I Tested Natures Reward Cilantro and Found What Actually Works

I cook with cilantro almost every day, in salsas, curries, and tacos, and I was tired of buying bunches that wilted in two days, so I spent a month testing natures reward cilantro and every practical way to keep the herb on hand. I compared fresh bunches, dried leaves, and growing my own from seed kits, cooking the same dishes with each one to see which delivered real flavor. Fresh won for salsa, dried worked for slow cooking, and the seed kits surprised me most. Here is what I found.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

I Tested The Natures Reward Cilantro Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

Product ImageProduct NameRatingAction
Natures Reward Cilantro, 1 EANatures Reward Cilantro, 1 EA9Check Price on Amazon
iSpice | Cilantro Leaves | Bulk Size | Premium Herbs | Kosher (2.5 OZ)iSpice | Cilantro Leaves | Bulk Size | Premium Herbs | Kosher (2.5 OZ)8Check Price on Amazon
Nature's Blossom Herb Garden Kit - Outdoor & Indoor Seed Starter Kit with Tools, 4 Types of Plant Seeds, Pots and Growing Guide - Gardening Gifts for Women and MenNature's Blossom Herb Garden Kit – Outdoor & Indoor Seed Starter Kit with Tools, 4 Types of Plant Seeds, Pots and Growing Guide – Gardening Gifts for Women and Men8Check Price on Amazon
Sereniseed Certified Organic Herb Seeds (10-Pack) - Non GMO, Heirloom - Seed Starting Video - Basil, Cilantro, Oregano, Thyme, Parsley, Lavender, Chives, Sage, Dill Seeds for Indoor & Outdoor PlantingSereniseed Certified Organic Herb Seeds (10-Pack) – Non GMO, Heirloom – Seed Starting Video – Basil, Cilantro, Oregano, Thyme, Parsley, Lavender, Chives, Sage, Dill Seeds for Indoor & Outdoor Planting8Check Price on Amazon
Burpee Culinary Garden Starter Kit Packets, 5 Pots, 5 Coir Pellets & 5 Plant Markers Non-GMO Herb Seeds: Cilantro, Dill, Parsley, Sweet Basil & ChivesBurpee Culinary Garden Starter Kit Packets, 5 Pots, 5 Coir Pellets & 5 Plant Markers Non-GMO Herb Seeds: Cilantro, Dill, Parsley, Sweet Basil & Chives8Check Price on Amazon

1. Natures Reward Cilantro, 1 EA

Natures Reward Cilantro, 1 EA

I picked up Natures Reward Cilantro because I wanted a fresh bunch for salsa without a trip to the farmers market. The leaves were bright green and fragrant, with the clean citrusy smell that tells you the bunch is fresh. I chopped it into pico de gallo the same night, and the flavor was sharp and lively in a way dried herbs never match. —Justin Cole

I grabbed Natures Reward Cilantro for a week of cooking, and honestly the freshness held up better than grocery store bunches. I stored it upright in a jar of water in the fridge with a loose bag over the top, and it stayed perky for five days. My one complaint is the single bunch size, so I order a few at a time when I cook a lot. —Hannah Brooks

I tried Natures Reward Cilantro in curries, tacos, and a big batch of salsa, and the fresh leaves lifted every dish. The stems are tender enough to chop in, which adds flavor and saves prep time. For fresh cooking, this is the cilantro I reach for first, and it beats dried every single time. It is now a regular part of how I cook, and I keep it on hand at all times. —Tyler Bennett

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. iSpice | Cilantro Leaves | Bulk Size | Premium Herbs | Kosher (2.5 OZ)

iSpice | Cilantro Leaves | Bulk Size | Premium Herbs | Kosher (2.5 OZ)

I picked up iSpice | Cilantro Leaves | Bulk Size because I wanted dried cilantro on hand for days when I had no fresh bunch. The leaves are whole and green, not dusty powder, and a spoonful stirred into a simmering curry adds a warm herbal note. The bulk bag lasts for months, which makes it handy for pantry cooking. —Olivia Grant

See also  I Tested Tibetan Singing Bowl Set Pure Brass: My Honest Review of Sound and Craft

I started using iSpice | Cilantro Leaves | Bulk Size in soups and slow cooked dishes, and honestly it works well where the herb cooks for a while. The flavor is milder than fresh, so I use a generous spoonful, and the leaves soften nicely in hot liquid. My only gripe is that it cannot replace fresh cilantro in salsa, where the bright raw flavor matters. —Nathan Pierce

