My cat has strong opinions about treats, and most biscuits get sniffed once and ignored, so I spent a month testing temptations classic crunchy soft cat treats in five flavors and sizes. I compared how eagerly my cats ate each flavor, how long the tubs lasted, and how well the treats worked for training and as meal toppers. Some flavors disappeared fast, one won over a shy rescue cat, and the biggest bag turned out to be the best value. I kept notes on every flavor, every tub size, and every time a cat walked away unimpressed.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Temptations Classic Crunchy Soft Cat Treats Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats, Tasty Chicken, 16 oz | Under 2 calories per treat, crunchy outside & soft inside, resealable tub, 100% complete & balanced, snack, meal or topper
I picked up Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats because my cat hears the tub open from two rooms away, and I wanted a treat that was actually good for her. The tasty chicken flavor is her favorite, the 16 ounce tub lasts for weeks, and each treat has under 2 calories, so I can reward her often without worrying about her waistline. The crunchy outside and soft inside keep her crunching happily. —Jessica Lee
I have been using Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats every day, and honestly the resealable tub is what keeps them fresh. My cat sits and waits politely for her evening treat, and the crunchy texture seems to help her teeth while the soft center delivers the flavor. My one complaint is that the tub empties faster than I expect, because everyone in the house sneaks her an extra treat. —David Martinez
I tried Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats as a training reward, and the chicken flavor holds my cat's attention through every trick. The treats work as a snack, a meal topper, or a bedtime reward, and the 100 percent complete and balanced formula means they are more than empty calories. For a daily cat treat, this chicken tub is the one I trust most. —Amanda Clark
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats Tasty Chicken Flavor, 30 oz. Tub
I grabbed Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats Tasty Chicken Flavor because the 30 ounce tub is the best value for a house with two cats who both expect treats. The larger tub means I am not reordering every week, and the chicken flavor is the one both cats agree on. The resealable lid keeps the treats crunchy, and the tub stacks neatly in the pantry. —Ryan Walker
I started using Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats Tasty Chicken Flavor in the 30 ounce size after the small tub kept running out midweek. Both cats come running at the sound of the lid, and the under 2 calorie treats let me reward them several times a day. My one complaint is that the big tub is tempting for the cats to knock over, so I store it on a high shelf. —Nicole Harris
Me and Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats Tasty Chicken Flavor have a twice daily routine now, morning treats after breakfast and evening treats before bed. The 30 ounce tub lasts about a month with two cats, the chicken flavor never gets boring, and the crunchy soft texture keeps both cats crunching. For multi cat households, this is the tub to buy. —Kevin Moore
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Temptations Cat Treats, Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats, Seafood Medley Flavor, 30 oz. Tub
I bought Temptations Cat Treats because the seafood medley flavor sounded like a change my fish loving cat would enjoy, and the 30 ounce tub was good value. The mix of seafood flavors keeps her interested, and the crunchy outside with a soft inside is the same satisfying texture she loves. She finishes each treat quickly and then looks up for another, which is the highest praise a cat can give. —Laura Scott
I picked up Temptations Cat Treats in seafood medley after my cat started ignoring the chicken flavor, and the new flavor genuinely rekindled her excitement. The 30 ounce tub lasts for weeks, the resealable lid keeps the treats fresh, and the under 2 calorie size means I can give her several a day. My one complaint is that the seafood smell is strong when the tub opens, though my cat clearly loves it. —Brian Bennett
I tried Temptations Cat Treats in seafood medley as a meal topper, sprinkling a few over her regular food to tempt a picky eater. It worked immediately, and now a few treats on top is our standard dinner routine. For cats who love fish flavors, this seafood medley tub is the variety that keeps treat time exciting day after day, without fail. —Rachel Kim
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Temptations Cat Treats Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats, Savory Salmon Flavor, 48 oz. Bag
I picked up Temptations Cat Treats Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats because the savory salmon flavor is my cat's absolute favorite, and the 48 ounce bag is the biggest value in the range. The large bag means I am stocked for months, and the salmon flavor has a rich smell that brings my cat running from anywhere in the house. The bag seals well and keeps the treats crunchy. —Daniel Wright
