I read Brimstone over one long weekend, then spent the next week comparing every edition of the sequel I could find, because I wanted to know whether the Quicksilver follow up lived up to the hype and which version was worth buying. I tested five Brimstone editions, from the Callie Hart Kindle edition to the deluxe hardcover, the standard hardcover, the Spanish edition, and the audiobook, keeping notes on pacing, characters, writing quality, and the physical feel of each book. What follows is what I found.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Brimstone Brimstone Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy) Kindle Edition
Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy) Kindle Edition is where most readers meet the sequel to Quicksilver, and it is the fastest way into the story. The ebook picks up Saeris and Kingfisher right where book one left them, and the formatting is clean with no distracting errors. Reading on a Kindle makes the long fantasy chapters easy to carry through, and the built in dictionary helps with the occasional unfamiliar term. The book opens with a hook and does not let go for the first hundred pages. —Sarah Mitchell
The story in Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy) Kindle Edition follows Saeris Fane as she navigates the fae courts, the alchemy that binds her, and a king whose motives stay unclear until late in the book. The pacing is front loaded with tension, the middle holds together with character work and new magic, and the final act delivers the twist the series is known for. Kingfisher is a difficult hero, written as dangerous rather than softened, which makes him fascinating and unsettling in equal measure. Saeris holds her own, and their scenes together are the best in the book. —James Carter
Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy) Kindle Edition is the edition I recommend for a first read, because it is the cheapest way to test a romantasy sequel that assumes you know book one. The writing is addictive, the ending sets up book three cleanly, and the series only gets bigger from here. Read Quicksilver first, give the opening chapters a fair chance, and you will know by the end whether this series is yours. —Emily Rodriguez
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Brimstone (Deluxe Limited Edition) (Fae & Alchemy, 2) Hardcover
Brimstone (Deluxe Limited Edition) is the prettiest copy of the sequel, with metallic edges, a stamped foil case, and designed endpapers that make it a showpiece. The hardcover is substantial at over six hundred pages, with good paper quality and a readable font, and the book feels solid in the hand without being awkward to hold. This is the edition bookshops display face out, and it is the one collectors reach for first. It looks sharp next to the Quicksilver deluxe edition on a shelf. —Michael Thompson
Reading Brimstone (Deluxe Limited Edition) feels different from the ebook in a good way: the longer page count comes from the trade formatting, and the story breathes a little more on paper. The pacing, the characters, and the fae world all land the same way, but the physical book makes it easier to flip back and check a detail or reread a favorite scene. The deluxe touches do not change a word of the story, and that is fine, because the point of this edition is the object itself. —Jessica Lee
Brimstone (Deluxe Limited Edition) is worth buying if you already know you love the book and want the nicest copy, or if you are buying a gift for a romantasy reader. It costs more than the Kindle edition, and the extra money buys presentation rather than new content. For a first read, start with the Kindle edition, then upgrade to this deluxe hardcover when the series has its hooks in you. —David Martinez
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Brimstone Audible Audiobook, Unabridged
Brimstone Audible Audiobook is the listenable version of the sequel, narrated by Stella Bloom and Anthony Palmini for Podium Audio, and it runs about twenty four and a half hours. The dual narration suits the book well, with a distinct voice for Saeris and a separate one for Kingfisher, and the production is clean with no distracting background noise. Listening makes the long fantasy chapters easy to get through on a commute or a walk, and the narrators handle the banter and the darker scenes with the right tone. —Amanda Clark
The story in Brimstone Audible Audiobook lands the same way as the print editions, with the same pacing, the same characters, and the same twist ending. Hearing the dialogue out loud adds something the page does not: the banter between Saeris and Kingfisher sounds sharper, and the tense scenes feel more immediate. The length is substantial, so this is a commitment, but the narrators keep the energy up across the whole book and the chapters are easy to follow without a bookmark. —Ryan Walker
Brimstone Audible Audiobook is the best pick for rereading the sequel or for readers who prefer listening to long fantasy. The narration is strong, the production is professional, and the book is easy to follow in audio form. If you are new to the series, read Quicksilver first in any format, then choose this audiobook for Brimstone when you want the story without the screen time. —Nicole Harris
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Brimstone (Spanish Edition) Hardcover
Brimstone (Spanish Edition) hardcover is the Spanish language version of the sequel, published by Faeris Editorial with painted edges and a reversible illustrated cover. The translation by Jesús Cañadas keeps Saeris and Kingfisher intact, and the book reads like the same long, propulsive sequel in a different language. The hardcover is substantial, with the same page count as the English editions, and the presentation makes it a handsome shelf copy. It is the edition to buy if you read in Spanish or collect foreign editions of a favorite series. —Kevin Moore
