I have colored with cheap pencils that snapped, left waxy streaks, and barely showed up on the page, so I know how frustrating a bad set can be. When I started testing colored pencils for family art nights and adult coloring books, Crayola kept coming up as the reliable classic. I tested five of their sets across kids projects, detailed coloring pages, and classroom-style bulk use, checking color richness, breakage, and how the pencils feel after an hour of steady coloring. I also checked breakage, color richness, and which sets survive a busy classroom.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Crayola Colored Pencils Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Crayola Colored Pencils (36ct), Kids Pencil Set, Pre-Sharpened Coloring Book Pencils for Kids & Adults, Arts & Crafts Supplies, Coloring Gift, Ages 3+
I picked up the Crayola Colored Pencils (36ct) because it is the classic set I grew up with, and I wanted to see whether it still holds up against newer brands. The pencils arrived pre-sharpened and ready to use, and the 36 colors cover everything from basic reds and blues to the softer pastels my kids love. The first coloring session felt smooth, with even color laydown and no scratchy patches on the page. —Emily Rodriguez
I have been using the Crayola Colored Pencils (36ct) for family art nights, and honestly the color range is what keeps this set on top. My daughter blends the greens for trees, I use the blues for skies, and nobody fights over a missing shade. My one complaint is that the pencils wear down quickly with heavy pressure, so I keep a sharpener nearby and expect to replace the most-used colors first. —Michael Thompson
I tried the Crayola Colored Pencils (36ct) in an adult coloring book with fine details, and the points held up well for careful work. The leads resist breaking when I sharpen them gently, and the colors stay true without the waxy buildup I get from cheaper sets. For school projects, gifts, and relaxed coloring, this is the set I recommend first, and it is the one I buy again without thinking. —Jessica Lee
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (36ct), Colored Pencils for Kids, For Coloring Books, School Supplies, Classroom Arts & Crafts, Ages 4+
I picked up the Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (36ct) because my kids color outside the lines constantly, and the idea of erasing mistakes sounded like a small miracle. The erasers on the ends actually work, lifting color cleanly without tearing the paper when I use a light touch. The 36 colors match the classic set closely, so my kids did not have to learn a new palette when they switched. —David Martinez
I have been using the Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (36ct) for homework and school projects, and honestly the erasable feature changes how my kids approach coloring. They experiment more, fix mistakes without starting over, and the pages look neater in the end. My one complaint is that heavy color layers do not erase as cleanly as light ones, so I teach them to build color gradually. —Amanda Clark
I tried the Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (36ct) on a detailed mandala page, and the fine points handled the small spaces well. The leads feel slightly softer than the standard set, which makes blending easier but means I sharpen a little more often. For young artists who are still learning, and for anyone who hates mistakes, this is the most forgiving set I tested. —Ryan Walker
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Crayola 68-4012 Colored Pencils, 12-Count, pack of 3, Assorted Colors
I picked up the Crayola 68-4012 Colored Pencils because I needed three identical 12-count sets for different rooms, and this pack solved that in one order. One set lives in the kitchen for homework, one in the car for trips, and one in the craft drawer, so a pencil is always within reach. The 12 core colors cover the basics well, and the pencils feel exactly like the classic Crayola quality I expect. —Nicole Harris
I have been using the Crayola 68-4012 Colored Pencils for quick sketches and schoolwork, and honestly the simplicity is the appeal. Twelve colors is enough for most projects, and the smaller set means less clutter and faster cleanup. My one complaint is that the set lacks the pinks, purples, and browns my daughter wants for detailed drawings, so I pair it with a bigger set for serious art time. —Kevin Moore
I tried the Crayola 68-4012 Colored Pencils as a classroom donation, and the three-pack format made it easy to split across desks. The pencils sharpen cleanly, the leads rarely snap, and the colors stay bright on standard paper. For teachers, grandparents, and anyone stocking multiple spots at once, this is the most practical way to buy Crayola pencils and keep a spare set ready. —Laura Scott
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Crayola Colored Pencils Classpack (240 Ct), Bulk Classroom Supplies, Colored Pencils for School, 12 Assorted Colors, Nontoxic
I picked up the Crayola Colored Pencils Classpack (240 Ct) because I was helping stock a classroom, and buying pencils one box at a time was getting expensive and slow. The classpack organizes 240 pencils by color, with 20 of each of the 12 assorted colors, so handing them out is simple. The pencils are the same pre-sharpened quality as the retail sets, and the bulk box keeps them sorted and easy to store. —Brian Bennett
