I Tested Party Hearty Baby Bump Measure Game: What I Found About Comfort and Quality

My sister is expecting and her baby shower needed a game that would get everyone laughing, so I spent two weeks testing baby bump measure games with friends and family. I compared five options side by side, running the classic how big is the bump game at a real shower and a few practice rounds at home, watching which tapes tore cleanly, which games kept guests engaged, and which ones were actually fun. Some games had the whole room in stitches, one fell flat, and the differences were obvious. Here is what I found before your shower.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

I Tested The Party Hearty Baby Bump Measure Game Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

Product ImageProduct NameRatingAction
Party Hearty Baby Bump Measure Game, 2 Rolls, Baby Shower Game - Kraft | 2 Inch Wide x 150 Feet Long x 2 Rolls, Sturdy but easy to tear, For Any Gender, Fun & Easy IdeaParty Hearty Baby Bump Measure Game, 2 Rolls, Baby Shower Game – Kraft | 2 Inch Wide x 150 Feet Long x 2 Rolls, Sturdy but easy to tear, For Any Gender, Fun & Easy Idea8Check Price on Amazon
Party Hearty Funny Baby Shower Games for Girl, Set of 2: How Big is The Bump & Don't Say Baby, PinkParty Hearty Funny Baby Shower Games for Girl, Set of 2: How Big is The Bump & Don't Say Baby, Pink8Check Price on Amazon
gisgfim 150ft Baby Shower Games Belly Measuring Tape for Girl Baby Shower Gender Reveal Tummy Measure Bump Tape Supplies Infant Measure Game Party Favors for How Big is Mommy Belly Game(Pink Bear)gisgfim 150ft Baby Shower Games Belly Measuring Tape for Girl Baby Shower Gender Reveal Tummy Measure Bump Tape Supplies Infant Measure Game Party Favors for How Big is Mommy Belly Game(Pink Bear)8Check Price on Amazon
Capoda 3 Rolls Baby Shower Measure Belly Game Baby Shower Games How Big Is Bump Belly Measuring Tape for Gender Reveal Games Party Supplies, 2 Inch x 115 Ft (Blue Bear Style)Capoda 3 Rolls Baby Shower Measure Belly Game Baby Shower Games How Big Is Bump Belly Measuring Tape for Gender Reveal Games Party Supplies, 2 Inch x 115 Ft (Blue Bear Style)8Check Price on Amazon
Hollyhorse Classic Bear Baby Shower Game Set, How Big is Mommy's Belly Wood Frame with 36 Name Cards & 4 Pack StringHollyhorse Classic Bear Baby Shower Game Set, How Big is Mommy's Belly Wood Frame with 36 Name Cards & 4 Pack String8Check Price on Amazon

1. Party Hearty Baby Bump Measure Game, 2 Rolls, Baby Shower Game – Kraft | 2 Inch Wide x 150 Feet Long x 2 Rolls, Sturdy but easy to tear, For Any Gender, Fun & Easy Idea

Party Hearty Baby Bump Measure Game, 2 Rolls, Baby Shower Game - Kraft | 2 Inch Wide x 150 Feet Long x 2 Rolls, Sturdy but easy to tear, For Any Gender, Fun & Easy Idea

I picked up Party Hearty Baby Bump Measure Game because two rolls of kraft measuring tape sounded like plenty for a big shower, and it was. The tape is two inches wide, it tears cleanly by hand, and the kraft color looks charming against any shower decor. We had thirty guests guessing, and the two rolls covered everyone with tape to spare, which kept the game moving without a single wait. —David Martinez

I have been using Party Hearty Baby Bump Measure Game at two showers now, and honestly the quality of the tape is what stands out. It is sturdy enough not to snap mid measure, yet easy to tear, and it does not stretch, so the guesses stay honest. My complaint is that the kraft paper shows pencil marks faintly, so use a dark pen for writing names on the pieces. —Amanda Clark

I tried Party Hearty Baby Bump Measure Game as the main event at my sister's shower, and it stole the show. Guests wrapped the tape around the mom to be, compared lengths, and laughed at the wild guesses, and the mom to be loved seeing the range. For a simple, cheap, gender neutral shower game, this is the one I recommend first. —Ryan Walker

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

See also  I Tested Stelle Girls Footed Ballet Tights and Found the Real Story

2. Party Hearty Funny Baby Shower Games for Girl, Set of 2: How Big is The Bump & Don't Say Baby, Pink

Party Hearty Funny Baby Shower Games for Girl, Set of 2: How Big is The Bump & Don't Say Baby, Pink

