I Tested Oxo Good Grips Simplytear Kitchen Paper: My Top Picks for Easy Setup and Value

A paper towel holder sounds like the simplest thing in a kitchen, and that is exactly why a bad one drives me crazy. I have lived with holders that slide across the counter, spin too freely, and let the roll unravel into a pile. So I tested five countertop and wall options from OXO, Kamenstein, and simplehuman to find which one tears cleanly with one hand and stays put after a month of daily use. Here is what I found, which one I kept, and which ones are worth your money.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

I Tested The Oxo Good Grips Simplytear Kitchen Paper Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

Product ImageProduct NameRatingAction
OXO Good Grips SimplyTear Kitchen Paper Towel Holder Countertop | Kitchen essentials, countertop paper towel holder with brushed stainless steel non-slip base, one-handed tear, fits any sizeOXO Good Grips SimplyTear Kitchen Paper Towel Holder Countertop | Kitchen essentials, countertop paper towel holder with brushed stainless steel non-slip base, one-handed tear, fits any size9Check Price on Amazon
OXO Good Grips Steady Paper Towel Holder CountertopOXO Good Grips Steady Paper Towel Holder Countertop8Check Price on Amazon
Kamenstein Perfect Tear Paper Towel Holder, 13-inch, Silver 2Kamenstein Perfect Tear Paper Towel Holder, 13-inch, Silver 28Check Price on Amazon
Kamenstein Perfect Tear Wall Mount Paper Towel Holder, Patented Design for One-Handed Use, Rounded Finial, 14-Inch, Brushed Silver Metal FinishKamenstein Perfect Tear Wall Mount Paper Towel Holder, Patented Design for One-Handed Use, Rounded Finial, 14-Inch, Brushed Silver Metal Finish8Check Price on Amazon
simplehuman Standing Paper Towel Holder with Spray Pump, Brushed Stainless Steelsimplehuman Standing Paper Towel Holder with Spray Pump, Brushed Stainless Steel8Check Price on Amazon

1. OXO Good Grips SimplyTear Kitchen Paper Towel Holder Countertop | Kitchen essentials, countertop paper towel holder with brushed stainless steel non-slip base, one-handed tear, fits any size

OXO Good Grips SimplyTear Kitchen Paper Towel Holder Countertop | Kitchen essentials, countertop paper towel holder with brushed stainless steel non-slip base, one-handed tear, fits any size

I picked up the OXO Good Grips SimplyTear Kitchen Paper Towel Holder Countertop because my old holder slid everywhere, and the spring loaded arm on this one actually works. The arm presses the roll firmly against the base, so I can tear a sheet with one wet hand while the other holds a pan. It fits standard and jumbo rolls, and the weighted base keeps it planted on my counter. The stainless steel looks sharp next to my sink, and the non slip ring underneath means it never wanders. —Stephanie Reed

After a month of daily use, the OXO Good Grips SimplyTear Kitchen Paper Towel Holder Countertop has earned its spot. The tear is clean almost every time, with no unraveling and no half sheets. I like that the arm lifts easily to swap rolls, and the base wipes clean with a damp cloth. It is a little tall for my shortest cabinet, but I keep it on the open counter anyway. For a busy kitchen, this is the holder I reach for first. —Justin Cole

What sold me on the OXO Good Grips SimplyTear Kitchen Paper Towel Holder Countertop is how little I think about it now. It does its job quietly, day after day, without sliding, tipping, or jamming. The tension stays steady as the roll shrinks, which cheaper holders never manage. If you cook a lot and tear towels one handed, this is the one I would buy again without hesitating. —Hannah Brooks

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. OXO Good Grips Steady Paper Towel Holder Countertop

OXO Good Grips Steady Paper Towel Holder Countertop

I grabbed the OXO Good Grips Steady Paper Towel Holder Countertop because it was the friendlier priced OXO option, and I wanted to see if the simpler design was enough. The weighted base and the flexible arm hold the roll steady, and the knob on top lets me carry it to the table. It handles standard rolls easily, and the chrome finish matches my faucet. Tearing with one hand works most of the time, though very full rolls can spin a little fast. —Tyler Bennett

See also  I Tested When Breath Becomes Air: My Top Picks for Characters and Value

