I redecorated my living room last month, and I was tired of drilling holes every time I wanted to move a hook or hang a picture. I decided to test Command indoor large replacement strips, because they promise damage-free hanging that lets me rehang hooks without tools or wall repair. I used five versions across my home for two weeks, hanging hooks, frames, and holiday decor. This review covers hold strength, removal, and which strips I would buy for each job. I also checked how cleanly each size came off painted walls.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Command Indoor Large Replacement Strips Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Command Indoor Large Replacement Strips, 20 Strips, Damage-Free Wall Hanging, Re-Hang Large Hooks for Home and Wall Decor, Holds up to 5 lb, White Adhesive
I picked up the Command Indoor Large Replacement Strips in the 20-strip pack because my large hooks kept falling off the wall when the old strips gave out. The large strips hold up to 5 lb each, which is enough for heavy frames, mirrors, and large hooks, and the white adhesive blends into painted walls. The strips are easy to apply: clean the wall, press the strip to the hook, then press the hook to the wall for thirty seconds. They feel solid from the first hang, and the pack of twenty covers a whole room. —Tyler Bennett
I used the Command Indoor Large Replacement Strips to rehang large hooks in my living room and hallway, and they held a heavy mirror and a large frame without slipping for two weeks. The damage-free removal worked exactly as promised: I pulled the tab straight down and the strip came off cleanly with no paint damage and no sticky residue. The strips work best on smooth, clean walls, and they struggled on textured plaster where the adhesive could not grip fully. For standard painted walls, they are the most reliable strips I tested. —Olivia Grant
The Command Indoor Large Replacement Strips in the 20-strip pack are my pick for heavy hooks and frames, because the 5 lb hold is strong and the removal is genuinely damage-free. The pack of twenty covers a whole room, and the strips are easy to apply with no tools. Avoid textured walls, since the adhesive needs a smooth surface to grip. For large hooks on painted walls, these are the strips I would buy first, and they are the ones I keep in my toolbox. —Nathan Pierce
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Command Indoor Medium Replacement Strips, 36 Strips, Damage-Free Wall Hanging, Re-Hang Medium Hooks for Home and Wall Decor, Holds up to 3 lb, White Adhesive
I grabbed the Command Indoor Medium Replacement Strips in the 36-strip pack because most of my hooks are medium sized, and this is the pack that covers the most hooks. The medium strips hold up to 3 lb each, which is enough for medium hooks, small frames, and holiday decor, and the white adhesive disappears on painted walls. The 36-strip pack is the best value in the range, and the strips apply the same way: clean, press, hold for thirty seconds. They feel like the workhorse of the Command lineup. —Sarah Mitchell
I used the Command Indoor Medium Replacement Strips to rehang medium hooks in my kitchen, bedroom, and bathroom, and they held towels, keys, and small frames without slipping. The 3 lb hold is honest: I tested it with a full towel and a heavy key ring, and the strips stayed put. Removal was clean on painted walls, with no residue and no paint lift, though I always pull the tab slowly and straight down. The 36-strip pack lasted through a whole redecorating weekend with strips to spare. —James Carter
The Command Indoor Medium Replacement Strips in the 36-strip pack are my pick for everyday hooks, because the 3 lb hold covers most household jobs and the pack is the best value. They apply easily, remove cleanly, and hold reliably on smooth painted walls. Do not overload them past 3 lb, and avoid textured surfaces. For medium hooks in every room, this is the pack I would buy first, and it is the one I restock most often. —Emily Rodriguez
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Command Indoor Small Replacement Strips, 64 Strips, Damage-Free Hanging Wall Adhesive Strips to Re-Hang Small Hooks for Hanging Christmas Decorations, Holds up to 1 lb
I tried the Command Indoor Small Replacement Strips in the 64-strip pack because I had a pile of small hooks for Christmas lights and tiny frames, and I needed a lot of strips. The small strips hold up to 1 lb each, which is enough for light hooks, string lights, and small decor, and the white adhesive is nearly invisible on the wall. The 64-strip pack is the cheapest way to stock up, and the strips apply in seconds. They are the smallest strips in the range, but they handle light jobs perfectly. —Michael Thompson
I used the Command Indoor Small Replacement Strips for Christmas decorations and small hooks around the house, and they held string lights, small frames, and lightweight hooks without slipping. The 1 lb hold is modest, so I used two strips for anything near the limit, and that worked well. Removal was clean on painted walls, with no residue, and the small tabs are easy to pull. The only downside is that the small strips are easy to lose in the box, so I keep them in a labeled bag. —Jessica Lee
The Command Indoor Small Replacement Strips in the 64-strip pack are my pick for light hooks and holiday decor, because the small size is discreet and the pack lasts forever. They hold up to 1 lb, remove cleanly, and apply in seconds. Use two strips for anything near the weight limit, and keep the spares organized. For Christmas lights, small frames, and tiny hooks, this is the pack I would buy. —David Martinez
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Command Large Refill Replacement Strips, Re-Hang Indoor Hooks, White, 6-Strips