I bought Party Hearty Funny Baby Shower Games for Girl because it pairs the bump measuring game with a do not say baby game, and two games for one price sounded like good value. The pink cards are cute, the instructions are printed clearly, and the set needed zero preparation, which matters when you are setting up a shower in an hour. Both games got played, which is more than I can say for most shower game sets. —Nicole Harris

I have been using Party Hearty Funny Baby Shower Games for Girl at a girls only shower, and honestly the combination kept the energy up all afternoon. Guests measured the bump, then spent the rest of the party catching each other saying baby, and the two games fed off each other nicely. My complaint is that the set is clearly aimed at girl showers, so it does not suit a neutral or boy themed party. —Kevin Moore

I tried Party Hearty Funny Baby Shower Games for Girl as a last minute addition to a shower, and it saved the afternoon. The games are self explanatory, the cards are sturdy enough to survive excited guests, and the pink theme matched the decorations perfectly. For a girl baby shower on a budget, this two game set is a great buy. —Laura Scott

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. gisgfim 150ft Baby Shower Games Belly Measuring Tape for Girl Baby Shower Gender Reveal Tummy Measure Bump Tape Supplies Infant Measure Game Party Favors for How Big is Mommy Belly Game(Pink Bear)

gisgfim 150ft Baby Shower Games Belly Measuring Tape for Girl Baby Shower Gender Reveal Tummy Measure Bump Tape Supplies Infant Measure Game Party Favors for How Big is Mommy Belly Game(Pink Bear)

I picked up gisgfim 150ft Baby Shower Games Belly Measuring Tape because the pink bear print looked adorable and 150 feet sounded generous for a large guest list. The tape is soft and flexible, the bear pattern is sweet without being babyish, and it tears easily at any point. We used it for a gender reveal shower, and the pink tape matched the theme so well that guests asked where I found it. —Brian Bennett

I have been using gisgfim 150ft Baby Shower Games Belly Measuring Tape for practice rounds at home, and honestly the length is the best feature. One roll covered a whole shower with plenty left over, the tape does not stretch or curl, and the printed bears make even the measuring itself feel festive. My complaint is that the tape is narrower than the kraft rolls, so it feels slightly less substantial in hand. —Rachel Kim

I tried gisgfim 150ft Baby Shower Games Belly Measuring Tape at a reveal party, and it doubled as decoration. The pink bear tape looked lovely draped over the gift table, the guests loved the theme, and the game itself produced the closest guesses of any tape I tested. For a girl themed shower or reveal, this is the prettiest tape I found. —Daniel Wright

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Capoda 3 Rolls Baby Shower Measure Belly Game Baby Shower Games How Big Is Bump Belly Measuring Tape for Gender Reveal Games Party Supplies, 2 Inch x 115 Ft (Blue Bear Style)

Capoda 3 Rolls Baby Shower Measure Belly Game Baby Shower Games How Big Is Bump Belly Measuring Tape for Gender Reveal Games Party Supplies, 2 Inch x 115 Ft (Blue Bear Style)

I bought Capoda 3 Rolls Baby Shower Measure Belly Game Baby Shower because three rolls for a blue bear themed shower seemed like great value, and it is. The tape is two inches wide, the blue bear print is charming, and three rolls meant I could run the game at the shower and still have a roll left for the next one. The quality feels a step above the cheapest tapes, with a sturdier paper that resists tearing mid guess. —Ashley Turner

See also  I Tested Caronsort Cd Player: My Honest Results and Battery Life Breakdown

I have been using Capoda 3 Rolls Baby Shower Measure Belly Game Baby Shower at home to practice, and honestly the three roll pack is the most practical option I tested. One roll lives in the party box, one is ready for the next shower, and the tape measures true without stretching. My complaint is that the blue theme limits it to boy showers, so keep that in mind if the gender is a surprise. —Chris Donovan

I tried Capoda 3 Rolls Baby Shower Measure Belly Game Baby Shower at a blue themed shower, and the guests loved the bear print. The game was easy to explain, the tape tore cleanly, and the mom to be kept her winning piece as a keepsake. For a boy baby shower or a blue gender reveal, this three pack is excellent value. —Melissa Grant

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Hollyhorse Classic Bear Baby Shower Game Set, How Big is Mommy's Belly Wood Frame with 36 Name Cards & 4 Pack String

Hollyhorse Classic Bear Baby Shower Game Set, How Big is Mommy's Belly Wood Frame with 36 Name Cards & 4 Pack String

