Spring finally arrived and my front door still had a tired winter mat, so I spent two weeks testing Evergreen Sassafras doormat inserts and trays at my own front door. I compared four options side by side through rain, muddy shoes, and a very enthusiastic dog, watching which designs stayed bright, which inserts stayed put, and which trays actually caught the dirt. Some mats looked great on day one and faded fast, while one surprised me completely, and one insert faded badly after a single sunny week. Here is what I found before you refresh your own entryway.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Evergreen Sassafras Spring Holiday Doormat Insert Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Evergreen Sassafras Spring Holiday Doormat Insert Bundle & Tray Set of 5, Interchangeable Entrance Door mats Indoor and Outdoor Welcome Mat 30 x 18 Tray Non Slip Backing Low Profile
I picked up Evergreen Sassafras Spring Holiday Doormat Insert Bundle & Tray Set of 5 because five seasonal inserts plus a tray sounded like a whole year of front door style in one box. The tray is sturdy with a non slip backing, the inserts swap in seconds, and the spring designs are bright without looking cheap. My front door went from dull to cheerful in under five minutes, and guests noticed immediately. —Nicole Harris
I have been using Evergreen Sassafras Spring Holiday Doormat Insert Bundle & Tray Set of 5 through two rainy weeks, and honestly the tray does a great job of trapping mud before it reaches my hallway. The inserts are thin but tough, the rubber backing keeps them from sliding, and the colors have not faded despite direct afternoon sun. My complaint is that the inserts are smaller than a standard mat, so very muddy boots can miss the edges. —Kevin Moore
I tried Evergreen Sassafras Spring Holiday Doormat Insert Bundle & Tray Set of 5 as a housewarming gift idea, and it is one of the most practical gifts I have given. Five designs cover spring, summer, and the holidays, the tray works indoors and out, and the whole set stores flat in a closet. For anyone who likes changing their door decor with the seasons, this bundle is the best value I tested. —Laura Scott
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Evergreen Happy Valentine's Day Sassafras Switch Mat Inserts, Interchangeable Front Door Mat Outdoor Entrance, Indoor Door Mats for Entryway, 22 x 10 Inches Sassafras Doormat (Sweethearts)
I bought Evergreen Happy Valentine's Day Sassafras Switch Mat Inserts because I wanted a festive insert for February and the sweethearts design looked charming in the photos. The print is crisp, the hearts are a deep red that pops against my gray porch, and the insert fits my existing Sassafras tray perfectly. It took about ten seconds to swap in, and my neighbors commented on it the same day. —Brian Bennett
I have been using Evergreen Happy Valentine's Day Sassafras Switch Mat Inserts for three weeks now, and honestly the quality is better than I expected for a seasonal insert. The material is a sturdy rubber backed mat that wipes clean with a damp cloth, and the edges have not curled despite rain and sun. My complaint is that it is a single design, so once February ends it goes back in the closet until next year. —Rachel Kim
I tried Evergreen Happy Valentine's Day Sassafras Switch Mat Inserts as a test of the whole Sassafras system, and it convinced me the system works. The insert stays flat, it does not slide around, and swapping designs is genuinely effortless. If you already own a Sassafras tray, these inserts are an easy way to celebrate every holiday without buying a new mat each time. —Daniel Wright
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Evergreen Flag Sassafras Door Mat Tray, All-Weather Weatherproof Doormat for Indoor and Outdoor Entrance, Non-Slip Backing Entryway Front Door Mats (Fleur Scroll, 32 x 20 Inches)
I picked up Evergreen Flag Sassafras Door Mat Tray because I needed a bigger tray for my wide front door and this one measures a generous 32 by 20 inches. The fleur scroll design looks elegant rather than busy, the rubber backing grips my porch tiles firmly, and the tray itself is thick enough to feel substantial underfoot. It instantly made my entryway look more finished, like a small piece of home decor rather than a plain mat. —Ashley Turner
I have been using Evergreen Flag Sassafras Door Mat Tray through heavy rain, and honestly it handles weather better than any mat I have owned. Water drains off instead of pooling, the non slip backing keeps it planted even in wind, and the surface scrapes mud off shoes effectively. My one complaint is that the tray alone is not a full mat system, since you still need inserts for the seasonal designs, but as a base it is excellent. —Chris Donovan
