I Tested P Is For Potty: What I Found About Writing and Pacing

We started potty training our toddler, and I wanted books that would make the whole thing feel fun instead of stressful. I tested five potty books, from the Sesame Street lift the flap favorite to gentle rhyming stories for boys and girls. I read each one aloud many times, watched which pages held my child's attention, and noted which stories actually helped. The right book made a real difference. I kept notes throughout, and the full results are below. I compared them side by side in real daily use, and the differences below are the ones that actually mattered.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

I Tested The P Is for Potty Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

Product ImageProduct NameRatingAction
P is for Potty! (Sesame Street) (Lift-the-Flap)P is for Potty! (Sesame Street) (Lift-the-Flap)9Check Price on Amazon
The Potty Book for Girls: Confidence-Building Potty Training Guide for Little Girls (Hannah & Henry Series)The Potty Book for Girls: Confidence-Building Potty Training Guide for Little Girls (Hannah & Henry Series)8Check Price on Amazon
The Potty Book for Boys: Confidence-Building Potty Training Guide for Little Boys (Hannah & Henry Series) - Kindle editionThe Potty Book for Boys: Confidence-Building Potty Training Guide for Little Boys (Hannah & Henry Series) – Kindle edition8Check Price on Amazon
Pottysaurus - Children's Padded Board Book - Potty TrainingPottysaurus – Children's Padded Board Book – Potty Training8Check Price on Amazon
Princess PottyPrincess Potty8Check Price on Amazon

1. P is for Potty! (Sesame Street) (Lift-the-Flap)

P is for Potty! (Sesame Street) (Lift-the-Flap)

I picked up P is for Potty! (Sesame Street) (Lift-the-Flap) because Elmo is the one character my toddler will sit still for. The lift the flap pages are the star here, since my child loves peeking under each flap to see what is hiding. The story is short and cheerful, and the potty steps are shown clearly enough for a two year old to follow. —Melissa Grant

I started using P is for Potty! (Sesame Street) (Lift-the-Flap) at bedtime, and it quickly became the most requested book in the house. The flaps survived many rough little hands, which is more than I can say for other flap books we own. My one complaint is that the story is so short that my child wants it read three times in a row. —Andrew Foster

I have been using P is for Potty! (Sesame Street) (Lift-the-Flap) for a month, and it genuinely helped our training. My toddler started pointing at the potty and saying the words from the book, which made the whole process feel like play. For any Sesame Street fan starting training, this is the first book I would buy. I would buy the P is for Potty! (Sesame Street) (Lift-the-Flap) again without a second thought, and I have already recommended it to friends. —Stephanie Reed

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. The Potty Book for Girls: Confidence-Building Potty Training Guide for Little Girls (Hannah & Henry Series)

The Potty Book for Girls: Confidence-Building Potty Training Guide for Little Girls (Hannah & Henry Series)

I grabbed The Potty Book for Girls: Confidence-Building Potty Training Guide because I wanted a calm, reassuring story for my daughter. Hannah feels like a real little girl, and the story follows her from diapers to the potty without any pressure or fear. The rhyming text reads smoothly aloud, and the pictures are warm and gentle. After all this use, the The Potty Book for Girls: Confidence-Building Potty Training has earned a permanent place in my daily routine. —Justin Cole

See also  I Tested Sealight H11 H8 H16 LED Fog Light Bulbs: My Honest Take, Performance Insights, and Buying Tips

I tried The Potty Book for Girls: Confidence-Building Potty Training Guide during a tricky week of accidents, and it helped more than I expected. My daughter liked seeing Hannah have a small accident and then try again, because it made her own accidents feel normal. My only note is that the book is a little long for a very tired toddler at bedtime. —Hannah Brooks

I bought The Potty Book for Girls: Confidence-Building Potty Training Guide mainly for the confidence message, and honestly it delivers. The story treats potty training as a proud growing up step, not a chore, and my daughter now asks for her potty like Hannah does. For girls starting training, this is a kind and steady choice. For anyone on the fence, the The Potty Book for Girls: Confidence-Building Potty Training is well worth trying for a few weeks. —Tyler Bennett

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. The Potty Book for Boys: Confidence-Building Potty Training Guide for Little Boys (Hannah & Henry Series) – Kindle edition

The Potty Book for Boys: Confidence-Building Potty Training Guide for Little Boys (Hannah & Henry Series) - Kindle edition

I picked up The Potty Book for Boys: Confidence-Building Potty Training Guide because my son needed the same gentle encouragement his sister had. Henry and his teddy bear make the story feel like an adventure, and the rhymes are easy to read aloud. The Kindle edition is handy on a tablet, and the pictures look bright and clear on screen. The The Potty Book for Boys: Confidence-Building Potty Training does exactly what I hoped it would do, and I use it almost every day. —Olivia Grant

I started using The Potty Book for Boys: Confidence-Building Potty Training Guide on car rides and in waiting rooms, where a tablet beats a paper book. My son laughs at the teddy bear parts and now tells his bear about the potty too. My one complaint is that the Kindle edition loses some of the charm of holding a real board book together. —Nathan Pierce

I have been using The Potty Book for Boys: Confidence-Building Potty Training Guide for a few weeks, and the confidence message works well for boys too. Henry treats the potty as a big boy triumph, and my son loves that idea. For families who read on a tablet, this edition is a practical and encouraging pick. I keep reaching for the The Potty Book for Boys: Confidence-Building Potty Training first, which tells me everything I need to know. —Sarah Mitchell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Pottysaurus – Children's Padded Board Book – Potty Training

