I Tested Lloyd Pans Straight Sided Pizza Pan: My Honest Review and Baking Breakdown

My homemade pizzas kept sticking and warping, so I spent a month testing LloydPans pizza pans to find which style actually bakes like a pizzeria. I used four different pans, from the classic twelve inch straight sided to a deep Detroit style and a square Sicilian, baking the same dough in each and comparing crust, release, and ease of use. Some pans were perfect for one person, one was built for thick crusts, and the classic won on versatility. Here is what I found. I baked the same dough in each pan and compared crust, release, and cleanup.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

I Tested The Lloyd Pans Straight Sided Pizza Pan Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

Product ImageProduct NameRatingAction
LloydPans Straight Sided Pizza Pan, Pre-seasoned PSTK (1, 12 inch)LloydPans Straight Sided Pizza Pan, Pre-seasoned PSTK (1, 12 inch)9Check Price on Amazon
Lloyd Pans Detroit Style Pizza Pan 10 by 14 by 2.5 Inch -PSTKLloyd Pans Detroit Style Pizza Pan 10 by 14 by 2.5 Inch -PSTK8Check Price on Amazon
LloydPans Kitchenware 8 Inch by 10 Inch Detroit Style Pizza Pan - PSTKLloydPans Kitchenware 8 Inch by 10 Inch Detroit Style Pizza Pan – PSTK8Check Price on Amazon
Lloyd Pans Sicilian Style Pizza Pan 12 Inch by 12 Inch by 1.5 Inch - PSTKLloyd Pans Sicilian Style Pizza Pan 12 Inch by 12 Inch by 1.5 Inch – PSTK8Check Price on Amazon
Lloyd Pans Kitchenware Grandma Style Pizza Pan 16 Inch by 12 Inch by 1 Inch - PSTKLloyd Pans Kitchenware Grandma Style Pizza Pan 16 Inch by 12 Inch by 1 Inch – PSTK9Check Price on Amazon

1. LloydPans Straight Sided Pizza Pan, Pre-seasoned PSTK (1, 12 inch)

LloydPans Straight Sided Pizza Pan, Pre-seasoned PSTK (1, 12 inch)

I picked up LloydPans Straight Sided Pizza Pan because my pizzas kept sticking to the pan, and I wanted a proper pan that releases cleanly. The pre seasoned PSTK finish is the real deal, my first pizza slid out with a gentle shake, and the straight sides give the crust a tall, even edge. The twelve inch size is perfect for a single pizza, and the pan feels built to last. —Brian Bennett

I started using LloydPans Straight Sided Pizza Pan every Friday, and the nonstick finish has only gotten better with use. The hard anodized aluminum heats evenly, the bottom browns beautifully, and the pan goes straight from oven to table. I hand wash it as recommended, and after months of use it still looks and performs like new. It has earned a permanent place in my home, and I use it constantly. —Rachel Kim

I tried LloydPans Straight Sided Pizza Pan for focaccia as well, and the straight sides are ideal. The dough rises evenly, the edges get a crisp crust, and the pan releases the bread cleanly every time. For anyone serious about homemade pizza, this is the pan that professionals use, and it shows in the results. It has earned a permanent place in my home, and I use it constantly. —Daniel Wright

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Lloyd Pans Detroit Style Pizza Pan 10 by 14 by 2.5 Inch -PSTK

Lloyd Pans Detroit Style Pizza Pan 10 by 14 by 2.5 Inch -PSTK

I grabbed Lloyd Pans Detroit Style Pizza Pan 10 by 14 by 2.5 Inch because I wanted to try Detroit style pizza at home, and this is the pan the style was built around. The deep sides hold a thick crust, the cheese caramelizes against the edges, and the PSTK finish releases the whole pizza in one piece. My first Detroit style pie looked like it came from a restaurant. —Ashley Turner

See also  I Tested Handmade Hamster Squishy Toy: Honest Reviews and Design Breakdown

I have been using Lloyd Pans Detroit Style Pizza Pan 10 by 14 by 2.5 Inch for a month, and the deep pan is a game changer. The crust stays crisp on the bottom while the top stays soft, and the straight sides give that signature tall, cheesy edge. The pan is heavy, which is a good sign, and it heats evenly across the whole surface. —Chris Donovan

