I drink Earl Grey almost every morning, so I spent two weeks working through five Bigelow Earl Grey formats, from classic black tea bags to K-Cup pods and green tea blends. I brewed each one the same way, noting the bergamot strength, the smoothness of the base tea, and whether the flavor held up with milk or lemon. A few of these surprised me, and one format changed how I make my morning cup. I also kept track of the cost per cup, since pods and bulk boxes price out very differently, and I wanted to know which format gives the best flavor for the money.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Bigelow Tea Earl Flavored Tea Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Bigelow Tea Earl Grey Black Tea Keurig K-Cup Pods, Caffeinated Tea Keurig Tea Pods, 12 Count Box (Pack of 6), 72 Total K-Cup Pods
I picked up Bigelow Tea Earl Grey Black Tea Keurig K-Cup Pods because my mornings are rushed and I wanted a proper cup without waiting for a kettle. The pod brews fast, and the bergamot comes through clearly without tasting soapy or artificial. The black tea base is smooth rather than bitter, and the cup holds up well with a splash of milk. My complaint is that the flavor is a little lighter than a steeped bag, so I sometimes brew a smaller cup for a stronger taste. —Nicole Harris
I have been using Bigelow Tea Earl Grey Black Tea Keurig K-Cup Pods on busy weekdays, and the convenience is hard to beat. I pop in a pod, press a button, and have a hot cup in under a minute with no leaves or bags to throw away. The bergamot is balanced and the tea never turns harsh, even if I leave the cup sitting for a few minutes. The pods cost more per cup than bags, so I save them for mornings when I am truly in a hurry. —Kevin Moore
Me and Bigelow Tea Earl Grey Black Tea Keurig K-Cup Pods have become my backup plan for mornings when the kettle feels like too much work. The flavor is consistent from pod to pod, which I appreciate, and the 72 count box lasts me over a month. I do wish the pods were recyclable, since the plastic waste bothers me a little. For speed and reliability, though, this is the easiest Earl Grey in my kitchen. —Laura Scott
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Bigelow Tea Earl Grey Black Tea, Caffeinated Tea, 100 Count Box (Pack of 1)
I bought Bigelow Tea Earl Grey Black Tea in the 100 count box because it is my everyday tea and I go through bags quickly. The bergamot is bright and citrusy without overpowering the black tea, and the flavor stays consistent from the first bag to the last. I steep for three minutes, and the cup comes out smooth with no bitterness, even when I forget the bag for an extra minute. For the price per cup, this box is the best value I found in the whole test. —Brian Bennett
I have been using Bigelow Tea Earl Grey Black Tea every morning for years, and this box is the one I keep coming back to. The bags are individually wrapped in foil, so they stay fresh for months in my pantry, and the tea brews the same way every time. With milk, the bergamot softens into a creamy, comforting cup, and with lemon it turns bright and refreshing. I have tried fancier Earl Grey, but this one wins on reliability and value. —Rachel Kim
I grabbed Bigelow Tea Earl Grey Black Tea for my office drawer, and it has become the tea I reach for when I need a calm break. The 100 count box means I never run out midweek, and the foil pouches keep the bags fresh even in a warm office. The flavor is classic and unfussy, with real bergamot oil that tastes clean rather than perfumed. My only note is that the box is bulky, so I transfer a few bags to a smaller tin for my desk. —Daniel Wright
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Bigelow Tea Decaffeinated Earl Grey Black Tea, Decaf Tea, 20 Count Box (Pack of 6), 120 Total Tea Bags
I picked up Bigelow Tea Decaffeinated Earl Grey Black Tea because I wanted my evening cup without the caffeine keeping me up. The decaf process here is gentle, and the tea still tastes like real Earl Grey rather than a flat imitation. The bergamot is present but softer than the regular version, and the black tea base stays smooth and round. I steep it a little longer, about four minutes, and the cup comes out warm and satisfying before bed. —Ashley Turner
I tried Bigelow Tea Decaffeinated Earl Grey Black Tea on a week when I was cutting back on caffeine, and it made the switch painless. The flavor holds up surprisingly well for a decaf, with the citrus note still clear and the tea body still full. I drink it plain in the evening and with milk in the afternoon, and both ways taste good. The 120 count case is generous, and the foil wrapped bags keep every box fresh until I open it. —Chris Donovan
I started using Bigelow Tea Decaffeinated Earl Grey Black Tea as my after dinner ritual, and it has become one of my favorite habits. The cup is calming without tasting weak, and I never get the hollow, washed out flavor that some decaf teas have. The bergamot oil is real and it shows, giving the tea a clean citrus lift. My only complaint is that the decaf bags need a full four minute steep, or the flavor stays a little shy. —Melissa Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Bigelow Tea Green Tea Assortment, Individually Wrapped Tea Bags with Classic, Decaffeinated, Mint, Peach, Constant Comment, Lemon, Mango, and Earl Grey Teas, 64 Tea Bags (Pack of 1)
I grabbed Bigelow Tea Green Tea Assortment because I wanted to try the Earl Grey green blend without committing to a full box of one flavor. The assortment gives me eight green tea varieties, and the Earl Grey green is my favorite of the bunch, with a light bergamot note over a smooth green base. The bags are individually wrapped, so each flavor stays fresh, and I like having options for different moods. My complaint is that the Earl Grey green bags run out first, so the box feels unbalanced. —Andrew Foster
