I spent two weeks punching holes in belts, watch straps, dog collars, and leather craft projects, testing five leather hole punch sets side by side to find which ones cut clean holes without tearing or dulling. I checked how each tool handled thick belt leather versus thin craft leather, how comfortable the grips felt after dozens of punches, and whether the cutting edges stayed sharp. Some sets punched perfect circles every time, one left ragged edges on thick leather, and the differences in build quality were obvious within the first hour. Here is what I found.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The General Tools Leather Hole Punch Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Spurtar Hollow Punch Set 12 Pieces 1/8"- 3/4" Heavy Duty Carbon Steel Round Leather Hole Tool Leather Punch Set Kit for Watch Cloth Belt Gaskets with Storage Bag (Black)
I picked up Spurtar Hollow Punch Set 12 Pieces 1/8"- 3/4" Heavy Duty because twelve sizes in one set sounded perfect for belts, watch straps, and gaskets, and I wanted a hollow punch that works with a mallet. The carbon steel punches felt heavy and solid, each size cut a clean circle in thick belt leather with a few firm taps, and the canvas storage bag kept all twelve organized. The range from tiny to large covered every project I tried. —Ashley Turner
I have been using Spurtar Hollow Punch Set 12 Pieces 1/8"- 3/4" Heavy Duty for two weeks now, and honestly the cutting edges have stayed impressively sharp. The punches cut cleanly through rubber, canvas, and thick leather without tearing, and the ground tips leave holes with smooth edges that need no trimming. My one complaint is that you need a mallet and a cutting mat, so it is less convenient than pliers for a quick belt adjustment. —Chris Donovan
I tried Spurtar Hollow Punch Set 12 Pieces 1/8"- 3/4" Heavy Duty on a thick leather dog collar, and the largest sizes punched through the doubled leather cleanly where pliers would have struggled. The set also worked well on gasket material and plastic sheeting, and the storage bag made it easy to carry to the workshop. For anyone who works with leather regularly, this twelve-piece set is the most versatile option I tested. —Melissa Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Leather Hole Punch Set for Belts, Watch Bands and Leather Crafts, Heavy Duty 6-Piece Hollow Punch Set with Sizes 1/16, 5/64, 3/32, 1/8, 9/64 and 5/32 Inch
I grabbed Leather Hole Punch Set for Belts because the six-piece hollow set promised clean holes in belts, watch bands, and leather crafts at a very fair size range. The alloy steel punches felt well made for the size, each punch cut a neat hole in belt leather with a mallet, and the small sizes were perfect for watch strap adjustments. The set covered the common hole sizes from tiny to medium without any wasted pieces. —Andrew Foster
I have been using Leather Hole Punch Set for Belts for two weeks now, and honestly the value is what stands out most. Six useful sizes, clean cuts, and sturdy steel at a modest cost make it easy to recommend for occasional leather work. My one complaint is that the smallest punches can clog with leather plugs, so I clear them with a pin after every few holes to keep the cuts clean. —Stephanie Reed
I tried Leather Hole Punch Set for Belts on a canvas strap and a vinyl watch band, and it punched both materials cleanly without cracking or fraying the edges. The heat-treated steel held its edge through dozens of holes, and the compact set fits easily in a craft drawer. For belts, watch bands, and small leather projects, this six-piece set does the job well. —Justin Cole
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Diyife Professional Leather Hole Puncher, Full Set Punch Tool Kits for Belt, Watch Band, Shoe, Crafting, Handbag Straps, Fabric, with Extra Punch Plates and Ruler, Multi Hole Sizes Make – Blue
I bought Diyife Professional Leather Hole Puncher because the full kit with spare plates, a screwdriver, and a ruler sounded like the most complete belt punch setup, and the revolving pliers design is faster than a mallet. The six rotating hole sizes covered every belt I own, the squeeze action punched clean holes in thick leather with one firm grip, and the spare plates and ruler made setup easy. It felt like a proper tool, not a toy. —Hannah Brooks
I have been using Diyife Professional Leather Hole Puncher for two weeks now, and honestly the convenience is what keeps it on my workbench. I can add a hole to a belt in seconds without finding a mallet, and the rotating wheel clicks firmly into each size so I never punch the wrong diameter. My one complaint is that very thick doubled leather needs two squeezes, so I work slowly on heavy belts. —Tyler Bennett
I tried Diyife Professional Leather Hole Puncher on a watch strap, a handbag strap, and a leather dog collar, and it handled all three with clean, round holes and no tearing. The blue plated steel feels sturdy, the extra punch plates mean I always have a sharp backup, and the ruler helped me space holes evenly. For quick belt and strap adjustments, this full kit is the most convenient option I tested. —Olivia Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. 8 Pcs Leather Circle Cutter Tool Set, Leather Punch Tool, High Carbon Steel Round Craft Punching Tools for DIY Craft, Punching Die Set, 8 Sizes 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55mm
I picked up 8 Pcs Leather Circle Cutter Tool Set because the eight large circle sizes promised clean cuts for craft projects, and I wanted a hollow punch set for bigger holes than belt pliers can make. The high carbon steel cutters felt solid, each size punched a clean circle in leather and craft foam, and the range from twenty to fifty-five millimeters covered coasters, patches, and decorative cutouts. The set worked exactly as advertised on the first try. —Nathan Pierce