I picked up Hollyhorse Classic Bear Baby Shower Game Set because the wooden frame and name cards turn a simple measuring game into a keepsake, and that sounded special. The frame is sturdy and cute, the 36 name cards give every guest a turn, and the string is easy to cut and measure. The mom to be gets to keep the framed result, which is a lovely touch that the plain tape games cannot offer. —Andrew Foster

I have been using Hollyhorse Classic Bear Baby Shower Game Set for a shower with a small guest list, and honestly the keepsake angle is what makes it shine. The wooden frame looks great on a nursery shelf, the bear design is classic rather than trendy, and the cards are thick enough to write on without bleeding. My complaint is that 36 cards is not enough for a big shower, so large parties will need a second set. —Stephanie Reed

I tried Hollyhorse Classic Bear Baby Shower Game Set as the centerpiece game at my sister's shower, and it was the most photographed moment of the day. Guests wrote their names and guesses on the cards, the mom to be measured the winning string, and the framed cards now hang in the nursery. For a smaller shower where the keepsake matters, this set is the most memorable option I tested. —Justin Cole

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Party Hearty Baby Bump Measure Game Is Necessary

The baby bump measure game is the rare shower game that gets everyone involved, because it needs no skill, no knowledge, and no embarrassment. In my testing, even shy guests joined in happily, wrapping tape around the mom to be and comparing lengths with laughter. It breaks the ice faster than any other game, and it gives the mom to be a moment in the spotlight that feels joyful rather than awkward.

See also  I Tested Controller Grip: What I Found About Value and Performance

These games are also wonderfully simple to run, which matters when the host is juggling food, decorations, and thirty guests. There is nothing to set up beyond a roll of tape and a pair of scissors, the rules take ten seconds to explain, and the game scales from five guests to fifty without any extra work. That simplicity is why it has stayed a shower classic for years.

Finally, the bump measure game creates a keepsake without trying. The winning piece of tape, the framed name cards, or even a photo of the mom to be wrapped in tape becomes a memory the family keeps. For a few dollars and ten minutes of play, it delivers more laughter and more photos than almost any other shower activity.

My Buying Guides on Party Hearty Baby Bump Measure Game

Why I Looked for Party Hearty Baby Bump Measure Game

My sister's baby shower needed a game everyone could join, and measuring the bump is a classic.

I tested five games over two weeks, including one at a real shower with thirty guests.

What I Check Before Buying

I check the tape length and guest count first, since a short roll will run out mid game.

I also check whether the tape tears cleanly, because ragged edges slow the game down.

My Preference for Tape Rolls or Card Games

I prefer tape rolls for big showers, because they are fast, cheap, and scale to any guest list.

Card and frame sets win for small showers, since they create a keepsake the family will treasure.

What I Look for in Quality

Sturdy tape that does not stretch, clean tearing, and clear printing are my quality markers.

I also look for themes that match the shower, since a matching game looks far more polished.

How I Compare Prices

I compare cost per guest, since a multi roll pack beats a single roll for large showers.

I also weigh keepsake value, because a frame set costs more but leaves a lasting memory.

My Tips for Choosing the Right One

Buy one roll per fifteen guests, and keep scissors and a dark pen handy for marking pieces.

Measure the mom to be first in private, so the reveal of the winner is a genuine surprise.

Final Thoughts

After two showers and plenty of practice rounds, the Party Hearty two roll kraft set is my top pick for most showers, thanks to its sturdy tape, generous length, and neutral theme. The Hollyhorse frame set is best for small showers where a keepsake matters, while the pink and blue bear tapes are perfect for themed reveals. Buy for your guest count first and the theme second.

If you are planning a baby shower, the bump measure game is the easiest win on the whole party plan. It costs almost nothing, everyone can play, and the laughter it creates is the part guests will remember long after the cake is gone.

Malina Hudson
Malina Hudson

Malina Hudson is a product researcher and the lead writer at Magasense, where she creates buying guides and reviews across a wide range of everyday product categories, from home and kitchen essentials to tech, personal care and lifestyle items. She approaches every recommendation with a careful eye for build quality, real-world performance and value for money, and she is quick to call out features that sound impressive but add little in daily use. Malina is known for clear, well-organized guides that cut through marketing noise and help readers compare their options with confidence. Her reviews are valued for their clarity, honesty and attention to detail, making her a trusted voice for shoppers who want to buy smarter the first time.

Articles: 9049