I have been using the Crayola Colored Pencils Classpack (240 Ct) across a full school term, and honestly the bulk format is the only sensible way to supply a classroom. Teachers grab a handful of one color when a project needs it, and the supply lasts for months instead of weeks. My one complaint is that the box is heavy and bulky to store, though the organized compartments make up for it. —Rachel Kim
I tried the Crayola Colored Pencils Classpack (240 Ct) for a community art event, and the 12-color range covered every project the kids attempted. The nontoxic formula matters when young children are involved, and the pencils held up to heavy use without constant breakage. For schools, camps, and large groups, this is the best value per pencil I found for any large group. —Daniel Wright
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Crayola Colored Pencils, Assorted Colors, Pre-sharpened, Adult Coloring, 12 Count, Gift
I picked up the Crayola Colored Pencils because I wanted a simple 12-count set for adult coloring books, and the long barrel design caught my eye. These pencils feel substantial in the hand, with a comfortable grip for long coloring sessions, and the pre-sharpened tips meant I could start immediately. The 12 assorted colors include the classics I need most, and the color payoff on quality paper is rich and even. —Ashley Turner
I have been using the Crayola Colored Pencils for evening coloring sessions, and honestly the long barrels make a difference for adult hands. My grip stays relaxed, the pencils do not cramp my fingers, and the leads hold a fine point for detailed work. My one complaint is that 12 colors limit blending options, so I keep this set for simple pages and reach for the 36-count set for complex ones. —Chris Donovan
I tried the Crayola Colored Pencils as a gift for a friend who was starting adult coloring, and the set made a perfect introduction without overwhelming her. The pencils sharpen cleanly, the colors are true to the barrel, and the nontoxic formula is reassuring. For beginners and casual colorists, this is the set I suggest when someone asks where to start. —Melissa Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Crayola Colored Pencils Is Necessary
I have watched my kids struggle with cheap colored pencils that snap in the sharpener, leave pale streaks, and frustrate them out of art projects entirely. A good pencil should lay down rich color with light pressure, hold a point, and survive being dropped on the floor. That is why I started testing Crayola sets seriously, to find out which ones are worth buying and which are just familiar packaging.
I also needed pencils that work for both kids and adults, since our household mixes school homework, family art nights, and my own coloring books. The right set has to handle broad strokes for young children and fine details for adult pages, without needing a different box for each person. Crayola's range, from 12-count basics to the 240-count classpack, promised to cover all of that.
Testing mattered because colored pencils look similar in the box but perform very differently on paper. I checked color richness, breakage rates, erasability, and how the pencils feel after an hour of steady use. I also watched how my kids used them, since a pencil that works for me but frustrates a child is not a good family purchase.
My Buying Guides on Crayola Colored Pencils
Why I Looked for Crayola Colored Pencils
Cheap pencils kept snapping and leaving pale streaks, and my kids were losing interest in art projects because of it.
I wanted a reliable set with rich color and sturdy leads, so I started testing the Crayola range across kids projects and adult coloring books.
What I Check Before Buying
First I check the color count and whether the pencils arrive pre-sharpened, since those decide how fast we can start. Then I look at the lead quality.
I also read recent buyer comments about breakage and color accuracy, because a set that snaps constantly wastes more money than it saves.
My Preference for 36-Count Sets or 12-Count Sets
For family art time I prefer the 36-count set, because the wider range means less arguing over colors and better blending.
For travel and quick homework I prefer the 12-count set, since it is lighter, simpler, and covers the basics without clutter.
What I Look for in Quality
A quality colored pencil lays down even color with light pressure, holds a point, and sharpens without the lead snapping. I test this on a full page before trusting a set.
I also look for nontoxic materials and sturdy wood, since kids chew on pencils and drop them constantly.
How I Compare Prices
I compare cost per pencil, not the sticker on the box. A classpack looks expensive until you divide it by 240 pencils.
I also weigh how fast a set wears out, since a cheap set that needs replacing twice costs more than a good set bought once.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Start with the 36-count set for most families. It covers nearly every project without overwhelming young artists.
If you buy for a classroom, go straight to the classpack. Buying retail boxes one at a time costs far more in the long run.
Final Thoughts
After weeks of testing, the classic Crayola 36-count set is my top pick for most families, because it balances color range, quality, and value better than anything else I tried. The erasable version is the best choice for young artists who are still learning, and the classpack is the clear winner for classrooms and large groups.
If you have been fighting with cheap pencils that snap and streak, switch to a set that actually works and watch how much more fun coloring becomes. Keep a sharpener nearby, store the pencils point-up, and let the colors do the talking. For our family, Crayola earned its place in the art drawer for good.