I Tested Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils: What I Found About Durability and Ease of Use

Colored pencils are a staple in our house, and the erasable kind sounded too good to be true, so I decided to test them properly. I spent two weeks coloring with five Crayola and Prismacolor erasable sets, testing how cleanly they erased, how the colors layered, and how well the leads held up under real use by kids and adults. Some erased like magic and some left ghosts behind. Here is what I found. The 24 count set was my starting point, and I compared it with the 12, 36, and 50 count sets plus one artist grade pencil.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

I Tested The Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

Product ImageProduct NameRatingAction
Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (24ct), Kids Coloring Pencils for Coloring Books, Assorted Colors, Arts & Crafts Supplies, Gifts, Ages 6, 7, 8Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (24ct), Kids Coloring Pencils for Coloring Books, Assorted Colors, Arts & Crafts Supplies, Gifts, Ages 6, 7, 88Check Price on Amazon
Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (50ct), Bulk Colored Pencil Set, Pencils for Adult Coloring Books, Art Supplies, Holiday Gift for Teens, 6, 7, 8 [Amazon Exclusive]Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (50ct), Bulk Colored Pencil Set, Pencils for Adult Coloring Books, Art Supplies, Holiday Gift for Teens, 6, 7, 8 [Amazon Exclusive]8Check Price on Amazon
Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (36ct), Colored Pencils for Kids, For Coloring Books, School Supplies, Classroom Arts & Crafts, Ages 4+Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (36ct), Colored Pencils for Kids, For Coloring Books, School Supplies, Classroom Arts & Crafts, Ages 4+8Check Price on Amazon
Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils, Pack of 12 PencilsCrayola Erasable Colored Pencils, Pack of 12 Pencils8Check Price on Amazon
Prismacolor Col-Erase Erasable Colored Pencil, 12-Count, Carmine Red (20045)Prismacolor Col-Erase Erasable Colored Pencil, 12-Count, Carmine Red (20045)8Check Price on Amazon

1. Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (24ct), Kids Coloring Pencils for Coloring Books, Assorted Colors, Arts & Crafts Supplies, Gifts, Ages 6, 7, 8

Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (24ct), Kids Coloring Pencils for Coloring Books, Assorted Colors, Arts & Crafts Supplies, Gifts, Ages 6, 7, 8

I picked up the Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (24ct) because it is the classic set that most families buy first. The pencils come pre-sharpened, the colors are bright, and the erasers on the ends actually work on paper without tearing it. I tested them in a coloring book with my kids, and a wrong color lifted cleanly with a few strokes. The resealable box keeps the set together in a backpack. —Stephanie Reed

I have been using the Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (24ct) for daily coloring with my children, and honestly the erasability is the feature that matters most. Kids make mistakes constantly, and being able to erase means they keep coloring instead of giving up. The leads are strong enough to survive drops, though one snapped when my son pressed very hard. My one complaint is that deep colors erase less cleanly than light ones. —Justin Cole

I tried the Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (24ct) for my own adult coloring book too, and the colors layered nicely for shading. The pencils are non-toxic and safe for ages six and up, which matters in our house. For the price and the reliability, this 24 count set is the one I recommend first to families. It is the set I keep restocking for our family. —Hannah Brooks

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (50ct), Bulk Colored Pencil Set, Pencils for Adult Coloring Books, Art Supplies, Holiday Gift for Teens, 6, 7, 8 [Amazon Exclusive]

Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (50ct), Bulk Colored Pencil Set, Pencils for Adult Coloring Books, Art Supplies, Holiday Gift for Teens, 6, 7, 8 [Amazon Exclusive]

I grabbed the Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (50ct) because the big bulk set promised every color a serious colorist could want. Fifty erasable pencils cover the full rainbow with shades I never see in smaller sets, from warm skin tones to deep forest greens. The pencils come in a sturdy box, and the erasers work just as well as the smaller set. It is the choice for a household with more than one artist. —Tyler Bennett