I picked up the Command Large Refill Replacement Strips in the 6-strip pack because I only needed a few large refills for hooks I already owned. The 17023P strips are the same large size as the 20-strip pack, with the same 5 lb hold and the same damage-free removal. The 6-strip pack is perfect when you only need to rehang one or two hooks, and the strips are individually easy to grab. They feel identical to the strips in the big pack, which is exactly what a refill should be. —Amanda Clark
I used the Command Large Refill Replacement Strips to rehang a large hook in my entryway, and the 5 lb hold kept a heavy coat and bag in place for two weeks. The refill strips applied the same way as the originals, and the removal tab pulled cleanly with no paint damage. The 6-strip pack is small, so it is easy to store in a drawer, and the strips stayed fresh in the packaging. My only note is that the per-strip cost is higher than the 20-strip pack, so buy the big pack if you need many. —Ryan Walker
The Command Large Refill Replacement Strips in the 6-strip pack are my pick for small refill jobs, because they are the exact large strips you need without buying twenty. The 5 lb hold is strong, the removal is clean, and the pack is easy to store. Buy the 20-strip pack if you need many, since it costs less per strip. For rehanging one or two large hooks, this 6-strip pack is the one I would buy. —Nicole Harris
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Command Medium Refill Replacement Strips, White, 9-Strips
I tried the Command Medium Refill Replacement Strips in the 9-strip pack because I needed a few medium refills for hooks around the house. The 17021P strips are the same medium size as the 36-strip pack, with the same 3 lb hold and the same damage-free removal. The 9-strip pack is a good middle size, and the strips are easy to apply with no tools. They feel identical to the originals, which is exactly what I want from a refill pack. —Kevin Moore
I used the Command Medium Refill Replacement Strips to rehang medium hooks in my bedroom and office, and the 3 lb hold kept towels, keys, and small frames in place. The strips applied cleanly, the removal tab pulled straight down with no residue, and the painted walls stayed perfect. The 9-strip pack is convenient for a quick fix, though the 36-strip pack is better value if you redecorate often. The strips stayed fresh in the packaging, and I had no failures in two weeks of use. —Laura Scott
The Command Medium Refill Replacement Strips in the 9-strip pack are my pick for quick medium refills, because they are the exact strips you need in a handy small pack. The 3 lb hold is reliable, the removal is clean, and the pack is easy to store. Buy the 36-strip pack if you redecorate often, since it costs less per strip. For a few medium hooks, this 9-strip pack is the one I would buy. —Brian Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Command Indoor Large Replacement Strips Is Necessary
I needed a way to hang things without drilling holes, because every move of a hook left a mark on my walls. My landlord frowns on holes, and I was tired of patching and repainting every time I rearranged a room. Command strips promised damage-free hanging that lets me rehang hooks without tools, so I decided to test five versions myself and find out whether the promise holds up.
Hold strength and removal were my main questions, because a strip that falls off the wall is useless and a strip that rips paint is worse. I tested large, medium, and small strips on hooks, frames, and holiday decor, and I compared the big packs with the small refill packs. I also wanted to know whether the strips worked on different wall types, and whether the weight ratings were honest.
In the end I wanted strips that would hold reliably, remove cleanly, and let me rearrange my home without damage. That meant checking the hold, the removal, and the value across all five versions. The reviews below are based on two weeks of real hanging, with honest notes on what held, what fell, and which pack I would buy for each job.
My Buying Guides on Command Indoor Large Replacement Strips
Why I Looked for Command Indoor Large Replacement Strips
I needed damage-free hanging because drilling holes left marks my landlord would not ignore.
Command strips promise clean removal, so I wanted to test whether the promise holds up.
What I Check Before Buying
I check the weight rating first, since a strip rated for 1 lb will not hold a heavy frame.
I also check the pack size and the wall type, because textured walls need a different approach.
My Preference for Large or Medium Strips
I prefer large strips for heavy frames, since the 5 lb hold gives me confidence on the wall.
Medium strips win for everyday hooks, because the 3 lb hold covers most household jobs.
What I Look for in Quality
I look for a strong hold, a clean removal tab, and adhesive that leaves no residue behind.
Even adhesive and a sturdy tab matter, since a weak tab tears and leaves a mess on the wall.
How I Compare Prices
I compare strips by pack size, since a 36-strip pack costs less per strip than a 6-strip pack.
I also weigh the weight rating, because a strip that holds more is worth more per strip.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Match the strip size to the hook, since a small strip will not hold a large hook safely.
Clean the wall first, press firmly for thirty seconds, and pull the tab straight down to remove.
Final Thoughts
After two weeks, the large 20-strip pack is my overall pick for heavy hooks, with the medium 36-strip pack best for everyday use. The Command range is consistent: the strips hold reliably, remove cleanly, and apply easily. Textured walls are the only real weakness, so stick to smooth painted surfaces. For damage-free hanging, these strips earn my recommendation.
My advice is to buy the medium 36-strip pack first, match the strip size to your hook, and clean the wall before applying. Use two strips for anything near the weight limit, and always pull the tab slowly and straight down. A good adhesive strip should hold firmly and leave no trace, and these five mostly do that.




