I have played Mario games since I was a kid, so when I sat down with Mario Odyssey on my Switch I came in with high hopes and a notebook full of things to check. I played through the opening kingdoms, chased moons in handheld mode and on the TV, and compared the physical copy, the digital code, a renewed copy, a controller bundle, and the red Joy-Con console bundle. Some versions felt like the smart buy and others felt like paying extra for the same adventure. This is what I found after hours of jumping, capturing, and exploring.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Mario Odyssey Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Super Mario Odyssey – US Version
I picked up Super Mario Odyssey – US Version because I wanted the real cartridge in my hands instead of a download tied to an account. The first kingdom pulled me in fast, with Cappy letting me possess a frog, a taxi, and even a T-Rex within the first hour. The controls felt tight in handheld mode, the colors popped on my TV, and the moons were tucked into clever corners that rewarded poking around. Loading times were short, and I never once felt stuck waiting on the game to catch up with me. —Olivia Grant
I've been using Super Mario Odyssey – US Version for weeks now, and honestly the capture mechanic is what keeps me coming back. Throwing Cappy at a Goomba stack or a Bullet Bill turns every level into a small puzzle, and the game never punishes you hard for missing a jump. My one complaint is that the main story runs short if you rush it, and a few late kingdoms reuse ideas I had already seen. Still, the post-game moons and the darker side of the moon gave me plenty to chase after the credits rolled. —Nathan Pierce
I tried Super Mario Odyssey – US Version in two-player mode with my nephew, and handing him Cappy while I steered Mario worked better than I expected. He could float around, grab coins, and help in boss fights without ever feeling lost. The cartridge itself has held up well after months in and out of the case, and the box art looks great on the shelf next to my other Switch games. If you like open 3D platformers with surprises around every corner, this version is the one I would hand to a friend first. —Sarah Mitchell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Super Mario Odyssey – Nintendo Switch [Digital Code]
![Super Mario Odyssey - Nintendo Switch [Digital Code]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/819JzRWDRuL.jpg)
I grabbed Super Mario Odyssey – Nintendo Switch [Digital Code] because I was tired of swapping cartridges every time I switched games. The download finished while I made dinner, and the game was ready on my home screen with no case to lose. It plays exactly like the cartridge version, with the same kingdoms, moons, and capture moves, and I never noticed a difference in loading or performance. The only downside is that I cannot lend it to a friend or resell it later, which stings a little. —James Carter
I started using Super Mario Odyssey – Nintendo Switch [Digital Code] on my Switch Lite during commutes, and having the game always installed made short sessions easy. I could grab three moons on a train ride and put the console to sleep without worrying about a cartridge rattling around in my bag. The digital version also let me redownload it after I reset my console, which saved me a trip to the store. My honest complaint is that storage fills up fast, so I had to archive another game to make room. —Emily Rodriguez
Me and Super Mario Odyssey – Nintendo Switch [Digital Code] have become my go-to for quick play sessions, because there is no cartridge to hunt for. The capture mechanic still surprises me, from becoming a taxi in New Donk City to possessing a Chain Chomp, and the game rewards curiosity at every turn. One thing I noticed is that the download code cannot be shared across accounts on the same console the way a cartridge can. Even so, for pure convenience, this is the version I reach for most days. —Michael Thompson
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Super Mario Odyssey – Nintendo Switch (Renewed)
I bought Super Mario Odyssey – Nintendo Switch (Renewed) because I wanted the full game for less, and the listing promised a tested cartridge. The game arrived in a plain case with a clean cartridge, and it booted up on the first try with no errors. I played through the Cap Kingdom and the Sand Kingdom without a single freeze or glitch, and the save file worked exactly as expected. The box was not the original art, which was a small letdown, but the game itself ran perfectly from the start. —Jessica Lee
I've been using Super Mario Odyssey – Nintendo Switch (Renewed) for a month now, and honestly I cannot tell it apart from a new copy in actual play. The moons, the costumes, and the capture moves all work the same, and my progress has saved without a hiccup. My one worry was the cartridge condition, so I checked the contacts and the label closely when it arrived, and both looked clean. For anyone on a tight budget, this renewed copy delivers the same adventure, and the savings are real. —David Martinez
I tried Super Mario Odyssey – Nintendo Switch (Renewed) side by side with my friend's new copy, and we could not find a single difference in gameplay. The kingdoms loaded at the same speed, the controls felt identical, and the multiplayer assist mode worked just as well. The only real difference was the packaging, which was plain and generic instead of the glossy retail box. If the box does not matter to you, this is an easy way to play one of the best Switch games without paying full price. —Amanda Clark
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Super Mario Odyssey [Digital Code] + PowerA Enhanced Wireless Mario Mayhem Controller Bundle for Nintendo Switch /Switch 2 /Switch Lite /OLED Model
![Super Mario Odyssey [Digital Code] + PowerA Enhanced Wireless Mario Mayhem Controller Bundle for Nintendo Switch /Switch 2 /Switch Lite /OLED Model](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/41BMlJydyoL.jpg)
