I bake most weekends, from birthday layer cakes to weeknight brownies, so I spent the last month testing nordic ware classic metal covered cake pan and four other Nordic Ware cake pans side by side. I baked the same recipes in each pan, watching for even browning, easy release, warping, and how the pan cleaned up afterward. Some pans browned edge to edge, one released a cake in a single perfect piece, and the covered pan earned its keep at a potluck. Here is what I found, pan by pan.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Nordic Ware Classic Metal Covered Cake Pan Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Nordic Ware Classic Metal 9×13 Covered Cake Pan
I picked up the Nordic Ware Classic Metal pan because I needed a reliable nine by thirteen for sheet cakes and potluck casseroles. The natural aluminum heats evenly, and my Texas sheet cake came out golden edge to edge with no dark corners. The metal cover snaps on snugly for carrying, and it kept the cake fresh overnight without plastic wrap. It is light enough to carry with one hand, and it has survived a year of regular use without warping. —Emily Rodriguez
I have been using the Nordic Ware Classic Metal pan for everything from brownies to lasagna, and honestly the lid is what makes it my most reached for pan. The cover doubles as a tray for cooling, and the pan itself cleans up with a quick soak and a soft sponge. I do hand wash it, since aluminum and the dishwasher do not mix well, and the finish still looks new. My one gripe is that the metal lid is not oven safe, so I swap it for foil when a recipe needs covering in the oven. —Michael Thompson
I tried the Nordic Ware Classic Metal pan at a family gathering, carrying a warm casserole across town with the lid on tight. Nothing spilled, the food stayed warm, and the pan slid easily into a standard oven when we reheated it. The reinforced rim has kept the pan flat through many hot bakes, which cheaper pans never manage. For the money, this is the covered pan I recommend to anyone who bakes for a crowd. —Jessica Lee
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Nordic Ware Classic Cast Pound Cake, Nonstick 10 Inch One Piece Pan – Great for Angel Food, Coffee Cake, 18 Cup – Graphite
I bought Nordic Ware Classic Cast Pound Cake because my grandmother's pound cake recipe deserves a pan that can handle a tall, dense batter. The heavy cast aluminum holds heat beautifully, and my cake rose evenly with a crisp, golden crust. The eighteen cup capacity swallows a double recipe without overflowing, and the nonstick coating released the cake in one clean piece. It feels substantial in the hand, and it bakes like a professional pan should. —David Martinez
I have been using Nordic Ware Classic Cast Pound Cake for angel food and coffee cakes too, and honestly the one piece design is the quiet hero here. With no seam or removable bottom, thin batters cannot leak, and cleanup is a simple wash and dry. The graphite nonstick surface needs only a light greasing, and my cakes release without a fight. My one complaint is the size, since the pan is tall and takes up real space in the cabinet. —Amanda Clark
I tried Nordic Ware Classic Cast Pound Cake on a sour cream pound cake for a church bake sale, and it came out with the most even crumb I have managed yet. The cast walls browned the outside gently while the center baked through completely, with no raw middle. I let it cool ten minutes, turned it out, and the fluted shape held beautifully. For bakers who love tall cakes and hate leaks, this pan is worth every bit of shelf space. —Ryan Walker
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Nordic Ware Naturals Round Cake Pan, 8-Inch
I picked up Nordic Ware Naturals Round Cake Pan in the eight inch size for small layer cakes and birthday treats. The pure aluminum bakes evenly, and my vanilla sponge came out level with a soft golden top. There is no nonstick coating to wear out, so I grease and flour it the old fashioned way, and the cake releases cleanly every time. It is a simple, honest pan that does exactly what a round cake pan should do. —Nicole Harris
I grabbed Nordic Ware Naturals Round Cake Pan when I started baking layer cakes regularly, and the eight inch size is perfect for two layer birthday cakes. The reinforced steel rim keeps the pan from warping, even after many hot oven cycles. My cakes brown evenly without dark edges, which used to be my biggest frustration with thin pans. I hand wash it to protect the aluminum finish, and it still looks nearly new after a year. —Kevin Moore
I started using Nordic Ware Naturals Round Cake Pan for everything from chocolate layers to carrot cake, and honestly the even heating is what sold me. The pan feels sturdy without being heavy, and it stacks neatly with my other bakeware. I line the bottom with parchment for easy release, which takes seconds and saves a stuck cake. For anyone building a baking collection, this is the round pan I would buy first. —Laura Scott
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Nordic Ware Naturals Round Cake Pan, 9-Inch
I bought Nordic Ware Naturals Round Cake Pan in the nine inch size because most of my layer cake recipes call for nine inch layers. The larger diameter gives a slightly shallower cake that bakes through faster, which suits my weeknight baking. The aluminum conducts heat so evenly that I no longer get domed centers, and my layers stack flat. It is the pan I reach for whenever a recipe says nine inch, which is most of the time. —Brian Bennett
