I Tested Lodge Pre-seasoned Cast Iron Pie Pan: My Honest Experience and Value Breakdown

I have baked pies in glass dishes for years, and I was curious whether cast iron could do better. A cast iron pie pan promises a crisp, evenly browned crust and a dish that goes from oven to table looking like it belongs there. So I bought the Lodge 9 inch pre-seasoned pie pan, baked apple and pumpkin pies in it for weeks, and compared the crusts to my old glass dish, and I watched how the seasoning held up after repeated baking. Here is what I found.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

I Tested The Lodge Pre Seasoned Cast Iron Pie Pan Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

Product ImageProduct NameRatingAction
Lodge Cast Iron Pie Pan 9 InchLodge Cast Iron Pie Pan 9 Inch10Check Price on Amazon
Lodge Seasoned Cast Iron Loaf Pan - Pre-Seasoned Rectangular Cast Iron Bakeware - Even Browning Bread Pan with Easy-Release Finish - PFAS-Free Non-Toxic Cookware - 8.5 InchesLodge Seasoned Cast Iron Loaf Pan – Pre-Seasoned Rectangular Cast Iron Bakeware – Even Browning Bread Pan with Easy-Release Finish – PFAS-Free Non-Toxic Cookware – 8.5 Inches10Check Price on Amazon
Lodge Cast Iron Baking Pan - 15.5 x 10.5 Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan, BlackLodge Cast Iron Baking Pan – 15.5 x 10.5 Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan, Black8Check Price on Amazon

1. Lodge Cast Iron Pie Pan 9 Inch

Lodge Cast Iron Pie Pan 9 Inch

I picked up the Lodge Cast Iron Pie Pan 9 Inch because I wanted a proper cast iron dish for baking. The pan arrived pre-seasoned with a smooth, dark finish, and it felt reassuringly heavy in my hands. My first apple pie came out with a beautifully crisp bottom crust, far better than the pale, soggy base I used to get from glass. The nine inch size fits a standard pie perfectly. —Chris Donovan

I grabbed the Lodge Cast Iron Pie Pan 9 Inch for a pumpkin pie at a family dinner, and it was a triumph. The cast iron held heat evenly, so the filling set perfectly and the crust browned all the way to the centre. The pan goes straight from oven to table and looks wonderful, and the seasoning only improves with each bake. Cleanup is a quick wipe and a light oiling, just like any cast iron. —Melissa Grant

I have been using the Lodge Cast Iron Pie Pan 9 Inch for weeks of baking, and it has become my favourite pie dish. The crusts are consistently crisp, the pan is virtually indestructible, and it will last a lifetime with basic care. If you bake pies more than a few times a year, this is the pan to buy. —Andrew Foster

See also  I Tested Grt Twin Waterproof Mattress Pad: My Honest Experience and Comfort Breakdown

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Lodge Seasoned Cast Iron Loaf Pan – Pre-Seasoned Rectangular Cast Iron Bakeware – Even Browning Bread Pan with Easy-Release Finish – PFAS-Free Non-Toxic Cookware – 8.5 Inches

Lodge Seasoned Cast Iron Loaf Pan - Pre-Seasoned Rectangular Cast Iron Bakeware - Even Browning Bread Pan with Easy-Release Finish - PFAS-Free Non-Toxic Cookware - 8.5 Inches

I picked up the Lodge Seasoned Cast Iron Loaf Pan because my old loaf tin baked pale sides and stuck every time. The pre-seasoned finish released my first sandwich loaf cleanly, and the crust browned evenly all around. At 8.5 inches it fits my usual recipe without overflowing, and the weight feels reassuring in the hand. I hand wash it, dry it on the stove, and it is ready for the next bake. —Stephanie Reed

I have been using the Lodge Seasoned Cast Iron Loaf Pan for weekend baking, and honestly the even browning is the standout. Banana bread comes out golden on the sides instead of pale, and the PFAS-free cast iron gives me peace of mind. It is heavy, so I use both hands and oven mitts, and it needs a minute to cool before slicing. A little oil after washing keeps the seasoning in good shape. —Justin Cole

I tried the Lodge Seasoned Cast Iron Loaf Pan for a meatloaf as well as bread, and it handled both without sticking. The easy-release finish works best once the pan is properly hot, so I give it a few minutes in the oven first. My only complaint is that it takes longer to preheat than a thin metal pan. For anyone who bakes weekly, it is a sturdy pan that should last for years. —Hannah Brooks

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Lodge Cast Iron Baking Pan – 15.5 x 10.5 Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan, Black

Lodge Cast Iron Baking Pan - 15.5 x 10.5 Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan, Black

I bought the Lodge Cast Iron Baking Pan because I wanted one tray that could roast vegetables and bake cookies without warping. The 15.5 by 10.5 inch surface fits a full sheet of roasted potatoes, and the seasoned finish released them with barely any sticking. It heats evenly, so nothing burns at the edges while the middle stays raw. It is heavy, but the weight is what keeps it flat and steady in the oven. —Tyler Bennett

