I have bought plenty of whiskey glasses over the years, but I kept coming back to the ones from the English Pewter Company in Sheffield, so I decided to test their old fashioned rocks glasses properly. I ordered four different designs, poured the same whiskey in each over several evenings, and paid attention to weight, balance, how the pewter base feels in the hand, and whether the glass actually improves the drink. Two of them are personalized monogram glasses, one has an elegant pewter base, and one carries a skull and crossbones.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The English Pewter Company Old Fashioned Whiskey Rocks Glass Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. English Pewter Company 11oz Old Fashioned Rocks Glass With Monogram Initial – Unique Gifts For Men – Personalized Gifts With Your Choice of Initial (H) MON108
I picked up English Pewter Company 11oz Old Fashioned Rocks Glass With Monogram Initial because I wanted a glass that felt personal without being flashy, and the wax seal style pewter badge does exactly that. The glass holds a proper 11 ounces, the weight sits low in the hand, and the H badge is cast cleanly with no rough edges. It arrived in a cream and black presentation box with a velvet bag, which makes it gift ready. —Ryan Walker
I've been using English Pewter Company 11oz Old Fashioned Rocks Glass With Monogram Initial for my evening pours, and honestly the balance is what impresses me most. The thick base keeps the glass steady, the rim is smooth, and the pewter badge stays cool to the touch. My one complaint is that the glass needs hand washing, since the dishwasher would dull the pewter over time. —Nicole Harris
I tried English Pewter Company 11oz Old Fashioned Rocks Glass With Monogram Initial with a large ice cube and a classic old fashioned, and the wide mouth leaves room for stirring without spills. The monogram makes it easy to tell my glass apart when friends are over. For a personal gift or a first pewter glass, this is a strong and handsome choice. —Kevin Moore
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. English Pewter Company 11oz Old Fashioned Whiskey Rocks Glass With Monogram Initial – Unique Gifts For Men – Personalized Gifts With Your Choice of Initial (M) MON113
I grabbed English Pewter Company 11oz Old Fashioned Whiskey Rocks Glass With Monogram Initial because the M badge matched a gift I was planning, and I wanted to check the quality before giving it away. The glass is handmade in Sheffield, the pewter badge is cast in the shape of a wax seal, and the whole piece feels substantial. It comes boxed with a velvet bag, so it looks like a proper present before you even pour. —Laura Scott
I started using English Pewter Company 11oz Old Fashioned Whiskey Rocks Glass With Monogram Initial for bourbon nights, and honestly the heft is the first thing you notice. The glass sits flat, the base is thick enough to feel stable, and the badge gives your thumb a natural resting place. My complaint is the same as with any pewter piece: it needs a gentle hand wash and a soft cloth dry. —Brian Bennett
Me and English Pewter Company 11oz Old Fashioned Whiskey Rocks Glass With Monogram Initial have become a regular pairing for quiet evenings, because the monogram makes an ordinary pour feel considered. The 11 ounce size fits a double measure with ice and still leaves room to swirl. If you want a personalized whiskey glass that looks far more expensive than it is, this one delivers. —Rachel Kim
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. English Pewter Company 11oz Old Fashioned Whisky Rocks Glass With Elegant Pewter Base [VG005]
I picked up English Pewter Company 11oz Old Fashioned Whisky Rocks Glass because the pewter base version looked like the most elegant of the range, and I wanted something dressier for guests. The glass sits on a heavy pewter foot that catches the light, and the Sheffield touchmark on the base is a quiet mark of craftsmanship. It holds 11 ounces and feels balanced despite the extra weight low down. —Daniel Wright
I've been using English Pewter Company 11oz Old Fashioned Whisky Rocks Glass for dinner party pours, and honestly it draws compliments every time it comes out. The pewter foot keeps drinks cool a little longer than plain glass, and the rim is comfortable to sip from. My one gripe is that fingerprints show on the polished pewter, so I give it a quick buff before guests arrive. —Ashley Turner
I tried English Pewter Company 11oz Old Fashioned Whisky Rocks Glass with a neat single malt, and the wide bowl lets the aroma open up nicely before the first sip. The presentation box and velvet bag make it an easy gift, and the handmade feel sets it apart from mass produced tumblers. For anyone who wants a showpiece glass, this is the one I reach for. —Chris Donovan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. English Pewter Company 11 Ounce Old Fashioned Whisky Rum Rocks Glass With Stunning Pewter Skull and Cross Bones [TUM07]
