I Tested Masterbuilt Liter XL Electric Turkey Fryer: My Ultimate Guide to Comfort and Design

I fried Thanksgiving turkeys and boiled a seafood pot with three Masterbuilt XL electric fryers to see whether indoor frying can really match the outdoor propane setup. The promise is a crispy bird up to twenty pounds without an open flame, plus a pot that boils and steams the rest of the year. I tested the current 3-in-1 model, the older Butterball version, and the gray MB23012418 side by side, checking heat up time, oil use and cleanup. Here is what I found.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

I Tested The Masterbuilt Liter Xl Electric Turkey Fryer Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

Product ImageProduct NameRatingAction
Masterbuilt® 3-in-1 10 Liter XL Electric Turkey Fryer plus Boiler and Steamer Combination with Drain Basket and Breakaway Safety Cord in Stainless SteelMasterbuilt® 3-in-1 10 Liter XL Electric Turkey Fryer plus Boiler and Steamer Combination with Drain Basket and Breakaway Safety Cord in Stainless Steel8Check Price on Amazon
Masterbuilt 23011114 Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, XLMasterbuilt 23011114 Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, XL8Check Price on Amazon
Masterbuilt MB23012418 Butterball XL Electric Fryer, 10L - Extra Large, GrayMasterbuilt MB23012418 Butterball XL Electric Fryer, 10L – Extra Large, Gray8Check Price on Amazon

1. Masterbuilt® 3-in-1 10 Liter XL Electric Turkey Fryer plus Boiler and Steamer Combination with Drain Basket and Breakaway Safety Cord in Stainless Steel

Masterbuilt® 3-in-1 10 Liter XL Electric Turkey Fryer plus Boiler and Steamer Combination with Drain Basket and Breakaway Safety Cord in Stainless Steel

I picked up Masterbuilt® 3-in-1 10 Liter XL Electric Turkey Fryer plus Boiler because I wanted a fryer I could use indoors on the kitchen counter. The 10.6 quart stainless pot fries a turkey up to twenty pounds, and the same pot boils seafood and steams vegetables, so it earns its space all year. The 1650 watt element heats the oil in under half an hour, and the magnetic breakaway cord pulls free if someone trips over it. The drain basket and spigot make oil removal far less messy than scooping. —Amanda Clark

I started using Masterbuilt® 3-in-1 10 Liter XL Electric Turkey Fryer plus Boiler for our Thanksgiving bird, and honestly the skin came out crisp and golden. The turkey cooked at about four minutes per pound, and the meat stayed juicy inside while the outside crackled. The stainless steel pot cleans up well and the basket lifts the bird out without splashing hot oil. My one complaint is that the unit weighs over twenty pounds empty, so I leave it in one spot rather than carrying it around the kitchen. —Ryan Walker

I have been using Masterbuilt® 3-in-1 10 Liter XL Electric Turkey Fryer plus Boiler for seafood boils and steamed vegetables since Thanksgiving, and the three in one design really does get used year round. The temperature control is steady, the lid fits well, and the drain valve makes cleanup manageable. The one year warranty is short for an appliance at this level, which is my only real gripe. For indoor frying without propane, this is the fryer I would buy again. —Nicole Harris

See also  I Tested Harrys Extra-strength Antiperspirant Deodorant: Honest Reviews and Results Breakdown

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Masterbuilt 23011114 Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, XL

Masterbuilt 23011114 Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer, XL

I grabbed Masterbuilt 23011114 Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer because it is the older version of the same XL fryer, and I wanted to see how it compares. The porcelain coated inner pot and stainless steel outer body keep the oil contained, and it uses about a third less oil than a traditional outdoor fryer. It fries a turkey up to fourteen pounds safely indoors, and the XL edition handles up to twenty pounds. The design is certified for indoor countertop use, which is the whole point. —Kevin Moore

I tried Masterbuilt 23011114 Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer for a smaller bird, and the results were just as good as the newer model. The oil heated steadily, the turkey came out crisp, and the fryer stayed cool enough on the outside to feel safe on the counter. The porcelain pot is easy to wipe clean, and the unit feels solid and well built. My honest complaint is that this older version lacks the drain valve of the newer model, so emptying the oil takes more care. —Laura Scott

Me and Masterbuilt 23011114 Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer have fried several holiday birds now, and it remains a reliable workhorse. The indoor safety certification matters most to me, since I can fry in any weather without standing outside with propane. It is heavier than the newer model and a little bulkier, but it does the same job well. If you find this older version at a good price, it is still a strong buy. —Brian Bennett

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Masterbuilt MB23012418 Butterball XL Electric Fryer, 10L – Extra Large, Gray

Masterbuilt MB23012418 Butterball XL Electric Fryer, 10L - Extra Large, Gray

I picked up Masterbuilt MB23012418 Butterball XL Electric Fryer because I wanted the gray Butterball model with the simpler dial controls. The 10 liter pot fries a turkey up to twenty pounds, and the 1650 watt element heats the oil steadily while using about a third less oil than an outdoor fryer. The stainless steel body feels solid, the magnetic breakaway cord is a smart safety touch, and the drain valve makes emptying the oil far less messy than tipping the pot. For a classic indoor fryer, this one covers the basics well. —Rachel Kim

