I roast a lot of chicken and the occasional turkey, and my old roasting pan had a warped base, a loose lid, and a nonstick coating that was flaking into dinner. I tested five Granite Ware oval roasters side by side over a month of Sunday roasts, from the compact 13 inch model up to the big 19 inch pan, checking how evenly each one browned, how the lid fit, and how hard cleanup really was. The differences were bigger than I expected, and one size surprised me. Here is what I found.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Granite Ware Oval Roaster Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Granite Ware 13-inch oval roaster with Lid. Enameled steel design to accommodate up to 7 lb poultry/roast. Resists up to 932°F. Ideal for preparing meals for two!
I picked up Granite Ware 13-inch oval roaster because I wanted a compact pan for weeknight chickens and small roasts without hauling out a giant tray. The speckled black enamel looks classic on the table, and the 7 lb capacity fits a small turkey or a big chicken with vegetables tucked around it. The lid doubles as a second roaster, which I use for baking bread, and the porcelain surface releases food better than I expected. —Michael Thompson
I have been using Granite Ware 13-inch oval roaster for a month of Sunday dinners, and honestly the even browning is what keeps me reaching for it. The dark enamel absorbs oven heat and gives chicken skin a deep golden color without burning the bottom. My complaint is that the handles are shallow, so I use oven mitts with a good grip when the pan is full and hot. Cleanup is easy since it goes straight in the dishwasher. —Jessica Lee
I tried Granite Ware 13-inch oval roaster for a sourdough loaf after reading that the lid traps steam well, and the crust came out better than in my Dutch oven. The pan is light enough to carry with one hand when empty, and the enamel has not chipped despite regular use. One thing to watch is that the lid can slide if you tilt the pan, so I lift it level. For small households and two-person roasts, this size is just right. —David Martinez
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Granite Ware 15-Inch Covered Oval Roaster, 10 Lb Capacity – Enamel Steel Cookware, Dishwasher Safe & PFOA-Free, Even Heat Distribution for Roasting Poultry, Meat, or Vegetables (Speckled Black)
I grabbed Granite Ware 15-Inch Covered Oval Roaster because the 13 inch model felt tight for a holiday bird with stuffing and vegetables. The 10 lb capacity hits a sweet spot for family dinners, and the enamel steel heats evenly from edge to edge. The self-basting lid is the feature I notice most, since it keeps the breast moist without me opening the oven to baste. The speckled finish still looks good after several washes. —Amanda Clark
I started using Granite Ware 15-Inch Covered Oval Roaster for a 8 lb turkey, and honestly it handled the bird better than my old stainless pan. The drippings collected cleanly for gravy, the skin browned evenly, and nothing stuck to the porcelain surface. My complaint is the weight when full, since a loaded 15 inch pan needs two hands and a steady grip. The dishwasher-safe claim holds up, and the pan came out spotless every time. —Ryan Walker
Me and Granite Ware 15-Inch Covered Oval Roaster have become my default for Sunday roasts and potlucks. The lid fits snugly without rattling, the pan slides into a standard oven without crowding the rack, and the PFOA-free enamel gives me one less thing to worry about. One quirk is that the lid is a little domed, so it needs a flat spot on the counter when I take it off. For a family of four, this is the size I recommend first. —Nicole Harris
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Granite Ware 19-Inch Covered Oval Roaster, 20 Lb Capacity – Enamel Steel Cookware, Dishwasher Safe & PFOA-Free, Even Heat Distribution for Roasting Poultry, Meat, or Vegetables (Speckled Black)
I bought Granite Ware 19-Inch Covered Oval Roaster because holiday dinners at my house mean a 20 lb turkey and a crowd that expects leftovers. The capacity is the whole point here, and it swallowed the bird with room for carrots and onions around the edges. The enamel steel is rated to 932 degrees, so I never worry about high-heat roasting, and the lid seals well enough to keep the meat juicy through a long cook. —Kevin Moore
I have been using Granite Ware 19-Inch Covered Oval Roaster for two big holiday meals, and honestly the even cooking across such a large pan impressed me. The legs and wings browned at the same rate as the breast, which my old pan never managed. My complaint is storage, since a 19 inch pan does not fit in a standard cabinet and lives on top of my fridge. It is also heavy when loaded, so I plan my oven rack height before the bird goes in. —Laura Scott
I tried Granite Ware 19-Inch Covered Oval Roaster for a slow-cooked pork shoulder, and the lid kept the moisture in for hours without a single baste. The porcelain surface wiped clean after an overnight soak, and the enamel showed no chips or stains. One thing to know is that the pan needs a full-size oven rack and a rimmed baking sheet underneath for safe handling. For big families and holiday cooks, this is the workhorse size. —Brian Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Granite Ware 18-Inch Oval Covered Roaster With Rack – Nonstick Enamel Steel Cookware with Lid for Baking, Broiling, Grilling, Even Cooking – Multiuse Roasting Pan for Versatile Meals
I picked up Granite Ware 18-Inch Oval Covered Roaster With Rack because I wanted the rack for lifting roasts out cleanly and letting fat drip away. The included rack is sturdy and fits the pan exactly, and the 15 lb capacity covers most turkeys and large chickens. The nonstick enamel surface releases skin and drippings easily, and the lid is tall enough to clear a big bird. It feels like a complete roasting system rather than just a pan. —Rachel Kim