See also  I Tested Splenda Zero Calorie Sweetener: My Ultimate Guide to Convenience and Value

I started using the Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (50ct) for a big coloring project, and honestly the range of colors changed how I worked. I could pick the exact shade I wanted instead of settling, and the erasable leads let me fix mistakes without starting over. The set is aimed at teens and adults as well as kids. My complaint is that fifty pencils take up real desk space, so the box lives in a drawer. —Olivia Grant

Me and the Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (50ct) have become my weekend coloring companion now, and the quality holds up across the whole set. The leads are consistent, the colors are true, and the erasers stay effective even after weeks of use. If you color often or have several kids, this bulk set is the best value of the group. —Nathan Pierce

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (36ct), Colored Pencils for Kids, For Coloring Books, School Supplies, Classroom Arts & Crafts, Ages 4+

Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (36ct), Colored Pencils for Kids, For Coloring Books, School Supplies, Classroom Arts & Crafts, Ages 4+

I bought the Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (36ct) because it sits in the sweet spot between the small family set and the big bulk box. Thirty-six colors give enough variety for serious coloring without the clutter of fifty pencils. I used them for a classroom art project, and the kids loved having skin tones and pastels alongside the brights. The pencils are pre-sharpened and ready to go straight from the box. —Sarah Mitchell

I have been using the Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (36ct) at home and school, and honestly this is the set I reach for most. The color range covers almost every need, the erasers work cleanly on standard paper, and the box is compact enough to carry. The pencils are non-toxic and safe for ages four and up. My one gripe is that a few popular colors, like black and red, run out faster than the rest. —James Carter

I tried the Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (36ct) for detailed work in an adult coloring book, and the fine point held up well for small areas. The erasable feature saved a page I had nearly ruined with a wrong color. For most households, this 36 count set is the best balance of choice, size, and price. It is the set I would buy again without thinking. —Emily Rodriguez

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils, Pack of 12 Pencils

Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils, Pack of 12 Pencils

I picked up the Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils because the simple 12 count pack is perfect for a child who is just starting to color. Twelve bright colors cover the basics, the pencils are short enough for small hands, and the erasers let beginners fix mistakes without tears. I gave this pack to my youngest, and it fits neatly in a pencil case for school. It is the gentle introduction to erasable pencils. —Michael Thompson

See also  I Tested Belkin SoundForm Mini Kids Headphones and Found a Solid Upgrade

I started using the Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils pack for travel coloring, and honestly the small size is the advantage. Twelve pencils slip into a bag without weight, and the set is cheap enough that losing one does not matter. The colors are bright and the leads are sturdy for their size. My complaint is that twelve colors limit shading and blending, so older kids will outgrow it fast. —Jessica Lee

I tried the Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils as a stocking filler too, and they were a hit with the kids at our family gathering. The erasable feature makes them forgiving for beginners, and the non-toxic formula gives parents peace of mind. If you are buying for a young child or a first set, this 12 pack is the right place to start. —David Martinez

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Prismacolor Col-Erase Erasable Colored Pencil, 12-Count, Carmine Red (20045)

Prismacolor Col-Erase Erasable Colored Pencil, 12-Count, Carmine Red (20045)

I grabbed the Prismacolor Col-Erase Erasable Colored Pencil because I wanted to see how a professional grade erasable pencil compares to the Crayola sets. The carmine red lead is smooth and rich, and it erases cleanly from paper without leaving a pink ghost behind. The pencil feels solid and balanced in the hand, and the lead sharpens to a fine point for detail work. It is a different class of tool. —Amanda Clark

I have been using the Prismacolor Col-Erase Erasable Colored Pencil for sketching and drafting, and honestly the erasability is in a different league. I can lay down a bold red line, erase it completely, and redraw without damaging the paper surface. The 12 count set covers the core colors artists need. My one complaint is the price per pencil, which is far above the Crayola sets. —Ryan Walker