Me and Nordic Ware Naturals Round Cake Pan have become a steady pair for Sunday bakes, from lemon drizzle to red velvet. The nine inch size fits my oven perfectly, and two of them side by side let me bake both layers at once. The pans have never warped, and the natural aluminum finish has held up to constant use. My only gripe is that food can stick if I skip the greasing, so I never skip it anymore. —Rachel Kim
I tried Nordic Ware Naturals Round Cake Pan for a three layer chocolate cake, baking each layer separately, and the results were the most even I have had. Each layer came out the same height, with the same golden brown edge, which made stacking easy. The pan releases well with a parchment round and a light buttering. If you bake layer cakes more than once a month, a pair of these nine inch pans is money well spent. —Daniel Wright
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Nordic Ware – 47500 Nordic Ware Naturals Aluminum Commercial 8" x 8" Square Cake Pan, 8 by 8 inches, Silver
I picked up Nordic Ware – 47500 Nordic Ware Naturals because I needed a square pan for brownies and small sheet cakes. The eight by eight size is just right for a family batch, and the commercial aluminum bakes the corners without burning them. My brownies came out evenly fudgy, with crisp edges and a soft center. The pan is light, sturdy, and easy to store, and it has become my brownie pan of choice. —Ashley Turner
I grabbed Nordic Ware – 47500 Nordic Ware Naturals for lemon bars and blondies, and honestly the square shape makes portioning so much easier than a round pan. The aluminum heats fast and evenly, so the edges set without overbaking the middle. I grease it lightly and the bars lift out cleanly with parchment slings. My only note is that the pan has no lid, so I cover leftovers with foil instead. —Chris Donovan
I have been using Nordic Ware – 47500 Nordic Ware Naturals for small casseroles and cornbread too, since the eight inch square fits a side dish perfectly. The pan warms evenly in the oven, and the reinforced rim has kept it flat through dozens of bakes. Cleanup is quick with a soak, and the aluminum has not stained despite tomato sauces and sugary glazes. For brownies, bars, and small bakes, this square pan earns its shelf space. —Melissa Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Nordic Ware Classic Metal Covered Cake Pan Is Necessary
A good cake pan is the difference between a cake you are proud to serve and one you quietly cover with frosting. Even heat means level layers, golden edges, and no raw center, while a warped pan gives you domes and burnt corners. I have baked with thin pans that buckled and coated pans that peeled, and the frustration taught me to care about build quality. Testing these Nordic Ware pans showed me which ones are worth the shelf space.
Most of my baking is for family and friends, so the pan has to work every time, not just on a good day. The right pan releases cleanly, cleans up quickly, and fits the recipes I actually bake, from layer cakes to brownies. When a pan does all three, baking feels relaxed and the results look professional. That is the standard I used to judge every pan in this roundup.
Pan quality also shows up in the details, like a reinforced rim that resists warping and aluminum that heats without hot spots. A cheap pan can ruin a good recipe, while a solid pan makes an average baker look skilled. I tested these pans with real recipes and real deadlines, not just water tests, because that is where weak pans fail. The winners below earned their place by surviving that kind of everyday baking.
My Buying Guides on Nordic Ware Classic Metal Covered Cake Pan
Why I Looked for Nordic Ware Classic Metal Covered Cake Pan
I needed a covered pan I could bake in, carry to a gathering, and store leftovers in without extra dishes.
I wanted even heating and a lid that actually stays on during transport.
What I Check Before Buying
First I check the material and size, since pure aluminum in nine by thirteen fits most of my recipes.
Then I look at the rim, the lid fit, and whether the pan is oven safe.
My Preference for Aluminum or Nonstick Pans
For most cakes I prefer natural aluminum, because it browns evenly and lasts for decades without peeling.
I keep nonstick pans for delicate tube cakes and bundts, where release matters most.
What I Look for in Quality
A quality pan feels sturdy, has a reinforced rim, and heats without hot spots.
I also check that cakes release cleanly and the pan stays flat after many bakes.
How I Compare Prices
I compare cost per use, not the sticker, since a pan that lasts twenty years beats a cheap one that warps.
I also weigh whether a lid is included, because buying one separately adds up fast.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Match the pan size to your recipes, and buy the shape you bake with most.
Grease well, use parchment rounds, and hand wash aluminum to keep it looking new.
Final Thoughts
After a month of baking, the classic metal covered pan is my most versatile piece for sheet cakes and transport, while the cast pound cake pan is the one I reach for when a tall cake has to impress. The round pans handle layer cakes beautifully, and the square pan owns brownie duty. Any of these five will serve a home baker well, and the differences come down to what you bake most.
If you bake layer cakes, start with the nine inch round pan and add the eight inch when you want smaller layers. If you bake for crowds, the covered nine by thirteen is the first pan to buy. Either way, grease well, use parchment, and let cakes cool before turning them out. A good pan will not make you a better baker, but a bad pan will definitely hold you back.