I started using Granite Ware 18-Inch Oval Covered Roaster With Rack for a glazed ham, and honestly the rack made carving and serving much easier. The ham lifted out in one piece, the glaze stayed intact, and the drippings in the pan made a great sauce. My complaint is that the rack is a little fiddly to wash by hand, since the wires trap food, but the dishwasher handles it. The lid doubles as a shallow roaster for vegetables, which is a nice bonus. —Daniel Wright
Me and Granite Ware 18-Inch Oval Covered Roaster With Rack have become my pick for baking and broiling as well as roasting. I have used it for lasagna, roasted vegetables, and a whole chicken, and the even heat shows in every dish. One quirk is that the rack can slide if the pan is tilted, so I keep it level when moving it. For cooks who want a rack included and a pan that does more than turkey, this one earns its shelf space. —Ashley Turner
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Granite Ware 4-Piece 18-in Roasting Set w/Lid, Enameled Steel, Speckled Black
I grabbed Granite Ware 4-Piece 18-in Roasting Set w/Lid because I liked the idea of a full set that covers roasting, baking, and serving in one box. The 18 inch covered roaster holds up to 15 lb with the lid off, and the extra pieces mean I always have the right pan for the job. The speckled black enamel matches the rest of my cookware, and the set feels solid without being heavy. It is the kind of kit that replaces three separate pans. —Chris Donovan
I have been using Granite Ware 4-Piece 18-in Roasting Set w/Lid through a month of roasts and bakes, and honestly the versatility is what stands out. The roaster browns poultry evenly, the lid works as a second pan for casseroles, and everything stacks neatly when I am done. My complaint is that the set takes up real cabinet space, so I keep the pieces nested on a high shelf. The enamel has held up to weekly dishwasher cycles without dulling. —Melissa Grant
I tried Granite Ware 4-Piece 18-in Roasting Set w/Lid for a full holiday meal with a turkey, a side of roasted vegetables, and a baked dessert, and every piece earned its place. The roaster handled the bird, the lid baked the vegetables, and cleanup was a single dishwasher load. One thing to watch is that the pieces are steel, not cast iron, so they heat fast and cool fast. For a new kitchen or a cook who wants one set to do it all, this is a smart buy. —Andrew Foster
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Granite Ware Oval Roaster Is Necessary
I went looking for a proper oval roaster because my old pan browned unevenly, stuck to every roast, and had a lid that never sat flat. Sunday dinners kept ending with dry breast meat and a burnt bottom, and I was tired of scrubbing for half an hour after every meal. A good roaster should do the work for you, and that is what I set out to find.
An oval shape matters because it matches the shape of a bird, so heat wraps around the roast instead of pooling in corners. A tight lid matters just as much, since it traps steam and bastes the meat on its own. I also wanted enamel steel, which is light, heats fast, and cleans up without special care.
Testing five Granite Ware roasters taught me that size is the decision that matters most, more than any coating or feature. A pan that is too small crowds the bird and steams it, while a pan that is too big dries the drippings out. Pick the size that fits your usual roast, and the rest falls into place.
My Buying Guides on Granite Ware Oval Roaster
Why I Looked for Granite Ware Oval Roaster
My old roasting pan browned unevenly and stuck to every roast, so I wanted an oval pan that matched the shape of a bird.
I also wanted a lid that actually fit, since a loose lid lets steam escape and dries the meat out.
What I Check Before Buying
First I check the capacity in pounds, since the bird has to fit with room for vegetables around it.
Then I look at the enamel quality and the lid fit, because a warped lid or thin coating will show up fast.
My Preference for Small or Large Roasters
For weeknight chickens I prefer the compact 13 inch pan, since it heats fast and cleans up in minutes.
For holidays I go big, because a crowded pan steams the bird instead of roasting it.
What I Look for in Quality
A quality roaster has even heat, a snug lid, and enamel that does not chip or stain after real use.
I also check the handles, since a full hot pan needs a grip I can trust with oven mitts on.
How I Compare Prices
I compare the cost per use, since a roaster that lasts a decade is cheaper than a bargain pan replaced every year.
I also weigh a set against single pans, because a lid that doubles as a second pan adds real value.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Measure your oven rack first, then pick the largest pan that fits with room to spare.
Choose enamel steel for easy cleanup, and always let the pan cool before washing to protect the finish.
Final Thoughts
After a month of Sunday roasts, the 15 inch Granite Ware is the size I would buy first, with the 13 inch model perfect for smaller households and the 19 inch pan reserved for real holiday crowds. The rack model is the best all-rounder if you roast more than turkey, and the four-piece set is the smartest buy for a new kitchen. Whichever you pick, the enamel and the lid do the heavy lifting.
If you roast even once a month, a proper oval roaster is worth the shelf space. Pick your size by your usual bird, preheat the pan if your recipe calls for it, and let the lid do the basting for you. Your chicken will come out juicier, your cleanup will be faster, and Sunday dinner will taste like you worked much harder than you did.




