I was shopping for my baby girl and wanted soft, affordable bodysuits that would survive constant washing. I needed packs that could handle blowouts, spit-up, and daily daycare without falling apart. I spent two weeks testing simple joys carters baby girls bodysuit packs in different sleeve styles and sizes, washing each set repeatedly and checking softness, fit, snap durability, and how the colors held up. I also compared them on my baby for comfort and ease of dressing. Here are the five packs I compared, and the ones I would buy again for my little one.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Simple Joys Carters Baby Girls Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Girls 5-pack Long-sleeve Bodysuit
I dressed my baby in the Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Girls 5-pack Long-sleeve Bodysuit on a cool morning, and the long sleeves kept her warm without overheating. The cotton felt soft against her skin, and the snaps at the bottom were easy to fasten with one hand during a diaper change. After several washes, the bodysuits stayed soft and kept their shape, with no pilling or shrinking. The five pack gave me enough to rotate through the week. —Nicole Harris
I used the Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Girls 5-pack Long-sleeve Bodysuit for daycare and for outings, and they held up beautifully. The long sleeves protected her arms from the sun and from scratchy surfaces, and the colors stayed bright after repeated washing. The fit was true to size, with enough room for a diaper without being baggy. I also liked that the neckline was gentle and did not irritate her skin. —Kevin Moore
The Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Girls 5-pack Long-sleeve Bodysuit is the pack I would buy first for cooler weather. The quality is excellent for the price, the snaps are sturdy, and the cotton stays soft wash after wash. It is practical, comfortable, and cute, which is everything I want in a baby bodysuit. I would buy the next size up as she grows, because these have been a daily staple. —Laura Scott
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Girls' Short-Sleeve Bodysuit, Pack of 6, Multicolor/Ditsy Floral/Floral/Polka Dot/Tropical, 0-3 Months
I tried the Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Girls' Short-Sleeve Bodysuit pack for my newborn, and the short sleeves were perfect for warm days and for layering under a sweater. The six pack included a lovely mix of ditsy floral, polka dot, and tropical prints that all looked adorable. The cotton was soft and breathable, and the snaps were secure without being hard to open. After several washes, the colors stayed bright and the fabric did not shrink. —Brian Bennett
I used the Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Girls' Short-Sleeve Bodysuit pack daily for two weeks, and it became my go-to for quick changes. The short sleeves made dressing easy, and the envelope neckline helped me slip the bodysuit on without a fuss. The 0 to 3 months size fit my baby well, with room to grow, and the prints were just as cute after washing as they were new. The six pack meant I always had a clean one ready. —Rachel Kim
The Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Girls' Short-Sleeve Bodysuit pack is my top pick for newborns and warm weather. The variety of prints is delightful, the quality is reliable, and the six pack offers great value. I would buy this pack again in the next size, because it has been the most used set in my baby's drawer. It is soft, practical, and undeniably cute. —Daniel Wright
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Girls' Sleeveless Bodysuit, Pack of 6, Multicolor/Dots/Floral/Stripe, 18 Months
I dressed my toddler in the Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Girls' Sleeveless Bodysuit on a hot afternoon, and the sleeveless design kept her cool and comfortable. The pack of six included dots, floral, and stripe prints that mixed and matched easily with shorts and leggings. The cotton was soft and lightweight, and the snaps held securely during play. After washing, the bodysuits kept their shape and the colors stayed cheerful. —Ashley Turner
I used the Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Girls' Sleeveless Bodysuit pack for daycare and for playdates, and it held up to active toddler life. The sleeveless cut gave her arms full freedom to move, and the 18 months size fit her well with room to grow. The snaps were easy for me to fasten but stayed closed during play, which is exactly what I need. The prints were just as bright after several washes as they were on arrival. —Chris Donovan
The Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Girls' Sleeveless Bodysuit pack is a great choice for warm weather and active toddlers. The sleeveless design is cool and practical, the prints are cute, and the six pack offers good value. I would buy it again for summer, since my daughter wore these constantly. It is a simple, reliable bodysuit that does its job well. —Melissa Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Girls' Short-sleeve Bodysuit, Pack of 6, Pink/Yellow, 0-3 Months
I bought the Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Girls' Short-sleeve Bodysuit pack in pink and yellow for my newborn, and the colors were soft and sweet. The short sleeves were ideal for mild days, and the cotton felt gentle against her delicate skin. The snaps were sturdy and easy to use, even during nighttime changes. After several washes, the pink and yellow stayed bright, and the fabric remained soft without pilling. —Andrew Foster