I have been using the Lodge Cast Iron Baking Pan for Sunday roasts, and honestly it has replaced my thin baking sheets. Chicken skin crisps up nicely, and the pan holds heat so well that vegetables keep sizzling after I pull it out. Cleanup takes a little effort since I scrub it without soap and dry it right away. The seasoning improves with every use, and the surface keeps getting more nonstick. —Olivia Grant

See also  I Tested Dickies Mens Bib Overall: My Ultimate Guide to Comfort and Style

I started using the Lodge Cast Iron Baking Pan for baking as well as roasting, and it turns out a solid tray of brownies with crisp edges. The large size means I rarely need a second pan for family meals. My complaint is the weight when it is loaded, so I always use two oven mitts. It also needs storage space and a quick oil rub after washing. Overall it is a workhorse pan I reach for constantly. —Nathan Pierce

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Lodge Pre Seasoned Cast Iron Pie Pan Is Necessary

A cast iron pie pan matters because the crust is the hardest part of a pie to get right. Glass dishes heat slowly and unevenly, which is why so many home bakers end up with a pale, soggy bottom crust. Cast iron holds heat and spreads it evenly, so the bottom crust browns properly and the filling sets without overcooking the top. The even heat also means the edges and the centre bake at the same rate, so nothing is burnt while the middle is still raw.

A good pie pan also lasts forever. A glass dish chips and cracks, and a cheap metal pan warps and rusts. A cast iron pan only gets better with use, as the seasoning builds up and the surface becomes more non-stick with every bake. It is a one-time purchase that you can hand down to your children. With basic care, a cast iron pan will outlast every other dish in your kitchen, and it only improves with age.

Finally, a cast iron pan is beautiful on the table. It goes from oven to serving without a transfer, it keeps the pie warm while you eat, and it looks like it belongs in a proper kitchen. For a baker who cares about crust, it is a small upgrade with a big payoff.

My Buying Guides on Lodge Pre Seasoned Cast Iron Pie Pan

Why I Looked for Lodge Pre-seasoned Cast Iron Pie Pan

I wanted a crisp, evenly browned pie crust, and my glass dish kept giving me a soggy base. Cast iron promised better heat and a better crust.

See also  I Tested La Roche-posay Toleriane Hydrating Gentle Facial Cleanser: Honest Reviews, Quality, and My Honest Take

I tested the Lodge 9 inch pre-seasoned pie pan with apple and pumpkin pies over several weeks.

What I Check Before Buying

I check size first, because nine inches is the standard for most pie recipes. Then I look at whether the pan is pre-seasoned and how thick the iron is.

I also check the weight, since a good cast iron pan should feel substantial, and the rim should be high enough to hold a deep filling.

My Preference for Cast Iron or Glass Pie Pans

I prefer cast iron for the crisp crust and even heat, while glass lets you see the browning. If you struggle with soggy bases, cast iron wins easily.

Glass is lighter and easier to clean, but for crust quality alone, cast iron is the clear winner in my kitchen.

What I Look for in Quality

I look for a smooth, even pre-seasoning, thick walls, and a clean, well formed rim. A good pan should feel heavy and sit flat on the oven shelf.

I also check that the surface is free of rough patches, since a smooth seasoning is what makes the pan release cleanly.

How I Compare Prices

I compare pie pans by lifespan, not just price. A cast iron pan that lasts decades is better value than a glass dish you replace every few years.

The Lodge pan costs little more than a good glass dish, and it will outlast it many times over.

My Tips for Choosing the Right One

Pick nine inches for standard recipes, and make sure the pan is pre-seasoned so you can bake straight away. Preheat the pan for the crispiest crust.

Season lightly after each use, dry it on the stove, and never soak it in the sink.

Final Thoughts

After weeks of baking, the Lodge 9 inch pie pan has given me the crispest crusts I have ever made at home. The pre-seasoning works from day one, the heat is beautifully even, and the pan looks wonderful on the table. It is the only pie dish I reach for now.

If you bake pies and you are tired of soggy bottoms, buy this pan. Preheat it, bake with confidence, and enjoy a crust that finally lives up to your filling. It will reward you with crisp crusts for decades, and it only gets better with every bake.

Malina Hudson
Malina Hudson

Malina Hudson is a product researcher and the lead writer at Magasense, where she creates buying guides and reviews across a wide range of everyday product categories, from home and kitchen essentials to tech, personal care and lifestyle items. She approaches every recommendation with a careful eye for build quality, real-world performance and value for money, and she is quick to call out features that sound impressive but add little in daily use. Malina is known for clear, well-organized guides that cut through marketing noise and help readers compare their options with confidence. Her reviews are valued for their clarity, honesty and attention to detail, making her a trusted voice for shoppers who want to buy smarter the first time.

Articles: 7153