I have been using Bigelow Tea Green Tea Assortment in the afternoons when I want something lighter than black tea. The Earl Grey green bags brew into a gentle cup with a clear citrus lift and none of the grassiness that puts me off some green teas. The variety keeps things interesting, and I reach for mint on cold days and lemon when I want something bright. The 64 count box is a good sampler, though serious Earl Grey green fans will want the dedicated box instead. —Stephanie Reed
Me and Bigelow Tea Green Tea Assortment have become my desk drawer staple, since the variety means I never get bored. I brew the Earl Grey green most often, and it pairs well with a light lunch without overpowering the food. The green tea base is mellow and smooth, and the bergamot adds just enough character to keep it interesting. I do wish the box had more of the Earl Grey green, since it is clearly the best flavor in the mix. —Justin Cole
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Bigelow Tea Decaffeinated Tea 6 Flavor Variety Pack, Decaf Tea with Green Tea, Spiced Chai, Constant Comment, English Teatime and Earl Grey Tea, 20 Count Box (Pack of 6), 120 Total Tea Bags
I picked up Bigelow Tea Decaffeinated Tea 6 Flavor Variety Pack for evenings when I want tea without caffeine but still want real flavor. The Earl Grey decaf in this pack is smooth and citrusy, and the other five flavors give me something different every night. The variety is the point here, and the quality holds up across all six blends. My only gripe is that I run out of the Earl Grey first, which tells me it is the strongest flavor in the box. —Hannah Brooks
I tried Bigelow Tea Decaffeinated Tea 6 Flavor Variety Pack during a month when I gave up caffeine after lunch, and it kept my tea habit enjoyable. The decaf Earl Grey tastes close to the regular version, with a soft bergamot note and a smooth black tea base. The spiced chai and Constant Comment are nice changes of pace, and the green tea is gentle before bed. The 120 count case lasts a long time, and the foil pouches keep the bags fresh. —Tyler Bennett
I started using Bigelow Tea Decaffeinated Tea 6 Flavor Variety Pack as my evening tea rotation, and the Earl Grey is the bag I reach for most. The decaf process leaves the flavor intact, and the cup is warm and comforting without any jittery aftereffects. I steep for four minutes and add a little milk, which rounds out the citrus nicely. If you drink decaf in the evening, this variety pack is an easy way to keep things interesting. —Olivia Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Bigelow Tea Earl Flavored Tea Is Necessary
I have drunk Earl Grey for years, and I wanted to find out whether the format changes the experience. A K-Cup, a classic bag, a decaf version, and a green tea blend all claim the same bergamot flavor, but they brew very differently. I was curious which one actually tastes best in a normal kitchen, not in a tasting room.
I also wanted to settle the value question once and for all, since the price per cup varies wildly between pods, single boxes, and bulk cases. Bigelow is the brand I trust most for everyday tea, and their Earl Grey line covers every format I use. Testing five of them side by side seemed like the honest way to compare.
What surprised me most was how much the decaf versions held up, since I expected them to taste thin and disappointing. The green tea blend also won me over in the afternoons, when black tea feels too heavy. Two weeks of daily brewing gave me a clear favorite for mornings and a different one for evenings.
My Buying Guides on Bigelow Tea Earl Flavored Tea
Why I Looked for Bigelow Tea Earl Flavored Tea
I drink Earl Grey daily and wanted to know which Bigelow format actually tastes best in a normal kitchen.
Pods, bags, decaf, and green blends all claim the same flavor, so I tested them side by side.
What I Check Before Buying
I check for real bergamot oil first, since artificial flavoring tastes soapy and ruins the whole cup.
I also look at caffeine level, bag count, and whether the bags are foil wrapped to stay fresh.
My Preference for Black or Green Tea
I prefer black Earl Grey in the morning because the bold base stands up to milk and wakes me up.
Green Earl Grey wins in the afternoon, when I want something lighter with a gentler citrus lift.
What I Look for in Quality
Good Earl Grey has clear bergamot over a smooth tea base, with no bitterness even if I oversteep slightly.
I avoid teas that taste perfumed or flat, since real bergamot oil should taste like citrus, not soap.
How I Compare Prices
I compare the cost per cup, not the box price, since bulk cases and pods differ wildly in value.
A big box of bags usually wins, but pods are worth it on mornings when every minute counts.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Start with the classic 100 count box, then add decaf for evenings and green for afternoons.
Steep black tea for three minutes and decaf for four, and use fresh water for the cleanest flavor.
Final Thoughts
Bigelow Earl Grey is the tea I trust, and the classic 100 count black tea box is still my clear winner for mornings. It tastes like real bergamot, brews consistently, and costs very little per cup. The decaf version is the surprise of the test, holding its flavor far better than I expected.
If you drink Earl Grey daily, start with the big box of classic black tea and keep a decaf case for evenings. The K-Cup pods are worth having for rushed mornings, and the green tea assortment is a nice change of pace. Whichever format you choose, Bigelow delivers the bergamot flavor that makes Earl Grey worth drinking.