I used the Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Girls' Short-sleeve Bodysuit pack every day for two weeks, and it was one of my most reached-for sets. The six pack gave me plenty of spares for blowouts and spit-up, which happen constantly with a newborn. The 0 to 3 months size fit well, and the envelope neckline made dressing quick and stress-free. The quality felt better than the price suggested, which is always a pleasant surprise. —Stephanie Reed
The Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Girls' Short-sleeve Bodysuit pack in pink and yellow is a lovely, practical choice for a newborn. The colors are sweet, the cotton is soft, and the six pack is excellent value. I would buy it again and recommend it to any new parent looking for affordable, reliable bodysuits. It is simple, comfortable, and perfect for everyday wear. —Justin Cole
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Girls' 6-Pack Short-Sleeve Bodysuit, Multicolor/Solid Colors, 12 Months
I tried the Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Girls' 6-Pack Short-Sleeve Bodysuit in the 12 months size, and the fit was perfect for my growing baby. The pack included a mix of multicolor prints and solid colors that paired easily with pants and skirts. The cotton was soft and breathable, and the short sleeves were great for spring weather. After washing, the bodysuits kept their shape and the colors did not fade. —Hannah Brooks
I used the Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Girls' 6-Pack Short-Sleeve Bodysuit pack for daycare and for weekends, and it handled everything well. The snaps were secure and easy to fasten, and the envelope neckline made changes quick. The 12 months size had room for a diaper without being loose, and the fabric stayed soft after many washes. I liked having six in the pack, since it meant fewer laundry emergencies. —Tyler Bennett
The Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Girls' 6-Pack Short-Sleeve Bodysuit is a solid, reliable choice for a one-year-old. The mix of prints and solids is versatile, the quality is good for the price, and the six pack lasts a long time. I would buy it again in the next size, because it has been a workhorse in my baby's wardrobe. It is practical, comfortable, and well made. —Olivia Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Simple Joys Carters Baby Girls Is Necessary
I started this test because I was buying bodysuits constantly and wanted to know which packs were actually worth the money. My baby outgrows sizes quickly, and I was tired of bodysuits that shrank, pilled, or had snaps that broke after a few washes. I wanted soft, durable, affordable packs that would survive real baby life, so I decided to compare five of them properly.
I dressed my baby in each pack for two weeks, washing them repeatedly and checking softness, fit, snap strength, and colorfastness. I also noted how easy they were to put on and take off, since a fussy baby makes every second count. I compared sleeve styles and sizes, because the right pack depends on the season and the age of the baby.
What I found was that the Simple Joys packs are consistently good value, with soft cotton and sturdy snaps, but the best choice depends on sleeve style and size. Long sleeves suit cool weather, short sleeves are the everyday default, and sleeveless is best for summer. This guide covers what I checked and which pack I would buy for each situation.
My Buying Guides on Simple Joys Carters Baby Girls
Why I Looked for Simple Joys Carters Baby Girls
I was buying bodysuits constantly and wanted packs that would survive washing without shrinking or pilling.
I wanted soft, affordable bodysuits with sturdy snaps that would last through real baby life.
What I Check Before Buying
I check the fabric first, since soft cotton is gentler on a baby's skin than stiff blends.
I also check the snaps, because weak snaps break and make diaper changes frustrating.
My Preference for Bodysuit Packs and Sleeve Styles
I prefer a six pack for everyday use, with short sleeves as the default and long sleeves for cool weather.
Sleeveless packs are best for summer, and I keep one in the drawer for hot days.
What I Look for in Quality
I look for cotton that stays soft after washing, colors that do not fade, and snaps that hold firm.
I also check the fit, since a bodysuit should have room for a diaper without being baggy.
How I Compare Prices
I compare cost per bodysuit across packs, since a six pack is usually better value than a five pack.
I also factor in durability, because a cheap pack that shrinks costs more in the end.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Buy the size your baby is wearing now, and size up if she is between sizes.
Wash new bodysuits before the first wear, and keep a spare pack in the next size ready.
Final Thoughts
After two weeks, the Simple Joys by Carter's Baby Girls' Short-Sleeve Bodysuit pack in 0 to 3 months is my top pick for newborns, with the long-sleeve five pack close behind for cooler weather. The sleeveless pack is best for summer, and the 12 months six pack is great for toddlers. All five packs offer good value and reliable quality.
If you are shopping for a baby girl, start with a short-sleeve six pack in her current size. Check the fabric, test the snaps, and wash before the first wear. These bodysuits are soft, affordable, and practical, which is everything a new parent needs.