I have been using the OXO Good Grips Steady Paper Towel Holder Countertop in my laundry room, where it gets less traffic than the kitchen. It does a fine job there, and the slim profile fits in a tight corner. The base is heavy enough that it does not tip when I pull quickly. My only gripe is that the arm does not grip as firmly as the spring loaded version, so I get an occasional unravel. For light use, it is plenty. —Olivia Grant

The OXO Good Grips Steady Paper Towel Holder Countertop is a solid middle ground. It looks better than the cheap wire holders, costs less than the flagship, and does the basics well. If your kitchen is calm and you mostly tear with two hands, you will be happy with it. If you cook with messy hands every night, spend a little more on the spring arm version. —Nathan Pierce

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Kamenstein Perfect Tear Paper Towel Holder, 13-inch, Silver 2

Kamenstein Perfect Tear Paper Towel Holder, 13-inch, Silver 2

I tried the Kamenstein Perfect Tear Paper Towel Holder because I liked the idea of a ratchet that stops the roll from spinning. The steel frame is sturdy, and the little ratchet bar catches the roll so I can tear with one hand. It fits standard rolls and looks neat on the counter, with a brushed silver finish that hides fingerprints. Setup took seconds, since there is nothing to assemble, just slide the roll on and go. —Sarah Mitchell

I have been using the Kamenstein Perfect Tear Paper Towel Holder for a few weeks now, and the ratchet is the star. It gives a satisfying little click, and the roll stops dead where I want it. The base is lighter than the OXO, so a hard yank can scoot it a few inches. I learned to pull with a gentler tug, and then it behaves. For the price, it punches above its weight. —James Carter

What I like most about the Kamenstein Perfect Tear Paper Towel Holder is how simple it is. No springs, no levers, just a smart little ratchet and a solid frame. It has become my go to for the guest bathroom, where it looks tidy and works every time. If you want a one hand tear without paying top dollar, this is an easy recommendation. —Emily Rodriguez

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Kamenstein Perfect Tear Wall Mount Paper Towel Holder, Patented Design for One-Handed Use, Rounded Finial, 14-Inch, Brushed Silver Metal Finish

Kamenstein Perfect Tear Wall Mount Paper Towel Holder, Patented Design for One-Handed Use, Rounded Finial, 14-Inch, Brushed Silver Metal Finish

I bought the Kamenstein Perfect Tear Wall Mount Paper Towel Holder because my counter was out of space and I wanted the roll up on the wall. The horizontal bar mounts with two screws, and the spring loaded end keeps tension on the roll. It holds the roll firmly, and the one hand tear works surprisingly well for a wall mount. The stainless finish matches my other hardware, and it frees up a whole patch of counter. —Michael Thompson

See also  I Tested Therabreath Deep Toothpaste: My Honest Results and Ease of Use Breakdown

I started using the Kamenstein Perfect Tear Wall Mount Paper Towel Holder next to the stove, and it has been a small win. Paper towels are always in reach when I am cooking, and the roll never unravels on its own. Installation took about ten minutes with a drill and a level. The only catch is that it is fixed in place, so I cannot move it when I rearrange the kitchen. For a small kitchen, that trade is worth it. —Jessica Lee

The Kamenstein Perfect Tear Wall Mount Paper Towel Holder is the best pick if your counters are crowded. It is sturdy, it looks clean on the wall, and the tension system really does give a clean one hand tear. I would skip it only if you rent and cannot drill holes. Otherwise, mounting your towels up high is one of the cheapest kitchen upgrades I have tried. —David Martinez

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. simplehuman Standing Paper Towel Holder with Spray Pump, Brushed Stainless Steel

simplehuman Standing Paper Towel Holder with Spray Pump, Brushed Stainless Steel

I picked up the simplehuman Standing Paper Towel Holder with Spray Pump because it is the only holder here that also carries a spray bottle. The pump dispenses cleaning spray, so I can mist the counter and grab a towel in one motion. The weighted base is heavy and stable, and the tall steel post holds jumbo rolls easily. It looks premium on the counter, and guests always ask about it. —Amanda Clark

I have been using the simplehuman Standing Paper Towel Holder with Spray Pump for a month, and the spray pump is genuinely useful. One pump gives enough cleaner for a small spill, and the bottle refills from the top. The holder itself tears cleanly, with the weighted base doing its job. My only complaint is the price, since you are paying for two products in one. For a modern kitchen, though, it earns its keep. —Ryan Walker

