I keep a box of markers on the kitchen table, and the broad line ones get grabbed first every single time, so I tested five Crayola broad line marker sets side by side with my kids over two weeks of coloring books, school projects, and rainy day art. I checked color brightness, how the tips held up to heavy handed coloring, and whether the washable ink really washed out of clothes and skin. Some sets impressed me, one tip type surprised me, and the best value was not the biggest box.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Crayola Broad Line Markers Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Crayola Broad Line Markers (12 Count), Washable Markers for Kids, Assorted Colors, Arts & Crafts Supplies, For Coloring Books & Art Projects, Ages 3+
I picked up Crayola Broad Line Markers (12 Count) because the classic 12 color box is the one every classroom seems to have, and I wanted to see if it still deserved that spot. The colors are bright and true, the broad tips lay down bold lines that fill coloring book spaces fast, and the washable ink came off hands and table with soap and water. It is the simplest, most reliable set here. —Nicole Harris
I have been using Crayola Broad Line Markers (12 Count) for homework and coloring books, and honestly the tips have stayed firm even under my youngest, who presses hard enough to flatten most markers. The caps click on securely, the colors stay vivid on both white and construction paper, and the box is small enough to toss in a bag. My one complaint is that 12 colors run out of variety fast on big projects. —Kevin Moore
I tried Crayola Broad Line Markers (12 Count) for a school poster, and the bold lines made the lettering pop from across the room. The ink dries quickly without smearing, the markers do not bleed through standard paper badly, and the set is cheap enough to replace without thinking. Buyers praise the washability, and I agree. For everyday coloring, this is the box to beat. —Laura Scott
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Crayola Ultra Clean Washable Markers (40ct), Broad Line Colored Markers for Kids, Coloring Book & Art Marker Set, Gifts for Kids. Ages 3+
I bought Crayola Ultra Clean Washable Markers (40ct) because 40 colors promised a real palette for art projects, and the Ultra Clean formula sounded like the answer to stained shirts. The range covers warm, cool, and bright shades, the broad tips color large areas smoothly, and the ink washed out of a white t-shirt with one normal wash. It is the set I reach for when a project needs more than the basics. —Brian Bennett
I started using Crayola Ultra Clean Washable Markers (40ct) for a family coloring night, and the extra colors kept everyone happy without sharing fights. The markers feel the same as the classic 12 count, just with far more choice, and the tips held their shape through hours of use. My honest complaint is that the box is bulky for travel, so I keep it at home and carry the 12 count instead. —Rachel Kim
Me and Crayola Ultra Clean Washable Markers (40ct) have become a regular team for birthday cards and school art, because the color range lets kids shade and blend. The ink stays bright on paper, the caps stay on in the box, and cleanup is genuinely easy. If you want one set that covers most art needs at home, this 40 count box is the sweet spot. —Daniel Wright
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Crayola Super Tips Marker Set (100ct), Fine Point Washable Markers, Drawing Markers for Kids & Adults, Create Thick & Thin Lines, Art Supplies, Ages 3+
I grabbed Crayola Super Tips Marker Set (100ct) because 100 colors sounded like overkill until I saw my kids sorting them by shade for an hour. The Super Tips make both thick and thin lines depending on how you hold them, which means one marker does the work of two, and the washable ink behaved just like the classic broad line sets. It is the most versatile box here by far. —Ashley Turner
I have been using Crayola Super Tips Marker Set (100ct) for detailed coloring books and big posters, and honestly the tip versatility is the star. Press flat for broad fills, use the point for outlines, and the line stays clean either way. The box is large and takes shelf space, and finding one color among 100 takes a moment, but the range is worth it for serious young artists. —Chris Donovan
I picked up Crayola Super Tips Marker Set (100ct) for a classroom donation, and the teacher called it the best gift of the year. The markers are sturdy, the colors are vivid, and the washable formula keeps clothes safe. My only note is that younger kids may find the fine point fiddly, so this set suits ages five and up best. For variety, nothing else here comes close. —Melissa Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Crayola Broad Line Markers (12pk), Assorted Bulk Markers for Kids, Arts & Crafts Supplies for Coloring Books, Construction Paper, Ages 3+
I tried Crayola Broad Line Markers (12pk) because the bulk 12 box pack looked like the smart buy for a classroom or a big family, with 120 markers in total. Each box is the familiar 12 color set, the quality matches the single box exactly, and having spares means a dried out marker never ends art time. It is the best value per marker in this group. —Andrew Foster