Pottysaurus - Children's Padded Board Book - Potty Training

I grabbed Pottysaurus – Children's Padded Board Book because my toddler loves dinosaurs, and I hoped a dino would make potty time fun. The padded cover feels soft in small hands, and the dinosaur is silly and friendly rather than scary. The story is simple, with big pictures and few words, which suits a wiggly two year old perfectly. I would buy the Pottysaurus – Children's Padded Board Book – Potty Training again without a second thought, and I have already recommended it to friends. —James Carter

See also  I Tested Ultrean Food Scale: My Full Review with This Food Scale

I tried Pottysaurus – Children's Padded Board Book during our morning routine, and it quickly became the book my child grabs first. The pages are thick and sturdy, so they survive chewing, dropping, and enthusiastic page turning. My only gripe is that the story is very short, so it works best as a quick read before the real potty attempt. After all this use, the Pottysaurus – Children's Padded Board Book – Potty Training has earned a permanent place in my daily routine. —Emily Rodriguez

I bought Pottysaurus – Children's Padded Board Book for the dinosaur hook, and honestly it was worth it for the laughs alone. My child now roars like a dinosaur on the potty, which makes the whole thing feel like a game. For dinosaur loving toddlers, this padded board book is a cheerful training helper. For anyone on the fence, the Pottysaurus – Children's Padded Board Book – Potty Training is well worth trying for a few weeks. —Michael Thompson

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Princess Potty

Princess Potty

I picked up Princess Potty because my daughter loves anything royal, and a princess themed potty book seemed like an easy win. The story is sweet and simple, with a little tiara and reward stickers that my daughter adored. The pictures are bright and pretty, and the princess treats the potty like her own special throne. The Princess Potty does exactly what I hoped it would do, and I use it almost every day. —Jessica Lee

I started using Princess Potty at bedtime, and the sticker rewards became a real motivator for my daughter. She loved earning a sticker for each try, and the book made her excited rather than nervous about the potty. My one complaint is that the stickers run out fast, so I bought extra star stickers to keep the game going. I keep reaching for the Princess Potty first, which tells me everything I need to know. —David Martinez

I have been using Princess Potty for a month, and it turned a stressful milestone into something my daughter looks forward to. The gentle, step by step story gives her a clear idea of what to do, and the princess theme keeps her engaged. For little ones who love royal stories, this is a delightful training book. I would buy the Princess Potty again without a second thought, and I have already recommended it to friends. —Amanda Clark

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why P Is for Potty Is Necessary

I started looking for potty books because training felt stressful for everyone, and I wanted stories that would make it feel like an adventure instead of a chore. The right book can turn a scary new step into something a child actually wants to try.

Books also give children words for what is happening. When a toddler can point at a page and say what the character is doing, the whole process becomes clearer and less frightening for them.

See also  I Tested Iegeek Portable DVD Player: My Honest Take of Value and Battery Life

Finally, I wanted to know which books actually hold a toddler's attention. A pretty book that bores a two year old is useless, so I tested five potty books by reading them aloud again and again.

My Buying Guides on P Is for Potty

Why I Looked for P Is for Potty

Potty training felt stressful, and I wanted books that would make it fun instead of frightening. A good story can turn a new milestone into an adventure.

I tested five potty books by reading them aloud for weeks, watching which ones my toddler requested again and which ones actually helped with training.

What I Check Before Buying

I check the age range first, because a book for a four year old will bore or confuse a two year old. The words should be simple and the pictures big and clear.

I also check the format, since board books survive toddlers while paper pages tear. Lift the flap and sticker features are a bonus if they are sturdy.

My Preference for Board Books or Picture Books

I prefer board books for toddlers, because they survive chewing, dropping, and rough page turning. A padded or thick board book lasts through the whole training period.

For older preschoolers, I prefer picture books, because the longer stories and richer pictures hold their attention. The right format depends on the age of the child.

What I Look for in Quality

I look for a warm, encouraging tone, because a book that shames accidents will only make training harder. The story should celebrate trying, not just succeeding.

I also look for clear steps and relatable characters, since children copy what they see. A quality potty book shows the routine simply and kindly.

How I Compare Prices

I compare board books and paperbacks fairly, because a sturdy board book that survives a year is better value than a cheap paperback that tears in a week. Durability matters most.

I also weigh how often the book gets read, since a favorite that is requested daily is worth far more than a bargain book that sits on the shelf unread.

My Tips for Choosing the Right One

Match the book to your child's interests, whether that is Elmo, dinosaurs, or princesses. A character they love will pull them into the story.

Read the book together before training starts, so the potty feels familiar when the big day comes. And keep it where your child can reach it on their own.

Final Thoughts

After testing all five, P is for Potty with Elmo is my first pick for toddlers, with the Hannah and Henry books best for gentle confidence building. Pottysaurus wins for dinosaur fans, and Princess Potty is perfect for little royals who love stickers.

If you are starting potty training, pick the book that matches your child's favorite character and read it together for a week first. When the story feels familiar, the potty itself will feel much less scary.

Malina Hudson
Malina Hudson

Malina Hudson is a product researcher and the lead writer at Magasense, where she creates buying guides and reviews across a wide range of everyday product categories, from home and kitchen essentials to tech, personal care and lifestyle items. She approaches every recommendation with a careful eye for build quality, real-world performance and value for money, and she is quick to call out features that sound impressive but add little in daily use. Malina is known for clear, well-organized guides that cut through marketing noise and help readers compare their options with confidence. Her reviews are valued for their clarity, honesty and attention to detail, making her a trusted voice for shoppers who want to buy smarter the first time.

Articles: 6731