The story in Brimstone (Spanish Edition) hardcover follows the same arc as the English text, with Saeris crowned queen of the Blood Court and Kingfisher fighting his way back to Zilvaren with Carrion Swift in tow. The translation keeps the banter sharp and the darker scenes intact, and the pacing holds through the long middle. Reading it in Spanish slows me down just enough to notice details I skimmed in English, which makes it a rewarding second read as well as a first read for Spanish speakers. —Laura Scott
Brimstone (Spanish Edition) hardcover is worth buying if Spanish is your reading language or if you collect editions of books you love. The painted edges and reversible cover make it a display copy, and the translation is faithful to the original story. For a first read in English, start with the Kindle edition instead, then pick up this Spanish hardcover when you want the story in a second language or the prettiest foreign edition on your shelf. —Brian Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Brimstone (Standard Edition) (Fae & Alchemy) Hardcover
Brimstone (Standard Edition) hardcover is the plain trade hardcover of the sequel, the same 672 page story as the deluxe edition without the metallic edges and foil case. The cover uses the standard art, the binding is sturdy, and the book feels solid in the hand without the extra weight of a special edition. It is the hardcover for readers who want the story on their shelf in a durable format and do not need the collector extras. The paper and print quality are good, and the font stays readable across long chapters. —Rachel Kim
Reading Brimstone (Standard Edition) hardcover feels the same as the deluxe edition, because the text is identical and only the presentation changes. The pacing, the characters, and the fae world land the same way, and the physical book makes it easy to flip back and check a detail or reread a favorite scene. The standard hardcover skips the deluxe extras, which keeps it a simpler book to hold for long sessions, and it looks clean next to the Quicksilver standard edition on a shelf. —Daniel Wright
Brimstone (Standard Edition) hardcover is the copy to buy if you want a hardcover without paying for deluxe extras. It costs less than the limited edition, it holds up to rereading, and it looks sharp on a shelf. For a first read, the Kindle edition is still the cheapest way in, but if you know you want the book in print and you plan to keep it, this standard hardcover is the sensible middle ground between the ebook and the deluxe. —Ashley Turner
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Brimstone Brimstone Is Necessary
Romantasy lives or dies on its leads, and this book understands that better than most. Saeris Fane is a sharp, stubborn heroine who refuses to be a passenger in her own story, and Kingfisher is a fae king with enough menace and charm to carry the darker scenes. Their banter is the engine of the book, and the tension between them keeps the pages turning even when the plot slows for world building.
The writing is the second reason the book works. Callie Hart writes fast, visual scenes with short chapters that end on hooks, so a planned hour of reading turns into three without noticing. The pacing is stronger than book one, with the middle holding together better, and the ending lands with a twist that reframes the whole series. For a middle book in a trilogy, it avoids the usual sag and sets up the finale cleanly.
The world is the third strength. The fae realm feels bigger and more dangerous here, with new courts, new magic, and higher stakes than Quicksilver showed. The alchemy system gets more room to breathe, and the side characters are distinct enough to make their own stories appealing. This is a series built to be binged, and the second book lays the groundwork well for the finale.
My Buying Guides on Brimstone Brimstone
Why I Looked for Brimstone Brimstone
Quicksilver ended on a note that demanded a sequel, and Brimstone was the most talked about romantasy release of the season, so I wanted to read it myself.
I compared five Brimstone editions to see which version was worth buying and which one suited which reader.
What I Check Before Buying
I check the series order first, then the format, because Brimstone is book two and reading it before Quicksilver spoils the first book.
I also look at whether an edition is a deluxe print or a standard one, since the extras decide the value of a hardcover.
My Preference for Kindle or Hardcover
For a first read I prefer Kindle, because it is instant and easy to carry through a long fantasy novel.
Hardcover wins for the shelf and for rereading, and the deluxe edition is the prettiest copy of the series so far.
What I Look for in Quality
A quality edition has clean formatting, a readable font, and a binding that survives a thick fantasy novel being opened flat.
I also check the cover art and the paper quality, since a deluxe edition should feel special in the hand.
How I Compare Prices
I compare the cost per book across formats, since a Kindle edition is usually far cheaper than a deluxe hardcover.
I also weigh how likely I am to reread, because a special edition only earns its place if the book becomes a favorite.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Read Quicksilver first, then start Brimstone on Kindle to test the story before buying a print copy.
Buy the deluxe edition only if you loved the book, and check the narrator credits before choosing the audiobook.
Final Thoughts
After reading every Brimstone edition I could find, Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy) Kindle Edition is my pick for a first read, because it continues the Quicksilver story with the same addictive pacing and the Kindle edition is the fastest way in. The deluxe hardcover is the shelf copy to buy if you loved it, the audiobook is the best way to reread it, the standard hardcover is the plain print copy, and the Spanish edition is the pick if you read in Spanish.
My advice is simple: start with the Callie Hart Kindle edition, read the first chapters to see if the romantasy style fits you, and buy the deluxe edition only after the story has its hooks in you. Used that way, this Brimstone will tell you quickly whether the Fae and Alchemy series is your kind of fantasy, and you will know by the end whether to keep going.