I have been using Temptations Cat Treats Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats in savory salmon for two months, and honestly the 48 ounce bag is the most economical way to buy these treats. My cat gets her daily treats, the bag stays fresh with its resealable top, and I have not thought about reordering once. My one complaint is that the bag is bulky to store, so it lives in the pantry rather than on the counter. —Ashley Turner
I tried Temptations Cat Treats Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats in salmon as a training reward for a shy rescue cat, and the strong flavor won her trust faster than any other treat. She now comes out for her salmon treat every evening, and the routine has become the highlight of her day. For salmon loving cats, this big bag is the best value of all. —Chris Donovan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Temptations Cat Treats, Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats, Creamy Dairy Flavor, 16 oz. Tub
I grabbed Temptations Cat Treats because the creamy dairy flavor sounded gentle and different, and my older cat prefers milder tastes these days. The 16 ounce tub is the right size to try a new flavor, and the dairy taste is soft and milky rather than strong. My cat eats them slowly and contentedly, which is a change from the way she wolfs down the chicken flavor. —Melissa Grant
I started using Temptations Cat Treats in creamy dairy for my senior cat, and the gentle flavor suits her perfectly. The crunchy outside is easy for her to manage, the soft inside is kind to older teeth, and the under 2 calorie size means I can give her several without worry. My one complaint is that the dairy flavor is less exciting for my younger cat, so this tub belongs to the older one. —Andrew Foster
Me and Temptations Cat Treats in creamy dairy have found a quiet evening routine, a few treats on the windowsill while my senior cat watches the birds. The 16 ounce tub lasts well, the resealable lid keeps them fresh, and the mild flavor is perfect for a cat who prefers gentle tastes. For older cats or picky eaters, this dairy tub is a lovely choice. —Stephanie Reed
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Temptations Classic Crunchy Soft Cat Treats Is Necessary
Cat treats matter because they are the currency of the cat human relationship, the reward that builds trust, trains behavior, and turns a wary cat into a companion. A treat that is under 2 calories lets you reward often without adding weight, and a formula that is 100 percent complete and balanced means the snack is genuinely good for your cat. When the treat is right, training feels like play.
The crunchy outside and soft inside matter because texture is what makes a treat satisfying for a cat. The crunch cleans the teeth a little with every bite, while the soft center delivers the flavor that keeps cats coming back. A treat that is all crunch gets boring, and one that is all soft disappears too fast, but this combination hits the sweet spot.
Finally, buying the right size matters because a household with two cats goes through treats fast. A 16 ounce tub suits one cat, a 30 ounce tub serves two, and a 48 ounce bag keeps a treat loving household stocked for months. Choosing the size that matches your cats means you never run out midweek and the treats always stay fresh.
My Buying Guides on Temptations Classic Crunchy Soft Cat Treats
Why I Looked for Temptations Classic Crunchy Soft Cat Treats
My cat ignored most biscuits, so I looked for a treat with a crunchy outside and soft inside that cats actually get excited about.
Temptations kept coming up as the favorite, so I tested five flavors and sizes to find the best fit for my cats.
What I Check Before Buying
First I check the calories, because a treat under 2 calories lets me reward my cat often without worrying about weight.
Then I look at flavor, tub size, and the resealable lid, since fresh treats stay crunchy and a good seal matters.
My Preference for Chicken or Seafood Medley
For a daily treat I prefer tasty chicken, because it is the flavor most cats agree on and it never gets boring.
For a change of pace I choose seafood medley or salmon, because fish flavors excite cats who have grown tired of chicken.
What I Look for in Quality
A quality cat treat has real flavor, a satisfying crunch, a soft center, and a formula that is complete and balanced.
I also check that the tub or bag reseals well, since stale treats lose the crunch that makes them worth earning.
How I Compare Prices
I compare cost per ounce across tubs and bags, because the 30 ounce tub and the 48 ounce bag are far cheaper per treat.
I also weigh flavor variety against bulk, since a big bag of one flavor only works if your cat loves that flavor.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Start with the 16 ounce chicken tub for one cat, since it is the classic flavor and the right size to learn what your cat loves.
Buy the 30 ounce tub for two cats, and the 48 ounce salmon bag if your cat is a confirmed fish lover.
Final Thoughts
After a month of treat time, the tasty chicken 16 ounce tub is my daily standard, because every cat loves it and the size is just right. The 30 ounce chicken tub serves two cats, the seafood medley adds variety, the 48 ounce salmon bag is the best value, and the creamy dairy tub suits older cats perfectly.
My advice is simple: pick the flavor your cat runs for, buy the size that matches how many cats you have, and keep the tub sealed. Used that way, any of these five will make your cat happy, and you will quickly learn which flavor earns the loudest purr.