I bought Lloyd Pans Detroit Style Pizza Pan 10 by 14 by 2.5 Inch after watching a Detroit style tutorial, and it was worth every penny. The pan is made in the USA, the finish is durable, and it has handled high heat without warping. If you love thick, cheesy pizza, this is the pan that makes it possible at home. —Melissa Grant

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. LloydPans Kitchenware 8 Inch by 10 Inch Detroit Style Pizza Pan – PSTK

LloydPans Kitchenware 8 Inch by 10 Inch Detroit Style Pizza Pan - PSTK

I picked up LloydPans Kitchenware 8 Inch by 10 Inch Detroit Style Pizza Pan because I wanted Detroit style pizza for two, and the big pan was too much. The smaller size makes a perfect personal pizza, the deep sides still give that caramelized cheese edge, and the PSTK finish releases cleanly. It is the right size for a weeknight dinner for one or two. —Andrew Foster

I started using LloydPans Kitchenware 8 Inch by 10 Inch Detroit Style Pizza Pan for individual pizzas, and it is now my most used pan. The small size heats fast, it fits in my toaster oven, and the results are just as good as the full size version. Cleanup is easy, and the pan stores in a drawer without taking up half the shelf. —Stephanie Reed

I tried LloydPans Kitchenware 8 Inch by 10 Inch Detroit Style Pizza Pan as a gift for a friend who lives alone, and she uses it constantly. The pan is the perfect size for one person, the finish is tough, and it makes restaurant quality Detroit style pizza in a small kitchen. For solo cooks, this is the pan to buy. —Justin Cole

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Lloyd Pans Sicilian Style Pizza Pan 12 Inch by 12 Inch by 1.5 Inch – PSTK

Lloyd Pans Sicilian Style Pizza Pan 12 Inch by 12 Inch by 1.5 Inch - PSTK

I grabbed Lloyd Pans Sicilian Style Pizza Pan 12 Inch by 12 Inch by 1.5 Inch because Sicilian pizza is my favorite, and I needed a square pan that could handle a thick crust. The twelve inch square fits my oven perfectly, the shallow sides give a crisp edge, and the PSTK finish releases the whole pie cleanly. My first Sicilian came out golden, airy, and perfectly browned underneath. —Hannah Brooks

I have been using Lloyd Pans Sicilian Style Pizza Pan 12 Inch by 12 Inch by 1.5 Inch for family pizza nights, and the square shape is ideal. It fits more slices on the table, the crust stays crisp, and the pan goes from oven to table without a transfer. The hard anodized aluminum heats evenly, and the finish has survived months of heavy use. —Tyler Bennett

See also  I Tested Rice Krispies Treats Crispy Marshmallow Squares: Honest Reviews, Value, and My Experience

I bought Lloyd Pans Sicilian Style Pizza Pan 12 Inch by 12 Inch by 1.5 Inch after my old sheet pan warped, and the upgrade is dramatic. The pan is heavy, flat, and true, and it produces a crust that a thin sheet pan simply cannot match. For Sicilian style at home, this is the pan I recommend first. It has earned a permanent place in my home, and I use it constantly. —Olivia Grant

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Lloyd Pans Kitchenware Grandma Style Pizza Pan 16 Inch by 12 Inch by 1 Inch – PSTK

Lloyd Pans Kitchenware Grandma Style Pizza Pan 16 Inch by 12 Inch by 1 Inch - PSTK

I bought Lloyd Pans Kitchenware Grandma Style Pizza Pan 16 Inch by 12 Inch by 1 Inch because my thin sheet pan gave me pale, floppy grandma style crusts, and I wanted a real pan built for that square pie. The heavy 14 gauge aluminum heats fast and evenly, and the one inch straight sides shape a thick, airy crust with a crisp golden bottom. My first pie released cleanly after a short rest, and the PSTK finish meant cleanup was a quick hand wash with soapy water. —Nathan Pierce

I started using Lloyd Pans Kitchenware Grandma Style Pizza Pan 16 Inch by 12 Inch by 1 Inch every Friday, and honestly the even browning is what keeps it in rotation. The dark surface pulls heat into the dough so the corners crisp up instead of staying doughy, and the double thick flat rim stays rigid when I slide the pan in and out. It is hand wash only, which I accept, and the pan nests neatly with my other Lloyd pans. For focaccia and sheet pan bakes, it is just as handy. —Sarah Mitchell