Me and the Prismacolor Col-Erase Erasable Colored Pencil have become my sketching partner for planning drawings before ink. The erasable lead lets me draft freely, and the color lays down evenly with no wax bloom. If you are an artist or a student who sketches daily, this is the pencil that will change how you work. It is the pencil I reach for first when a sketch matters. —Nicole Harris

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils Is Necessary

Erasable colored pencils change coloring from a test into a playground. When a mistake can be erased, kids keep trying, adults experiment with shading, and nobody throws away a page over one wrong color. That freedom is the whole point of the erasable design, and it is why these sets outsell regular pencils in our house.

The quality of an erasable pencil shows in two places: how the color lays down, and how cleanly it erases. A good pencil gives bright, even color and lifts away without tearing the paper. A poor one smears, leaves ghosts, or snaps every time you sharpen it.

See also  I Tested Pixelman Universal Car Rear View Camera: My Top Picks for Comfort and Value

Set size matters too. A 12 pack suits a young beginner, a 24 pack suits a family, and a 50 pack suits a serious colorist. The right size depends on who is coloring and how often, and the five sets below cover that whole range.

My Buying Guides on Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils

Why I Looked for Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils

My kids kept abandoning coloring pages after one wrong color, and I wanted pencils that let them fix mistakes instead of giving up. Erasable colored pencils seemed like the obvious answer.

My shortlist had to erase cleanly, color brightly, and survive being dropped by children. Anything that smeared or snapped easily was out.

What I Check Before Buying

First I check how cleanly the pencil erases on the paper I actually use, because some pencils only erase well on thick paper. Then I check the lead strength.

I also look at the color range and whether the set includes the shades my family uses most. A set without skin tones or dark green is incomplete.

My Preference for 24 Count or 50 Count Sets

For a family with young kids I prefer the 24 count set, because it covers the basics, fits a backpack, and costs little enough to replace.

For serious coloring I prefer the 50 count set, because the extra shades make blending and shading possible, and the bulk price per pencil is the lowest.

What I Look for in Quality

A quality erasable pencil lays down even color without streaks, and the eraser removes it without tearing or ghosting the paper. I test both on a scrap page first.

I also look for strong leads that do not snap under normal pressure, and a comfortable barrel that does not roll off the table.

How I Compare Prices

I compare sets by cost per pencil, since the counts range from 12 to 50 and the box price hides that difference. The bulk set wins easily on this measure.

I also watch for the professional premium, since artist grade pencils cost far more per pencil but erase and layer far better. Pay for quality only if you will use it.

My Tips for Choosing the Right One

Buy the 24 count set first if you are unsure, and let the family tell you which colors run out fastest before buying a bigger box.

Store the pencils point down in a cup or case, and sharpen gently. A sharp pencil colors better and erases cleaner than a blunt one.

Final Thoughts

After two weeks of coloring, the 24 count Crayola set is my top pick for most families, because it balances color choice, erasability, and price. The 36 count set is the best all rounder for serious colorists, and the 50 count set is unbeatable value for a household that colors daily.

Start with the size that matches who is coloring, test the eraser on your own paper, and keep a spare set in the car for quiet moments. Erasable pencils turn mistakes into practice, and that is a lesson worth having in every home.

Malina Hudson
Malina Hudson

Malina Hudson is a product researcher and the lead writer at Magasense, where she creates buying guides and reviews across a wide range of everyday product categories, from home and kitchen essentials to tech, personal care and lifestyle items. She approaches every recommendation with a careful eye for build quality, real-world performance and value for money, and she is quick to call out features that sound impressive but add little in daily use. Malina is known for clear, well-organized guides that cut through marketing noise and help readers compare their options with confidence. Her reviews are valued for their clarity, honesty and attention to detail, making her a trusted voice for shoppers who want to buy smarter the first time.

Articles: 9684