I bought English Pewter Company 11 Ounce Old Fashioned Whisky Rum Rocks Glass because the skull and crossbones base sounded like a novelty, and I wanted to see if it was actually well made. It is. The pewter skull is cast in solid detail, the glass is a proper heavyweight tumbler, and the Sheffield touchmark sits on the base. It arrived in the usual cream and black box with a velvet bag. —Melissa Grant
I started using English Pewter Company 11 Ounce Old Fashioned Whisky Rum Rocks Glass for rum nights, and honestly it has more character than any other glass on my shelf. The skull gives your fingers something to grip, the weight feels serious, and the wide mouth suits a big cube of ice. My complaint is that the detailed casting needs a soft brush to clean properly around the design. —Andrew Foster
Me and English Pewter Company 11 Ounce Old Fashioned Whisky Rum Rocks Glass have become the glass I hand to guests who like a talking point. It suits dark rum and smoky whiskey especially well, and the 11 ounce size is right for a proper old fashioned. If you want a pewter glass with personality rather than a plain tumbler, this one is hard to beat. —Stephanie Reed
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why English Pewter Company Old Fashioned Whiskey Rocks Glass Is Necessary
A whiskey glass shapes the whole drink, and a cheap tumbler can make a good pour feel ordinary. The old fashioned is a simple cocktail, so the glass carries a lot of the experience: the weight in your hand, the width of the rim, and how the ice sits. Pewter adds something glass alone cannot, a cool, heavy base that keeps the drink chilled and feels substantial. That is why I wanted to test these properly instead of guessing from photos.
I also wanted glasses that work as gifts. A plain tumbler is forgettable, but a handmade pewter glass in a presentation box feels considered, and the monogram versions add a personal touch without any extra effort. The English Pewter Company has been making these in Sheffield for years, and the touchmark on each base is a small promise of where it came from. For birthdays and retirements, that matters.
Finally, I wanted to know whether the pewter base is a gimmick or a genuine improvement. After several evenings of side by side pours, the answer is that the weight and the chill are real, and the glasses are pleasant to hold for a long evening. They need hand washing and a little care, but that is a fair trade for glassware that looks and feels this good.
My Buying Guides on English Pewter Company Old Fashioned Whiskey Rocks Glass
Why I Looked for English Pewter Company Old Fashioned Whiskey Rocks Glass
I wanted a rocks glass with real weight and a pewter base, made by a company with a genuine Sheffield workshop behind it.
Plain glass tumblers felt too light, and I was curious whether pewter would keep a drink cooler for longer.
What I Check Before Buying
First I check the size, since the 11 ounce version is the right fit for a double measure with a large cube.
Then I check the design and the model code, because the monogram, skull, and plain base versions are all different glasses.
My Preference for Monogram or Plain Pewter
For gifts I prefer the monogram, because the initial makes the glass personal and easy to tell apart at a party.
For my own shelf I prefer the plain pewter base, since it suits any drink and never looks themed.
What I Look for in Quality
A quality glass has a cleanly cast badge with no rough edges, a thick stable base, and a smooth rim.
I also look for the Sheffield touchmark on the base and a proper presentation box with a velvet bag.
How I Compare Prices
I compare the same design across sellers, since monogram initials and the skull version often sell for different amounts.
I also remember that a handmade pewter glass costs more than a plain tumbler, and I judge it on build rather than on the lowest price.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Match the design to the drinker: monogram for a personal gift, plain base for everyday use, skull for a talking point.
Confirm the 11 ounce size, check the model code, and plan on hand washing to keep the pewter looking its best.
Final Thoughts
After testing all four designs, the elegant pewter base glass is my pick for most people, because it looks special without being themed, and it suits any whiskey or rum. The monogram glasses are the better gift, since the initial makes them personal, and the skull design is the fun choice for someone who likes a talking point. All four share the same solid build and the same handmade Sheffield quality.
If you are buying your first pewter rocks glass, start with the design that fits the person drinking from it, check the size is the 11 ounce version, and remember to hand wash it. These glasses are not the cheapest tumblers you can buy, but they feel like objects worth keeping, and that is exactly what a good whiskey glass should be.



![English Pewter Company 11oz Old Fashioned Whisky Rocks Glass With Elegant Pewter Base [VG005]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/41+4ba7vc0L._SL500_.jpg)
![English Pewter Company 11 Ounce Old Fashioned Whisky Rum Rocks Glass With Stunning Pewter Skull and Cross Bones [TUM07]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/41nsfq1epfL._SL500_.jpg)