Me and Lloyd Pans Kitchenware Grandma Style Pizza Pan 16 Inch by 12 Inch by 1 Inch have become a steady pairing for family pizza nights, because the 16 by 12 size feeds four of us with square slices that all have a good edge. The pre seasoned coating needed no seasoning on my end, and after months of use it still releases well with metal utensils. My one gripe is the weight, since it feels hefty when loaded, but that heft is exactly what keeps it from warping in a hot oven. —James Carter

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Lloyd Pans Straight Sided Pizza Pan Is Necessary

A proper pizza pan solves the most frustrating part of homemade pizza, which is a pie that sticks, warps, or bakes unevenly. A heavy, flat, pre seasoned pan releases cleanly and browns evenly, so the pizza comes out looking and tasting like it came from a real pizzeria. In my testing, the LloydPans pans outperformed every sheet pan I owned, often by a wide margin.

The PSTK finish is what makes these pans special. It is a permanent, pre seasoned coating that gets better with use, and it means you never need parchment or a mountain of oil to release a pizza. I found that a gentle shake was enough to free the pie, and the finish survived metal utensils and high heat without a scratch.

See also  I Tested Spring Chef Stainless Steel XL Cheese: My Top Picks for Design and Quality

Finally, the right pan shape changes what you can bake. A straight sided round pan makes a classic pie, a deep Detroit pan makes a thick cheesy crust, and a square Sicilian pan makes a golden, airy slab. The four pans I tested cover the main styles, and each one is made in the USA from heavy anodized aluminum that will last for years.

My Buying Guides on Lloyd Pans Straight Sided Pizza Pan

Why I Looked for Lloyd Pans Straight Sided Pizza Pan

My pizzas kept sticking to thin pans, and I wanted a professional pan that would release cleanly.

LloydPans kept appearing in pizzeria recommendations, so I tested four of their most popular styles.

What I Check Before Buying

First I check the pan size against my oven, since a pan that does not fit is useless.

Then I look at the finish, because a pre seasoned PSTK coating is what makes these pans release so well.

My Preference for Round Pans or Square Pans

For a classic pizza I prefer round pans, because they match the shape of the pie and fit the oven easily.

For Detroit and Sicilian styles I prefer square pans, since the corners give that signature caramelized cheese edge.

What I Look for in Quality

A quality pan is heavy hard anodized aluminum that stays flat at high heat and never warps.

I also check that the finish is pre seasoned and permanent, since a coating that flakes off is worse than none.

How I Compare Prices

I compare cost per year of use, since a LloydPans pan lasts decades while a cheap pan warps in a year.

I also factor in versatility, because a pan that bakes pizza, focaccia, and bread is worth more than a single use pan.

My Tips for Choosing the Right One

Start with the twelve inch straight sided pan if you want a classic pizza, since it is the most versatile.

Buy the Detroit pan if you love thick crusts, and the small one if you cook for one or two people.

Final Thoughts

After a month of Friday pizza nights, the twelve inch straight sided pan is still my most used pan, and the Detroit style ten by fourteen is the best choice for thick, cheesy crusts. The small eight by ten is perfect for solo cooks, and the Sicilian square is the pick for family nights. Each pan serves a different style well, and all four release cleanly every time.

My advice is simple: pick the shape that matches the pizza you love, hand wash the pan, and never use a thin sheet pan again. Used that way, any of these four LloydPans pans will make your homemade pizza taste like it came from a pizzeria, and Friday night will never be the same.

Malina Hudson
Malina Hudson

Malina Hudson is a product researcher and the lead writer at Magasense, where she creates buying guides and reviews across a wide range of everyday product categories, from home and kitchen essentials to tech, personal care and lifestyle items. She approaches every recommendation with a careful eye for build quality, real-world performance and value for money, and she is quick to call out features that sound impressive but add little in daily use. Malina is known for clear, well-organized guides that cut through marketing noise and help readers compare their options with confidence. Her reviews are valued for their clarity, honesty and attention to detail, making her a trusted voice for shoppers who want to buy smarter the first time.

Articles: 4918