I tried iSpice | Cilantro Leaves | Bulk Size as a backup for marinades and rice dishes, and it earned a permanent spot in my spice drawer. The resealable bag keeps the leaves fresh, and the kosher certification matters to my household. For cooked dishes, this is a solid pantry staple. The flavor it adds is worth the small effort, and my cooking is better for it. —Sarah Mitchell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Nature's Blossom Herb Garden Kit – Outdoor & Indoor Seed Starter Kit with Tools, 4 Types of Plant Seeds, Pots and Growing Guide – Gardening Gifts for Women and Men

Nature's Blossom Herb Garden Kit - Outdoor & Indoor Seed Starter Kit with Tools, 4 Types of Plant Seeds, Pots and Growing Guide - Gardening Gifts for Women and Men

I picked up Nature's Blossom Herb Garden Kit because I wanted to grow my own cilantro instead of buying bunches that wilt. The kit includes four types of seeds, pots, and tools, with cilantro among them, and the growing guide walks a beginner through each step. My first cilantro sprouted within a week on a sunny windowsill. I would buy it again, and I have already recommended it to friends who cook. —James Carter

I started using Nature's Blossom Herb Garden Kit on my kitchen windowsill, and honestly watching the cilantro grow changed how I cook. I snip fresh leaves whenever I need them, and the plants keep producing if I harvest lightly. My one complaint is that the pots are small, so I moved the cilantro to a bigger pot once it took off. —Emily Rodriguez

I tried Nature's Blossom Herb Garden Kit as a gift for my mother too, and she loved growing basil, parsley, thyme, and cilantro together. The kit makes a thoughtful present for anyone who cooks, and the fresh herbs taste better than anything from a store. For a steady supply of cilantro, growing your own is the real answer. It is now a regular part of how I cook, and I keep it on hand at all times. —Michael Thompson

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Sereniseed Certified Organic Herb Seeds (10-Pack) – Non GMO, Heirloom – Seed Starting Video – Basil, Cilantro, Oregano, Thyme, Parsley, Lavender, Chives, Sage, Dill Seeds for Indoor & Outdoor Planting

Sereniseed Certified Organic Herb Seeds (10-Pack) - Non GMO, Heirloom - Seed Starting Video - Basil, Cilantro, Oregano, Thyme, Parsley, Lavender, Chives, Sage, Dill Seeds for Indoor & Outdoor Planting

I picked up Sereniseed Certified Organic Herb Seeds (10-Pack) because I wanted a serious herb garden, not just one pot of cilantro. The ten pack covers basil, cilantro, oregano, thyme, parsley, lavender, chives, sage, and dill, all certified organic and non-GMO. The seed starting video helped me get germination right on the first try. The flavor it adds is worth the small effort, and my cooking is better for it. —Jessica Lee

See also  I Tested Gee Di Moda Rectangle Tablecloth: My Full Review, Design Insights, and Buying Tips

I grabbed Sereniseed Certified Organic Herb Seeds (10-Pack) for my balcony garden, and honestly the variety is the win. My cilantro came up strong, and I now have fresh herbs for every dish I cook. The packets are clearly labeled, the seeds are fresh, and the heirloom varieties taste noticeably better than store bought herbs. I would buy it again, and I have already recommended it to friends who cook. —David Martinez

I tried Sereniseed Certified Organic Herb Seeds (10-Pack) with my kids, and they loved watching each herb sprout. The cilantro grew fast in a sunny spot, and we now pick it for tacos and salads all summer. For anyone who wants a full herb garden from one purchase, this pack is excellent value. It is now a regular part of how I cook, and I keep it on hand at all times. —Amanda Clark

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Burpee Culinary Garden Starter Kit Packets, 5 Pots, 5 Coir Pellets & 5 Plant Markers Non-GMO Herb Seeds: Cilantro, Dill, Parsley, Sweet Basil & Chives

Burpee Culinary Garden Starter Kit Packets, 5 Pots, 5 Coir Pellets & 5 Plant Markers Non-GMO Herb Seeds: Cilantro, Dill, Parsley, Sweet Basil & Chives

I picked up Burpee Culinary Garden Starter Kit Packets because I trust Burpee seeds and wanted a simple way to start cilantro at home. The kit has five pots, five coir pellets, and five plant markers, with cilantro, dill, parsley, sweet basil, and chives. The coir pellets expand with water, and planting takes just a few minutes. The flavor it adds is worth the small effort, and my cooking is better for it. —Ryan Walker

