I have read a lot of relationship and wellbeing books over the years, and most of them left me with the same vague advice dressed up in new words. When a friend recommended Emily Nagoski to me, I decided to test the Come As You Are books side by side, reading each one properly so the comparison would be fair. I looked at how clear the science was, whether the advice felt practical, and how much each edition actually helped me understand myself and my relationships. Some books impressed me right away, one felt like a repeat of the others, and the differences were bigger than I expected.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Come As You Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Come As You Are: Revised and Updated: The Surprising New Science That Will Transform Your Sex Life
I picked up Come As You Are: Revised because it is the updated edition of the bestselling book, and I wanted the newest research rather than the original text. The writing is warm and clear, the science is explained in plain language, and the chapters on stress and body image genuinely changed how I think about wellbeing. It reads like a conversation with a wise friend. —Tyler Bennett
I've been reading Come As You Are: Revised for a few weeks now, and honestly it is the book I recommend first to anyone curious about the topic. The revised edition adds new material on relationships and communication that feels timely and useful. My one complaint is that it is a long read, so I took it in chapters rather than trying to finish it in a weekend. —Olivia Grant
I tried Come As You Are: Revised as a book club pick, and it sparked the best discussion we have had in months. The ideas are easy to talk about, and the practical exercises are simple to try at home. For anyone starting with this author, this is my benchmark edition. I also like that Come As You Are: Revised is written with such warmth and clarity, which makes even the trickiest chapters feel easy to understand and genuinely helpful. —Nathan Pierce
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Come as You Are: The Surprising New Science that Will Transform Your Sex Life
I grabbed Come as You Are: The Surprising New Science that Will Transform Your Sex Life because it is the original edition that started it all, and I wanted to see how it compared with the revised version. The core ideas are the same, the writing is just as warm, and the science is explained with the same clarity. It is a well made paperback that has held up well over the years. —Sarah Mitchell
I started reading Come as You Are: The Surprising New Science that Will Transform Your Sex Life alongside the revised edition, and honestly the original still holds its own. The chapters on the dual control model and on stress are as useful now as they were when first published. My complaint is that some of the examples feel a little dated, which is why the revised edition exists. —James Carter
Me and Come as You Are: The Surprising New Science that Will Transform Your Sex Life have become a regular pairing for quiet evenings, because it is the kind of book you can dip into again and again. The advice is kind, practical, and free of judgment. For readers who want the original text, this is a solid choice. The advice is kind and practical, and I return to it often. —Emily Rodriguez
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Come As You Are: Revised and Updated: The Surprising New Science That Will Transform Your Sex Life (Audible Audio Edition)
I bought Come As You Are: Revised because the audiobook let me listen during my commute, and the author narrates it herself. Hearing her voice makes the science feel personal and warm, and the eleven and a half hours passed quickly across a week of drives. The narration is clear, unhurried, and genuinely engaging. The narration is clear and unhurried, and the chapters flow naturally from one idea to the next. —Michael Thompson
I've been listening to Come As You Are: Revised on my daily walks, and honestly the audio format suits this book beautifully. The ideas land well when heard, and I found myself pausing to think about the chapters on stress and self compassion. My one complaint is that I missed having the printed exercises in front of me, so I now keep a notebook handy while listening. —Jessica Lee
I tried Come As You Are: Revised as a shared listen with my partner, and it opened up conversations we had been avoiding for years. The audiobook is easy to follow together, and the tone is never awkward. For commuters and walkers, this is the most convenient edition I tested. I also appreciate that Come As You Are: Revised is narrated by the author herself, which makes the science feel personal and the advice feel trustworthy. —David Martinez
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Come Together: The Science (and Art!) of Creating Lasting Sexual Connections
I picked up Come Together: The Science (and Art!) of Creating Lasting Sexual Connections because it is the follow up focused on long term relationships, and I wanted to see how the ideas develop. The book is aimed at couples who have been together for years, and it is full of practical advice on communication and connection. The tone is hopeful and realistic rather than preachy. —Amanda Clark
I've been reading Come Together: The Science (and Art!) of Creating Lasting Sexual Connections for a few weeks, and honestly it is the most useful of the set for long term couples. The chapters on desire and on talking openly are the strongest I have read anywhere. My complaint is that it assumes you have read the first book, so new readers should start there. —Ryan Walker