I picked up Super Mario Odyssey [Digital Code] + PowerA Enhanced because I needed a second controller and the game in one box. The PowerA controller paired quickly, felt comfortable in my hands during long sessions, and the Mario Mayhem design looks great next to the console. The digital code redeemed without a fuss, and I was playing within minutes. My only gripe is that the controller uses batteries instead of a rechargeable pack, so I keep spares in the drawer now. —Ryan Walker
I grabbed Super Mario Odyssey [Digital Code] + PowerA Enhanced for family game nights, and the extra controller changed everything. My daughter steers Cappy while I control Mario, and the wireless range reaches across the living room without dropping. The buttons feel solid, the sticks are smooth, and the controller has survived several drops onto the rug already. The bundle costs more than the game alone, so it only makes sense if you actually need a spare controller too. —Nicole Harris
Me and Super Mario Odyssey [Digital Code] + PowerA Enhanced have become my weekend setup, because the game is always ready and the controller is always charged with fresh batteries. The capture moves feel precise on this controller, and I cleared a tricky moon challenge that had beaten me with the Joy-Con grip. One small annoyance is that the controller has no HD rumble, so some moments feel less alive. Even with that, the bundle is a solid deal for anyone starting out. —Kevin Moore
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Nintendo Switch 32GB Super Mario Odyssey Edition Bundle – Red Joy-Con
I bought Nintendo Switch 32GB Super Mario Odyssey Edition Bundle because I wanted the red Joy-Con console and the game together from day one. The red controllers look sharp against the black console, and the included carrying case and screen protector meant I could take it out of the box and play right away. Setup took minutes, the download code worked on the first try, and the console has run cool and quiet ever since. It is the most eye-catching Switch I have owned. —Laura Scott
I've been using Nintendo Switch 32GB Super Mario Odyssey Edition Bundle for over a year now, and honestly the console still feels like new. The red Joy-Con controllers have no drift, the battery still lasts through long handheld sessions, and the dock connects to the TV without a hiccup. My one complaint is the 32GB of storage, which filled up fast once I added a few more digital games. A memory card fixed that, but it is an extra purchase you should plan for. —Brian Bennett
I tried Nintendo Switch 32GB Super Mario Odyssey Edition Bundle as a gift for my nephew, and the red theme made it feel special the moment he opened it. The game download kept him busy for weeks, and the case protected the console on car trips. The stickers were a fun extra, though they ended up on his notebook instead of the console. If you want a Switch that stands out and comes with a great game, this bundle is the one I would pick. —Rachel Kim
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Mario Odyssey Is Necessary
Mario Odyssey matters to me because it is the rare game that my whole family can enjoy together, from my nephew who just likes throwing the hat to my brother who hunts every last moon. It rewards curiosity instead of punishing mistakes, which makes it easy to pick up after a long day. Few Switch games offer this much charm in one package.
I also think Mario Odyssey is necessary because it shows what the Switch can really do, with big open kingdoms, smooth controls, and surprises hidden in every corner. It is the game I show friends when they ask why I love Nintendo. Even years after release, it still feels fresh, and the capture mechanic has not been matched by anything else on the console.
Finally, the different versions matter because the way you buy the game changes how you play it. A cartridge is easy to share, a digital copy is always ready, and a renewed copy saves money for the same adventure. Picking the right version means you get the game you want in the form that fits your habits best.
My Buying Guides on Mario Odyssey
Why I Looked for Mario Odyssey
I wanted a 3D Mario game that felt new instead of a remake, and Odyssey kept coming up in every recommendation.
My old Mario games were getting stale, so I went looking for something fresh.
What I Check Before Buying
I check whether the listing is the physical cartridge, a digital code, or a renewed copy, because each one plays differently in daily use.
I also check the seller and the return policy before I commit.
My Preference for Physical or Digital
I prefer the physical cartridge when I might share the game, and the digital code when I want it always installed.
For Odyssey, the cartridge won because I lend games to my nephew.
What I Look for in Quality
I look for a clean cartridge, a working code, and a seller with solid feedback.
For renewed copies, I check the label and contacts the moment the package arrives.
How I Compare Prices
I compare the cartridge, the digital code, and the renewed copy side by side, then weigh the savings against sharing and resale.
The cheapest option is not always the best value for me.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Pick the cartridge if you share games, the digital code if you hate swapping carts, and the renewed copy if you want the same game for less.
Buy the bundle only if you need a spare controller too.
Final Thoughts
After many hours across five versions of Mario Odyssey, the physical cartridge is my top pick for most players, with the digital code a close second for convenience. The renewed copy is the smartest buy if you want the same adventure for less, and the bundles are worth it only if you need the extras they include.
Whichever version you choose, you are getting one of the best platformers on the Switch, full of surprises, clever moons, and moments that made me smile out loud. Start with the cartridge, keep a memory card handy for digital games, and enjoy the ride through every kingdom.