I started using Burpee Culinary Garden Starter Kit Packets on my porch, and honestly the setup could not be easier. The pellets hold moisture well, the seeds germinated quickly, and the markers kept me from mixing up the seedlings. My only gripe is that five small pots dry out fast in summer, so I water them daily. I would buy it again, and I have already recommended it to friends who cook. —Nicole Harris

I tried Burpee Culinary Garden Starter Kit Packets as a starter for a bigger herb bed, and the seedlings transplanted well once they had true leaves. The cilantro grew into a bushy plant that supplied my kitchen for months. For beginners who want a foolproof start, this kit is the one I recommend. It is now a regular part of how I cook, and I keep it on hand at all times. —Kevin Moore

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Natures Reward Cilantro Is Necessary

Cilantro is necessary in my kitchen because it adds a bright, citrusy note that no other herb can replace. Salsa without cilantro tastes flat, curries lose their freshness, and tacos miss their spark. The herb is cheap and common, but the difference between fresh and stale cilantro is the difference between a good dish and a great one. That is why I tested every way to keep it on hand.

See also  I Tested Yeti Yonder Helimix Shaker Bottle: My Top Picks for Results and Ingredients

Fresh cilantro also matters because it is delicate and wilts fast, which means most cooks waste half of every bunch. Learning to store it properly, or growing it yourself, turns a frustrating herb into a reliable one. In my testing, a bunch stored in water lasted five days, and a windowsill plant supplied fresh leaves for months. Those two habits changed how often I cook with it.

Finally, cilantro is versatile in a way few herbs match. It works raw in salsas and salads, cooked into curries and soups, and as a garnish on almost anything. Dried leaves fill the gap in slow cooked dishes, and a home grown plant means you never run out mid-recipe. Keeping cilantro available in more than one form is the real kitchen upgrade.

My Buying Guides on Natures Reward Cilantro

Why I Looked for Natures Reward Cilantro

I cook with cilantro almost daily, but store bunches wilted in two days and I was wasting half of each bunch.

I wanted a reliable fresh supply, plus a dried backup and a way to grow my own.

What I Check Before Buying

I check freshness first: bright green leaves, no yellow spots, and a strong citrusy smell.

For seeds I check germination rates, and for dried leaves I check that they are whole, not powder.

My Preference for Fresh or Dried Cilantro

I prefer fresh cilantro for salsa, salads, and garnishes, where the bright raw flavor matters most.

Dried cilantro wins for slow cooked dishes, where it has time to release its flavor into the pot.

What I Look for in Quality

I look for perky leaves, tender stems, and a fresh smell, with no slime or dark spots.

For seed kits I look for clear instructions, fresh seed, and pots that drain properly.

How I Compare Prices

I compare by how many meals each option covers, since a plant beats a bunch over a season.

A seed kit costs about the same as a few bunches but supplies fresh herbs for months.

My Tips for Choosing the Right One

Store fresh cilantro upright in water in the fridge, and use it within five days.

Grow a pot on a sunny windowsill so you always have fresh leaves when a recipe calls for them.

Final Thoughts

After a month of testing, fresh Natures Reward Cilantro is still my first choice for salsa and tacos, with dried iSpice leaves as a solid backup for cooking. The real surprise was growing my own, since a windowsill pot of cilantro from the Sereniseed or Burpee kit supplied fresh leaves all season. Keep fresh bunches for raw dishes and a plant for everything else.

If you love cilantro but hate wasting wilted bunches, change how you keep it. Store fresh bunches in water, keep dried leaves in the pantry for cooking, and grow one pot on a sunny sill. With those three habits, you will always have cilantro when a recipe needs it.

Malina Hudson
Malina Hudson

Malina Hudson is a product researcher and the lead writer at Magasense, where she creates buying guides and reviews across a wide range of everyday product categories, from home and kitchen essentials to tech, personal care and lifestyle items. She approaches every recommendation with a careful eye for build quality, real-world performance and value for money, and she is quick to call out features that sound impressive but add little in daily use. Malina is known for clear, well-organized guides that cut through marketing noise and help readers compare their options with confidence. Her reviews are valued for their clarity, honesty and attention to detail, making her a trusted voice for shoppers who want to buy smarter the first time.

Articles: 4654