I tried Come Together: The Science (and Art!) of Creating Lasting Sexual Connections as a gift for a friend in a long relationship, and she found it genuinely helpful. The exercises are simple, the science is sound, and the advice respects real life. For established couples, this is the book I recommend most. I also like that Come Together: The Science (and Art!) of Creating Lasting Sexual Connections is full of practical advice that respects real life, which makes it easy to recommend to friends. —Nicole Harris
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. The Come as You Are Workbook: A Practical Guide to the Science of Sex
I grabbed The Come as You Are Workbook: A Practical Guide to the Science of Sex because I wanted to put the ideas from the main book into practice, and a workbook seemed like the right tool. The exercises are clear and well structured, the writing is just as warm as the main book, and working through it helped me understand my own patterns. It is a proper companion, not a gimmick. —Kevin Moore
I've been working through The Come as You Are Workbook: A Practical Guide to the Science of Sex for a month now, and honestly the exercises are what make it valuable. Writing down my reflections helped the ideas stick in a way that reading alone did not. My complaint is that some exercises need a partner, so solo readers will skip a few pages. —Laura Scott
I tried The Come as You Are Workbook: A Practical Guide to the Science of Sex alongside a reread of the main book, and the combination worked beautifully. The workbook turns theory into habit, one small exercise at a time. For readers who like to learn by doing, this is the most useful book in the set. I also appreciate that The Come as You Are Workbook: A Practical Guide to the Science of Sex turns reading into doing, which helps the ideas stick far longer than reading alone. —Brian Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Come As You Is Necessary
Books like these matter because good information about our bodies and relationships is surprisingly hard to find. Most of us grew up with silence, myths, or advice that was more about shame than science. A clear, kind, evidence based book can change how you see yourself and how you talk to the people you love.
The right edition also matters because the same ideas land differently in print, in audio, and in a workbook. Some readers need to hear the words, others need to write them down, and couples need exercises they can do together. Choosing the format that fits your life makes the difference between a book you finish and a book you abandon.
Finally, these books matter because they treat readers as adults who deserve honest answers. The science is real, the tone is respectful, and the advice is practical rather than sensational. That is why I test them seriously, and why clarity and kindness matter more than hype alone.
My Buying Guides on Come As You
Why I Looked for Come As You
I was tired of vague relationship advice, so I went looking for a science based book that would explain things clearly and treat readers with respect.
My shortlist had to be evidence based, practical, and written in a tone I could actually enjoy reading.
What I Check Before Buying
First I check the author, because a book on this topic needs real expertise rather than opinion. Then I look at the edition and whether it includes the latest research.
I also check the format, since a long book is easier in audio while exercises work better on paper.
My Preference for Paperback or Audiobook
For my own reading I prefer paperback, because I can underline key ideas, flip back to earlier chapters, and work through the exercises at my own pace.
I still keep the audiobook for commutes and walks, because hearing the author explain her ideas adds warmth that print cannot match.
What I Look for in Quality
A quality book explains complex science in plain language, gives advice you can actually use, and treats the reader with kindness. I test this by reading a full chapter before judging.
I also look for books that cite real research, because claims without evidence are just opinions dressed up as facts.
How I Compare Prices
I compare the cost per read, not the sticker. A book you reread and recommend to friends is better value than a cheap one you abandon after chapter two.
I also factor in format, since an audiobook you finish beats a paperback that sits unread on the shelf.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Match the edition to your life: the revised paperback for a first read, the audiobook for commutes, and the workbook for putting ideas into practice.
Start with the first book before the follow up, take it one chapter at a time, and talk about what you learn with someone you trust.
Final Thoughts
After testing all five, Come As You Are: Revised is still the edition I judge the others against, because it is the clearest, warmest, and most up to date version. The audiobook won for convenience, and the workbook was the best way to turn reading into real change.
My advice is simple: pick the edition that matches how you learn, whether that is reading quietly, listening on the move, or working through exercises, and then give it a few weeks. Read that way, any of these five will leave you better informed and more confident, and you will quickly learn which one belongs on your shelf for good.





