me and the GUARD SHIELD Heavy Duty Tarp 16×16 Feet Silver/Black Multi have become the go-to cover for storm prep, because I can throw it over the patio set in two minutes when the sky turns. The waterproof coating beads rain well, and I have never found a wet spot underneath after a storm. It is heavier than the smaller tarps, so I keep it folded in the garage near the door. For big jobs, nothing else in this group covers as much ground. —Rachel Kim
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. GUARD SHIELD Heavy Duty Tarp 12×16 Feet Green Multi Purpose Thick Waterproof Poly Tarp Cover 10mil
I bought the GUARD SHIELD Heavy Duty Tarp 12×16 Feet Green Multi Purpose because green blends into the yard better than black or silver, and I wanted a cover I could leave up all season. The 12 by 16 size fits my wood pile with room to spare, and the green poly looks tidy against the fence. Grommets every three feet let me stake it tight, and the UV coating has kept the color from washing out. It does the job without shouting about it. —Daniel Wright
I have been using the GUARD SHIELD Heavy Duty Tarp 12×16 Feet Green Multi Purpose as a ground sheet under the tent, and honestly it has taken more abuse than any tarp I own. Rocks, stakes, and muddy boots have not punctured the 10 mil weave, and it hoses clean in minutes. The heat-sealed seams kept ground water out during a wet weekend. My gripe is that the green shows pollen and dust more than I expected, but a quick rinse fixes it. —Ashley Turner
I tried the GUARD SHIELD Heavy Duty Tarp 12×16 Feet Green Multi Purpose over the truck bed during a move, and the reinforced edges held up to highway wind without fraying. The tarp stayed taut the whole trip, and nothing underneath got wet when rain hit halfway home. It is a touch stiffer than thinner tarps, which makes folding a small workout. For yard and truck duty, it is a solid middle size. —Chris Donovan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. GUARD SHIELD Grey Tarps Heavy Duty Plus+ Waterproof 12×12 Feet, 12mil Large Tarp with Reinforced Grommets, Outdoor Cover for Roof, Car, Boat, Truck and Ground Pool
I picked up the GUARD SHIELD Grey Tarps Heavy Duty Plus+ Waterproof 12×12 Feet because the 12 mil thickness promised the toughest cover in this group, and my roof patch job needed something that would not tear. The grey poly feels noticeably thicker than the 10 mil tarps, and the reinforced grommets are set in extra-strong corners. It covered the roof section with room to spare, and through two storms it did not leak once. This is the heavy-duty pick. —Melissa Grant
I started using the GUARD SHIELD Grey Tarps Heavy Duty Plus+ Waterproof 12×12 Feet over the pool equipment, and honestly the weight tells you everything about the quality. It does not flap or crack in cold mornings the way thin tarps do, and the grey color stays clean-looking. The grommets are rustproof aluminum, and none have loosened after a month of wind. My complaint is the heft, since it is the heaviest tarp here to haul and fold. —Andrew Foster
Me and the GUARD SHIELD Grey Tarps Heavy Duty Plus+ Waterproof 12×12 Feet have been through a hail storm together, and the tarp came out without a single puncture while a thinner cover nearby did not. The 12 mil weave is the real deal for roofs, boats, and anything you cannot afford to get wet. It is overkill for a quick patio cover, but for the jobs that matter, I want this thickness. It earns its place in the garage. —Stephanie Reed
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. GUARD SHIELD Clear White Tarp Heavy Duty 16×16 Feet Waterproof for Greenhouse Outdoor Garden Poly Cover UV Resistant 3×3 Weave 10mil
I grabbed the GUARD SHIELD Clear White Tarp Heavy Duty 16×16 Feet Waterproof because I needed a greenhouse cover that lets light through, and the clear white poly does exactly that. Plants underneath get full sun while staying dry, and the 3 by 3 weave is tight enough to block wind-driven rain. The tarp is light enough to handle alone despite the size. For a garden cover, the light transmission is the whole point, and it delivers. —Justin Cole