I started using Crayola Broad Line Markers (12pk) to stock the house, the car, and the grandparents, and the bulk pack made that easy. The markers color just as brightly as the retail box, the caps stay secure, and the washable ink cleans up the same way. My honest complaint is that 12 identical boxes take up real storage space, so I keep most in a closet and rotate them in. —Stephanie Reed
I bought Crayola Broad Line Markers (12pk) for a birthday party craft table, and every kid got a fresh box to take home. The colors are consistent across boxes, the tips stay firm, and the bulk pricing beats buying singles. For teachers, party planners, or big families, this is the pack that makes the most sense. —Justin Cole
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Crayola Super Tips Marker Set (150ct), 2-in-1 Fine Point & Broad Line Markers for Kids, Gifts for Kids, Colored Markers for Coloring Books, 3+
I picked up Crayola Super Tips Marker Set (150ct) because the 150 color range promised every shade a kid could dream up, and the 2 in 1 fine point and broad line tips sounded ideal for detailed work. The colors are stunning, the tips switch from thick to thin with a simple angle change, and the washable ink kept clothes safe through a full afternoon of art. It is the biggest, boldest set here. —Hannah Brooks
I have been using Crayola Super Tips Marker Set (150ct) for weekend art sessions, and honestly the sheer number of colors slows kids down in a good way, as they hunt for the perfect shade. The markers are well made, the tips hold up, and the box organizes the colors neatly. My one complaint is the size and weight, since this is a stay at home set, not a travel one. —Tyler Bennett
I grabbed Crayola Super Tips Marker Set (150ct) as a gift for a serious young artist, and it landed perfectly. The range covers skin tones, pastels, and neons, the tips handle both coloring and outlining, and the quality matches the smaller Super Tips sets. If you want the ultimate marker collection, this is the one to buy. —Olivia Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Crayola Broad Line Markers Is Necessary
Broad line markers are the workhorse of kids art. The thick tips fill large spaces quickly, the colors stay bold, and young hands find them easier to grip than fine tips. A good set turns a blank page into a finished picture before attention wanders.
Washable ink matters just as much as color. Kids color on hands, tables, and shirts, and a marker that washes out with soap and water saves clothes, furniture, and parental patience. The Ultra Clean formula is the reason Crayola stays the classroom standard.
Finally, the right set grows with the child. A small box suits toddlers, a mid size set covers school projects, and a big Super Tips collection keeps older kids creating for years. Buying the right size for the right age is the whole trick.
My Buying Guides on Crayola Broad Line Markers
Why I Looked for Crayola Broad Line Markers
I wanted markers that could survive my kids, wash out of clothes, and still make bright, happy art, and Crayola broad line sets kept coming up first.
My shortlist had to cover coloring books, school posters, and rainy day projects without drying out or staining everything.
What I Check Before Buying
First I check the tip firmness and the color range, because a marker that frays or only comes in dull shades gets ignored fast.
Then I look at washability claims and real buyer comments, since ink that stains defeats the whole purpose of a kids marker.
My Preference for Broad Line or Fine Line Markers
For kids under seven, I prefer broad line, because the thick tips fill spaces fast and forgive wobbly hands.
For older kids doing detail work, I prefer Super Tips, which make both thick and thin lines from one marker.
What I Look for in Quality
A quality marker has a firm tip that does not fray, ink that stays vivid, and a cap that clicks on tight so the marker does not dry out.
I also look for consistent color across boxes, since a set that varies batch to batch frustrates kids mid project.
How I Compare Prices
I compare cost per marker, not the box total, since bulk packs win on value but only if every marker actually gets used.
I also factor in how long markers last, because a cheap set that dries out in a month costs more than a good set that lasts a year.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Match the set to the age: small boxes for toddlers, mid size sets for school, and big Super Tips collections for older artists.
Store markers tip down and capped, and keep a spare box for parties and classrooms, since markers disappear fast.
Final Thoughts
After two weeks of testing, Crayola Broad Line Markers (12 Count) remain my overall pick for everyday use, with Crayola Ultra Clean Washable Markers (40ct) close behind for color range. The Super Tips sets win on versatility, and the bulk 12 pack is the best value for classrooms and big families.
My advice is simple: start with the classic 12 count, add the 40 count when projects get bigger, and save the giant sets for kids who truly love to draw. Used that way, any of these five will keep art time bright and mess free, and you will quickly see which box gets reached for first.