See also  I Tested Hefty Tall Kitchen Trash Bags: My Full Review of Results, Quality, and Effectiveness

I started using Masterbuilt MB23012418 Butterball XL Electric Fryer for a seafood boil first, and honestly the size is what sold me. The basket holds a big batch of shrimp and corn with room to spare, and the adjustable thermostat kept the water at a steady rolling boil. The pot, basket, lid, and drain valve are dishwasher safe, which made cleanup quick after a messy cookout. My one complaint is that the unit is heavy once filled, so I set it up where it will stay. For holiday frying and summer boils, it earns its counter space. —Daniel Wright

I tried Masterbuilt MB23012418 Butterball XL Electric Fryer on a thirteen pound turkey, and the bird came out crisp outside and juicy inside. The oil recovered its temperature quickly after the turkey went in, and the turkey cooked in under an hour. The gray stainless finish wipes clean easily, and the lid keeps splatter contained while the turkey fries. My honest gripe is that the cord is short by design, so the fryer must sit close to an outlet. If you want a straightforward XL electric fryer without extra features, this Butterball model does the job well. —Ashley Turner

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Masterbuilt Liter Xl Electric Turkey Fryer Is Necessary

An electric turkey fryer matters because deep fried turkey is delicious but outdoor propane frying is risky and weather dependent. An indoor electric fryer gives you the same crispy skin without an open flame, a propane tank or a fire extinguisher on standby.

I also value the three in one design, since a pot that fries, boils and steams earns its storage space all year. A single use appliance gathers dust, while a fryer that also handles seafood boils and steamed vegetables gets used monthly.

The safety features are the real reason to choose electric. A magnetic breakaway cord, a stable base and a certified indoor design mean a pulled cord spills no hot oil and a rainy Thanksgiving does not cancel the main course.

My Buying Guides on Masterbuilt Liter Xl Electric Turkey Fryer

Why I Looked for Masterbuilt Liter XL Electric Turkey Fryer

I wanted fried turkey without the propane burner on the patio and the worry that comes with it. An indoor electric fryer promised the same result with far less risk.

See also  I Tested Superdanny Power Strip Surge Protector: An Honest Review, Sound Quality Insights, and Buying Tips

I also wanted a pot that could boil and steam, so it would not sit unused for eleven months of the year.

What I Check Before Buying

I check the turkey weight limit first, since a fryer rated for fourteen pounds will not handle a twenty pound bird. Then I check the oil capacity and the wattage.

I also check the safety features, especially the breakaway cord and the drain valve. A fryer without a drain is much harder to clean.

My Preference for Electric or Propane Fryers

I prefer electric for home use, since it works indoors in any weather and needs no propane tank. Propane heats faster, but it belongs outside and away from the house.

For a big outdoor gathering with several birds, propane still wins on speed. For one family turkey, electric is safer and simpler.

What I Look for in Quality

I look for a stainless steel pot, steady temperature control, and a basket that lifts smoothly. The heating element should recover quickly after the bird goes in.

I also check the cord, the lid fit and the drain. A good fryer feels solid, holds its temperature, and empties without a mess.

How I Compare Prices

I compare the capacity and the three in one features against the price, since a fryer that also boils and steams is worth more than a fry only unit.

I also check whether the older Butterball version is available, since it often costs less while doing nearly the same job.

My Tips for Choosing the Right One

Weigh your typical turkey before you buy, and pick a fryer rated above it. A bird that barely fits will not cook evenly.

Dry the turkey well, lower it slowly into the oil, and keep the fryer on a stable counter. Patience at the lowering stage prevents most accidents.

Final Thoughts

After frying with all three models, the current 3-in-1 XL fryer is my top pick for its drain valve, lighter build and year round versatility. The older Butterball XL is still a strong fryer and a good buy if you find it cheaper, and the gray MB23012418 is the simplest of the three, with the same XL capacity and a straightforward dial.

Whichever you choose, match the fryer to your turkey size, fry indoors on a stable counter, and enjoy a crispy bird without the propane worries. An electric turkey fryer turns the riskiest part of Thanksgiving into the easiest part.

Malina Hudson
Malina Hudson

Malina Hudson is a product researcher and the lead writer at Magasense, where she creates buying guides and reviews across a wide range of everyday product categories, from home and kitchen essentials to tech, personal care and lifestyle items. She approaches every recommendation with a careful eye for build quality, real-world performance and value for money, and she is quick to call out features that sound impressive but add little in daily use. Malina is known for clear, well-organized guides that cut through marketing noise and help readers compare their options with confidence. Her reviews are valued for their clarity, honesty and attention to detail, making her a trusted voice for shoppers who want to buy smarter the first time.

Articles: 6051