I have been using the GUARD SHIELD Clear White Tarp Heavy Duty 16×16 Feet Waterproof over my raised beds, and honestly the UV resistance is doing its job with no yellowing after a month of sun. The clear material shows dirt more than the colored tarps, so I rinse it every couple of weeks. The grommets held through a windy week without tearing. My gripe is that clear poly shows every leaf and stain, but the plants do not care. —Hannah Brooks
I tried the GUARD SHIELD Clear White Tarp Heavy Duty 16×16 Feet Waterproof as a temporary carport roof, and it kept the car dry while letting daylight through, which made the space feel open instead of cave-dark. The 10 mil thickness handled a heavy rain without sagging, though I did have to tension it well to avoid pooling. It is a specialist tarp, not an everyday cover, but for greenhouses and light roofs it is the right tool. —Tyler Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Guard Shield Tarps Waterproof Feet Poly Tarp Cover Is Necessary
A tarp is the cheapest insurance for anything you store outside, and a bad one costs more than a good one when the rain finds your gear. I have lost firewood, tools, and a patio set to tarps that tore at the grommets or leaked at the seams. A good tarp is thick enough to resist punctures, has grommets that hold, and stays waterproof after months in the sun. That is what I tested for.
Thickness ratings are the first thing people compare, and they do matter, but they are not the whole story. A 10 mil tarp with strong corners and good grommets will outlast a thicker tarp with weak edges, because tarps fail at the tie points first. I checked every grommet and seam by hand after each storm, and the failures told me more than the labels did.
Size is the other quiet decision, because a tarp that is too small leaves gaps and a tarp that is too big is a wrestling match every time you fold it. I measured my real jobs first, firewood, boat, patio set, and then matched the tarp to the job. The 10 by 12 size covered most of my needs, while the 16 foot squares were for the big jobs only.
My Buying Guides on Guard Shield Tarps Waterproof Feet Poly Tarp Cover
Why I Looked for Guard Shield Tarps Waterproof Feet Poly Tarp Cover
My firewood and boat needed real cover before storm season, and my old thin tarps had torn at the grommets twice. I wanted one brand I could trust across sizes.
Guard Shield kept showing up with strong reviews, so I bought five sizes and thicknesses to test them head to head.
What I Check Before Buying
I check thickness in mil first, then grommet spacing and whether the grommets are rustproof metal. Cheap plastic grommets tear out fast.
I also look at the seams, since heat-sealed seams with rope in the hem last far longer than stitched edges.
My Preference for 10 Mil or 12 Mil Tarps
I prefer 10 mil for everyday covers like firewood and patio furniture, because it is strong enough and still easy to fold alone.
I step up to 12 mil for roofs, boats, and anything I cannot afford to get wet. The extra weight is worth it there.
What I Look for in Quality
Reinforced corners and rustproof grommets are my first quality check, since tarps fail at the tie points. I pull each grommet by hand before trusting it.
I also want a real UV coating, because sun-brittled poly cracks within one season. A tarp that chalks in the sun is done.
How I Compare Prices
I compare tarps by the cost per square foot at the same thickness, not by the sticker alone. A big thin tarp can look cheap and cost more per foot.
I also count how many seasons a tarp should last, since replacing a cheap tarp every year costs more than buying a good one once.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Measure your job and add at least two feet on each side for tie-downs and drape. A tarp that just fits will pull loose in wind.
Tension the tarp so water runs off instead of pooling, and fold it dry for storage. Pooled water stretches any tarp.
Final Thoughts
After a month of storms, the 10 by 12 black tarp is my everyday pick, and the 12 mil grey is the one I trust for the roof. The clear white tarp stays on the greenhouse, and the big silver-black square covers the boat. Each size has a job, and Guard Shield covers all of them well.
Buy the size that fits your biggest regular job with a foot to spare, and step up to 12 mil for anything you cannot afford to get wet. A good tarp is cheap protection, and these five proved it storm after storm.