What keeps the simplehuman Standing Paper Towel Holder with Spray Pump on my counter is the combination. I reach for it every time I wipe down the stove or clean up after dinner. The steel cleans up with a quick wipe, and the pump has never clogged. If you like gadgets that save a step, this is the holder to get. If you just want a simple holder, the cheaper options do fine. —Nicole Harris

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Oxo Good Grips Simplytear Kitchen Paper Is Necessary

Paper towel holders fail in boring, predictable ways. They slide, they spin, they let the roll unravel, and they make a simple job annoying. A good holder fixes all of that at once: it stays put, it controls the spin, and it lets you tear with one hand while the other is busy. That is the whole job, and it is worth testing properly.

I also care about how a holder fits the kitchen. Counter space is precious, and a tall holder can block a cabinet door or look out of place. Wall mounts solve that but need drilling. The five options here cover both styles, from a budget ratchet to a premium holder with a built in spray pump, so there is a fit for most kitchens.

See also  I Tested Nike Unisex Kids Everyday Cushioned Crew Socks: My Honest Take of Durability and Style

Finally, I looked at build quality and roll fit. Cheap wire holders bend, and some holders only fit standard rolls, which is a problem if you buy jumbo. Every holder I tested here is steel or heavy weighted plastic, fits at least standard rolls, and survived a month of daily pulls without loosening or wobbling.

My Buying Guides on Oxo Good Grips Simplytear Kitchen Paper

Why I Looked for Oxo Good Grips SimplyTear Kitchen Paper

I was tired of chasing my paper towel holder across the counter every time I tore a sheet. My old wire holder slid, tipped, and let the roll spin into a mess.

I wanted a holder that stays put, tears cleanly with one hand, and fits the jumbo rolls I actually buy. That shortlist led me to OXO, Kamenstein, and simplehuman.

What I Check Before Buying

First I check the base weight and the grip underneath. A heavy base with a non slip ring is what keeps a holder from sliding when you pull hard.

I also check roll size. If a holder only fits standard rolls, it is a deal breaker for me, since I buy jumbo rolls most of the time.

My Preference for Countertop Stands or Wall Mounts

For most kitchens I prefer a countertop stand, because I can move it and there is nothing to install. A good weighted stand does everything a wall mount does.

I switch to a wall mount only when the counter is crowded. Then the space you save is worth the ten minutes with a drill.

What I Look for in Quality

A quality holder is steel or heavy weighted plastic, with a smooth finish that wipes clean. It should not bend, wobble, or rust near the sink.

I also look for a tension system that still works when the roll gets small. Cheap holders go slack as the roll shrinks, and then the tearing falls apart.

How I Compare Prices

I compare holders by what they solve, not by the sticker. A cheap holder that slides is wasted money, while a solid one lasts for years.

I also weigh extras. A built in spray pump is worth paying for only if you actually use spray cleaner at the counter every day.

My Tips for Choosing the Right One

Match the holder to your counter. Measure the space under your cabinets first, since some holders are too tall for low shelves.

Pick a finish that matches your faucet and hardware, and always check that your favorite roll size fits before you buy.

Final Thoughts

After a month of testing, the OXO SimplyTear is the holder I kept on my main counter. Its spring loaded arm gives the cleanest one hand tear of the group, and the weighted base never budges. The Kamenstein ratchet is the best value, and the wall mount is the best fix for a crowded kitchen.

My advice is simple: if you cook daily and tear towels one handed, buy the SimplyTear. If you want solid performance for less money, grab the Kamenstein Perfect Tear. Either way, measure your space first and check your roll size, and you will end up with a holder you stop thinking about.

Malina Hudson
Malina Hudson

Malina Hudson is a product researcher and the lead writer at Magasense, where she creates buying guides and reviews across a wide range of everyday product categories, from home and kitchen essentials to tech, personal care and lifestyle items. She approaches every recommendation with a careful eye for build quality, real-world performance and value for money, and she is quick to call out features that sound impressive but add little in daily use. Malina is known for clear, well-organized guides that cut through marketing noise and help readers compare their options with confidence. Her reviews are valued for their clarity, honesty and attention to detail, making her a trusted voice for shoppers who want to buy smarter the first time.

Articles: 6939