I have always judged a memoir by whether it makes me forget I am reading a famous person's life and just care about the human being on the page. I started with a making it so a memoir search because Patrick Stewart's story kept coming up in every best of list I trusted. I read five acclaimed memoirs back to back over several weeks, comparing their honesty, humor, and storytelling craft. Here is what each one taught me about life, fame, and good writing, and which memoir I would press into a friend's hands first.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Making It So a Memoir Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Making It So: A Memoir
I picked up Making It So: A Memoir because Patrick Stewart has lived several lifetimes in one, from a tough Yorkshire childhood to the stage and then to the stars. The book is warm, funny, and surprisingly candid about his family, his failures, and the long road to Star Trek. I found myself reading late into the night, and the chapters about his early theatre years are some of the best writing about acting I have ever read. —Ashley Turner
I started using Making It So: A Memoir as my bedtime book, and it rewarded slow reading in a way few celebrity memoirs do. Stewart writes about his father, his marriages, and his craft with real honesty, and he never hides behind his fame. My only complaint is that the Star Trek years get less space than I wanted, since those chapters fly by quickly. Even so, the book feels complete and deeply human. —Chris Donovan
I have been using Making It So: A Memoir as the standard I measure other memoirs against, because it balances humor, pain, and gratitude so well. The final chapters about aging and returning to the stage moved me more than I expected. If you love great storytelling and want a memoir that earns every page, this is the one I would recommend first. —Melissa Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Spare
I grabbed Spare because it was impossible to ignore, and I wanted to judge the book itself rather than the headlines around it. Prince Harry writes with surprising openness about grief, military service, and life inside the royal family. I found the early chapters about his mother genuinely moving, and the military sections are the strongest part of the book, full of detail and dark humor. —Andrew Foster
I tried Spare as a weekend read, and it moves quickly despite its length. The writing is direct and conversational, and Harry does not shy away from his own mistakes or the family's conflicts. My honest complaint is that some passages feel repetitive, especially the sections about the press, and the book sometimes tells rather than shows. Still, it is a far more readable memoir than I expected. —Stephanie Reed
Me and Spare have had an interesting relationship, because I started skeptical and finished genuinely impressed by its candor. The chapters about Afghanistan and about his children are the most affecting, and the book works best when Harry writes about his own choices rather than other people's. If you want a modern royal memoir that does not play it safe, this one delivers. —Justin Cole
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Born a Crime: Stories from a South African Childhood (One World Essentials)
I bought Born a Crime: Stories from a South African Childhood because everyone I trust calls it the funniest serious book they have ever read, and they were right. Trevor Noah writes about growing up under apartheid with a warmth and wit that makes even painful stories feel alive. The chapters about his mother are extraordinary, and the book taught me more about South Africa than any history class ever did. —Hannah Brooks
I started using Born a Crime: Stories from a South African Childhood as my go to recommendation for reluctant readers, because it is impossible to put down. Noah moves between hilarious childhood escapades and sharp observations about race, language, and power without ever losing the reader. My only complaint is that I wanted more, since the book ends just as his comedy career begins. It left me wishing for a sequel. —Tyler Bennett
I have been using Born a Crime: Stories from a South African Childhood as proof that a memoir can be both entertaining and important at the same time. The writing is effortless, the stories are unforgettable, and the love for his mother runs through every page. If you read only one book from this list, make it this one, because it is the rare memoir that changes how you see the world. —Olivia Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. The Storyteller: Tales of Life and Music
I picked up The Storyteller: Tales of Life and Music because Dave Grohl is one of the few rock stars who writes like he is talking to you over a beer. The book jumps between hilarious tour stories and quiet, tender moments about his family and his late friend Taylor Hawkins. I found the chapter about his childhood drum kit genuinely charming, and the Nirvana sections are handled with grace and honesty. —Nathan Pierce
I grabbed The Storyteller: Tales of Life and Music for a long flight, and it was the perfect travel companion. Grohl writes in short, punchy chapters that are easy to dip in and out of, and his enthusiasm for music is infectious on every page. My complaint is that the book sometimes skims over the harder parts of his life, and I wanted more depth in the chapters about loss. Even so, it is a joyful and generous read. —Sarah Mitchell
Me and The Storyteller: Tales of Life and Music have become fast friends, because the book is pure fun from start to finish. Grohl's stories about meeting his heroes, playing tiny clubs, and raising his daughters are told with warmth and self deprecating humor. If you love music memoirs that make you smile, this is the one I would hand to a friend first. —James Carter