I have been using 8 Pcs Leather Circle Cutter Tool Set for two weeks now, and honestly the clean edges are what impress me most. The sharp circular cutters leave smooth holes with no fraying, and they cut through layered leather and thick felt without crushing the material. My one complaint is that the set is best for flat craft work, so it is less handy than pliers for a belt that needs one quick extra hole. —Sarah Mitchell
I tried 8 Pcs Leather Circle Cutter Tool Set on leather patches for a jacket and on craft foam for a kids project, and both came out with crisp, professional-looking circles. The alloy steel held its edge through many cuts, and the set stored neatly in the craft box. For leather crafters who need larger clean circles, this eight-piece set is the right tool for the job. —James Carter
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. 2 in 1 Leather Hole Punch, 3/16" 4.5mm Revolving Hole Puncher with Metal Eyelets for Leather, Belts, Watch Bands, Fabric, Plastic, DIY Handmade Production
I grabbed 2 in 1 Leather Hole Punch because the combination of a revolving hole puncher and metal eyelets in one kit sounded clever, and I wanted to try eyelets on a fabric project. The revolving pliers punched a clean four and a half millimeter hole in a belt with one squeeze, and the included eyelets set neatly into the hole for a finished look. It felt sturdy in hand, and the black and red grips were comfortable even after many punches. —Emily Rodriguez
I have been using 2 in 1 Leather Hole Punch for two weeks now, and honestly the eyelet feature is what makes it different from the other pliers I tested. I used it on a canvas bag strap and a leather belt, and the eyelets reinforced the holes beautifully so they will not stretch or tear. My one complaint is that it only offers one hole size, so it cannot replace a multi-size set for varied projects. —Michael Thompson
I tried 2 in 1 Leather Hole Punch on a watch band and a fabric belt, and the single size punched cleanly through both without fraying or cracking. The plated steel feels durable, the eyelets seated firmly with a firm squeeze, and the whole kit fits in a small pouch. For anyone who wants finished, reinforced holes in belts and straps, this two-in-one kit is a smart buy. —Jessica Lee
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why General Tools Leather Hole Punch Is Necessary
A leather hole punch matters because a belt that does not fit, a watch strap with the wrong holes, or a craft project with torn edges all come down to one clean cut. The right tool makes a perfectly round hole in seconds, while the wrong tool tears the leather, leaves ragged edges, or dulls after a few uses. Clean holes are the difference between a repair that looks professional and one that looks rushed.
The real value shows up across many small jobs, from adding a hole to a belt after losing weight to fitting eyelets on a bag strap or punching gaskets in the workshop. A good set handles thick and thin leather alike, stays sharp through dozens of holes, and feels comfortable in the hand. That versatility turns a single-purpose tool into a workshop staple.
Comparing these five sets side by side shows how much the design matters, from hollow punches that need a mallet to revolving pliers that work with one squeeze. The best choice depends on whether you need many sizes, quick belt adjustments, or clean craft circles, and the differences only show up after real use on real leather.
My Buying Guides on General Tools Leather Hole Punch
Why I Looked for General Tools Leather Hole Punch
I was tired of belts that never fit quite right and craft projects with ragged holes, so I went looking for a punch set that could handle thick belt leather and thin watch straps alike. My shortlist had to cut clean circles, stay sharp, and cover the sizes I actually use most often.
What I Check Before Buying
First I check the hole size range and whether the tool is a hollow punch for a mallet or revolving pliers for one-handed use, because that decides how I will actually use it. Then I look at the steel quality, the grip comfort, and whether spare parts or extra sizes are included.
My Preference for Rotary or Hollow Punch Sets
For quick belt adjustments I prefer revolving pliers, because one squeeze makes a clean hole without finding a mallet or a cutting mat. For craft work and thick leather I prefer hollow punch sets, because the mallet-driven cut is cleaner on heavy material and the size range is wider.
What I Look for in Quality
I look for heat-treated steel with sharply ground cutting edges, a comfortable grip that does not slip, and a mechanism that locks firmly into each size. Clean cuts on the first try, no tearing on thick leather, and edges that stay sharp after many holes tell me the tool is built to last.
How I Compare Prices
I compare the cost per usable size rather than the sticker price, since a twelve-piece set can cost less per punch than a small kit. I also weigh whether the set includes a storage case, spare plates, or eyelets, because those extras change the real value of the purchase.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Match the tool to your main job first, then check the size range against your belts and straps before you order. Practice on scrap leather, keep the cutting edges clean, and always punch on a proper mat so the tool stays sharp and your table stays undamaged.
Final Thoughts
After two weeks of steady use, the Spurtar twelve-piece hollow set is the one I would buy first for serious leather work, because the size range and clean cuts covered every project I tried. The Diyife revolving pliers won for quick belt fixes, the six-piece hollow set was the best value, and the circle cutters and eyelet kit each earned their place for craft work.
My advice is simple: pick the tool that matches your main job, check the size range against your belts and straps, and practice on scrap leather first. Used that way, any of these five will give you clean, professional holes, and the right punch will make leather repairs feel easy instead of frustrating.