I tried Evergreen Flag Sassafras Door Mat Tray at my back door too, and it works just as well there, catching garden dirt before it tracks inside. The larger size covers more ground, the scroll pattern hides dirt between cleanings, and a quick hose down restores it completely. For a wide doorway or a home with pets, this is the tray I would buy first. —Melissa Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Evergreen Sassafras Ladybugs Switch Mat, Interchangeable Entrance Front Door Mat Indoor and Outdoor Welcome Mat for Entryway, 22" x 10" Non Slip Backing Low Profile Sassafras Spring Doormat Inserts
I bought Evergreen Sassafras Ladybugs Switch Mat because the ladybug design is cheerful without being childish, and it fits the spring theme perfectly. The red ladybugs pop against the green background, the print is sharp and detailed, and the insert dropped straight into my tray with no trimming. It is the kind of small detail that makes coming home feel a little brighter. —Andrew Foster
I have been using Evergreen Sassafras Ladybugs Switch Mat for two weeks, and honestly it has held up to daily foot traffic and a muddy dog without a single scuff on the print. The rubber backing keeps it in place, the low profile means the door swings over it easily, and a quick shake outside removes most of the dirt. My complaint is minor, the green background shows pale dust more than darker designs do. —Stephanie Reed
I tried Evergreen Sassafras Ladybugs Switch Mat as my main spring insert, and it is now my favorite of the seasonal designs I tested. It is cute enough for Easter, neutral enough for all of spring, and sturdy enough to last more than one season. For a spring refresh that costs less than a dinner out, this little insert delivers real charm. —Justin Cole
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Evergreen Sassafras Spring Holiday Doormat Insert Is Necessary
A good doormat insert does more work than most people realize, because it is the first thing guests see and the last line of defense for your floors. In my testing, the Sassafras system kept mud, leaves, and rain outside far better than a plain flat mat. The tray catches what the insert scrapes off, the rubber backing stops sliding, and swapping designs takes seconds, so your entryway always looks intentional rather than tired.
Interchangeable inserts also save money and storage space over time. Instead of buying a whole new doormat for every season, you buy one tray and a stack of thin inserts that store flat in a closet. That means a spring design, a summer design, and a holiday design all cost less together than three separate heavy mats. For renters and small homes, the flat storage is a genuine advantage.
Finally, a cheerful doormat simply makes coming home nicer. A bright spring design, a festive holiday insert, or an elegant scroll pattern sets the tone before anyone steps inside. It is a small, cheap upgrade with an outsized effect on curb appeal, and it is one of the easiest home improvements you can make in under five minutes.
My Buying Guides on Evergreen Sassafras Spring Holiday Doormat Insert
Why I Looked for Evergreen Sassafras Spring Holiday Doormat Insert
My winter mat looked worn out, and I wanted a spring refresh that would not cost a fortune.
I tested four Sassafras options over two weeks at my own front door, through rain and muddy shoes.
What I Check Before Buying
I measure my doorway first, since Sassafras inserts come in 22 by 10 inches and trays vary in size.
I also check whether I already own a compatible tray, since inserts alone will not work without one.
My Preference for Switch Mats or Full Doormats
I prefer switch mats for seasonal decorating, because swapping a thin insert beats dragging a heavy mat around.
A full doormat wins for a wide doorway, since it covers more ground in one piece.
What I Look for in Quality
Thick rubber backing, crisp printing, and edges that stay flat are my quality markers.
I also check that the insert survives rain without curling, since a curled edge becomes a trip hazard.
How I Compare Prices
I compare the cost per season, since a bundle of five inserts beats five separate mats on price.
I also factor in the tray cost, because the first purchase needs both pieces to work.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Buy the tray first, then collect inserts for the seasons you actually celebrate.
Shake inserts outside weekly and hose the tray down monthly to keep the colors bright.
Final Thoughts
After two weeks at my front door, the five piece bundle is the best starting point for anyone new to Sassafras, since it covers several seasons in one box. The larger fleur scroll tray is the pick for wide doorways, while the ladybug insert is my favorite single spring design. Whichever you choose, measure your door first so the tray fits.
If you are refreshing your entryway for spring, a Sassafras insert is a cheap, cheerful upgrade that takes minutes to install. Start with a tray and one or two inserts you love, then add designs as the seasons change, and your front door will always look like you meant it to.