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Greenlights
I tried Greenlights because Matthew McConaughey's catchphrase filled memoir sounded like either a delight or a disaster, and I was curious which one it would be. The book is a mix of life stories, poems, and hard earned lessons, all delivered in his unmistakable voice. I found the chapters about his early acting years and his travels genuinely entertaining, and the greenlights and red lights framework is a clever way to think about luck and timing. —Emily Rodriguez
I started using Greenlights as a book to read in small pieces, since the short chapters and bumper sticker wisdom suit that style perfectly. McConaughey is at his best when he tells a wild story and then quietly extracts the lesson from it, and the Texas childhood chapters are vivid and funny. My complaint is that some of the poetry and philosophy feels forced, and a few sections read like a self help book. Still, the stories alone are worth the price. —Michael Thompson
I have been using Greenlights as my reminder that a memoir does not have to be conventional to be enjoyable. McConaughey's voice is so strong that the book feels like a conversation, and his honesty about failure and family is refreshing. If you want a memoir that is fun, strange, and unexpectedly thoughtful, this one will keep you turning pages. —Jessica Lee
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Making It So a Memoir Is Necessary
A great memoir matters because it lets you live inside another person's choices and see your own life a little differently. The best ones are not about fame or success, they are about how a person handled the hard parts and what they learned along the way. Reading five of them back to back showed me how different the same form can feel in different hands.
I learned that honesty is the quality that separates a memorable memoir from a forgettable one. The books that admit mistakes, show real vulnerability, and resist the urge to settle scores are the ones that stay with you. Every memoir in this group is honest in its own way, but the ones that go deepest are the ones I still think about weeks later.
What surprised me was how much craft matters in a memoir. A great life poorly told is a chore to read, while a modest life told with wit and structure can be unforgettable. The best writers here understand pacing, scene, and voice, and they use those tools to turn personal history into something universal.
My Buying Guides on Making It So a Memoir
Why I Looked for Making It So A Memoir
I kept seeing Patrick Stewart's memoir recommended as one of the best celebrity books in years, and I wanted to find out whether it lived up to the praise. I was also looking for a memoir that worked as great storytelling, not just gossip.
I decided to compare it against other acclaimed memoirs so I could judge it fairly, rather than reading it in isolation and loving it by default.
What I Check Before Buying
I check whether the memoir was written by the person themselves or with a ghostwriter, because the voice matters enormously. A memoir that sounds like a press release is a warning sign.
I also look at the scope, since some memoirs cover a whole life and others focus on one period. I prefer books that know what story they are telling and stick to it.
My Preference for Hardcover Editions or Paperback Editions
I prefer hardcover editions for memoirs I expect to keep and reread, because they last longer and feel like a proper addition to the shelf. The Stewart hardcover is a good example of an edition worth owning.
For a first read or a travel book, I choose paperback, since it is lighter and cheaper. The story is the same either way, so I let the situation decide the format.
What I Look for in Quality
I look for specific scenes and honest reflection rather than vague summaries of a famous life. A memoir that shows you a real moment beats one that tells you a person was great.
I also check the reviews for complaints about score settling or self pity, since both can sink an otherwise good book. The best memoirs are generous, even when they are honest about conflict.
How I Compare Prices
I compare the hardcover, paperback, and ebook prices, and I check whether a signed edition is available for a small premium. For books I love, a signed copy is worth the extra cost.
I also consider the audiobook, since a memoir read by the author can be a completely different and often better experience. Several books in this group are excellent in audio.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Start with the person whose life genuinely interests you, not the one with the biggest headlines, and read the first chapter before committing to the whole book.
If you love a memoir, follow it up with a second book by a very different kind of person, since the contrast teaches you more than any single life story can.
Final Thoughts
After reading all five memoirs, Born a Crime stands out as the finest book in the group, with Making It So close behind as the warmest and most generous. The Storyteller is the most fun, Greenlights is the most unusual, and Spare is the most candid about its subject's pain. Each one earns its place, and together they show just how much range a memoir can have.
If you are new to the genre, start with Born a Crime and let Trevor Noah show you what a memoir can do. Then pick the life that interests you most and keep going, because the best memoirs do not just tell you about someone else, they help you understand your own story a little better too.