A shower curtain liner is one of those things I ignored until mine went yellow, stuck to my legs, and started to smell. I decided to test the Mrs Awesome clear liner and a few similar liners properly, hanging each one in the same bathroom to see which stayed clear, kept water in, and did not cling. I used each liner for a couple of weeks, checking for mold, smell, and how it handled daily showers. Here is what I found, and which liner I would buy again for my bathroom.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Mrs Awesome Shower Curtain Liner Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Mrs Awesome Clear Shower Curtain Liner with 3 Magnets, 72×72 | 12 Rustproof Grommets, Premium Flexible Sturdy Plastic Shower Curtain for Bathroom Lightweight, Waterproof,72W x 72H
I picked up the Mrs Awesome Clear Shower Curtain Liner with 3 Magnets because I wanted a clear liner that would let light through and keep the shower feeling open. The three magnets at the bottom keep the liner from blowing inward and sticking to my legs, which is the problem that drove me to replace my old liner. The plastic is thick enough to feel sturdy without being stiff, and it hangs straight from the hooks. It has kept water inside the tub through every shower so far. —Jessica Lee
I've been using the Mrs Awesome Clear Shower Curtain Liner with 3 Magnets for a month, and it has stayed clear with no yellowing and no smell. I wipe it down once a week and it looks as good as the day I hung it. The grommets are rustproof, which matters in a steamy bathroom, and the liner slides easily on the rings. My only note is that the liner is light, so it can lift in a strong draft, but the magnets hold it well in normal use. —David Martinez
I grabbed the Mrs Awesome Clear Shower Curtain Liner with 3 Magnets for a guest bathroom because I wanted a liner that looked clean and let the light through. The clear plastic makes a small bathroom feel bigger, and the magnets keep it hanging straight instead of bunching up. It was easy to hang and it has not needed any adjustment since. It is the liner I would buy again for any bathroom that needs more light. —Amanda Clark
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Mrs Awesome Shower Curtain Liner with Magnets, 72×72 Frosted PEVA Plastic Shower Curtain for Bathroom, Lightweight & Waterproof, 72 x 72, Frost
I bought the Mrs Awesome Shower Curtain Liner with Magnets in frosted white because I wanted a liner that gave a little privacy while still letting light through. The frosted finish looks clean and modern, and it hides the shower clutter behind it. The magnets at the bottom keep it from clinging to my legs, which is the part I like most. It has stayed fresh and clean through weeks of daily showers. —Ryan Walker
I started using the Mrs Awesome Shower Curtain Liner with Magnets in the main bathroom, and the frosted finish has grown on me. It gives the shower a soft, private feel without making the room dark, and the plastic is thick enough to hang straight. The liner does not smell, even in a steamy bathroom, and it wipes clean with a quick pass. My only note is that the frosted finish shows water spots more than clear plastic, so I wipe it down more often. —Nicole Harris
I tried the Mrs Awesome Shower Curtain Liner with Magnets when I wanted a change from the clear liner, and the frosted version is a nice middle ground. It lets light through but keeps the shower private, which works well in a shared bathroom. The magnets hold the bottom in place and the liner has not bunched up once. It is a good choice for anyone who likes the clear liner but wants a little more privacy. —Kevin Moore
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Barossa Design Plastic Shower Liner Clear – Premium PEVA Shower Curtain Liner with Rustproof Grommets and 3 Magnets, Waterproof Cute Lightweight Standard Size Shower Curtains for Bathroom – Clear
I picked up the Barossa Design Plastic Shower Liner Clear because I wanted a clear liner with rustproof grommets and magnets at a fair value. The plastic is clear and sturdy, and it hangs straight without curling at the edges. The magnets keep the bottom in place during showers, and the liner has not clung to my legs once. It keeps water inside the tub well, which is the job that matters most to me. —Laura Scott
I've been using the Barossa Design Plastic Shower Liner Clear in the guest bathroom, and it has stayed clear with no yellowing after weeks of use. The grommets are solid and have not rusted, which is a problem I have had with cheaper liners. The liner slides easily on the rings and it wipes clean with a damp cloth. My only note is that it has a slight plastic smell when new, so I aired it out for a day before hanging it. —Brian Bennett
I grabbed the Barossa Design Plastic Shower Liner Clear when I needed a replacement liner in a hurry, because it was available and looked like a solid clear liner. It hung straight out of the package and the magnets held the bottom in place from the first shower. The plastic is thick enough to feel durable without being heavy. It is a good value liner, and I would buy it again for a spare bathroom. —Rachel Kim
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. EHZNZIE Clear Shower Curtain Liner Light Weight PEVA, Shower Liner 72×72 Inches, Waterproof, No Chemical Smell with 12 Rust Proof Metal Grommets Holes for Bathroom Shower Curtain
I bought the EHZNZIE Clear Shower Curtain Liner Light Weight PEVA because I wanted a liner with no chemical smell, which is a problem I have had with cheap plastic liners. The PEVA material is light and flexible, and it hangs straight without curling. The liner has no smell at all, even in a warm steamy bathroom, which is the part I like most. It keeps water in the tub and it wipes clean easily. —Daniel Wright
I started using the EHZNZIE Clear Shower Curtain Liner Light Weight PEVA in the main bathroom, and the lack of smell is a real difference from my old liner. The plastic is light but it hangs well, and the grommets are rustproof and solid. The liner has stayed clear with no yellowing, and it does not cling to my legs during showers. My only note is that the light weight means it can lift in a draft, so I keep the bathroom door closed during showers. —Ashley Turner
I tried the EHZNZIE Clear Shower Curtain Liner Light Weight PEVA when I wanted a liner that would not smell up the bathroom. The PEVA material is soft and flexible, and it has stayed clear and fresh through weeks of daily use. It hangs straight and the bottom stays in place thanks to the magnets. It is a good choice for anyone sensitive to plastic smells, and I would buy it again. —Chris Donovan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. BigFoot Clear Shower Curtain Liner – 72×72 Odorless Plastic with Magnets, Washable Long Bathroom Curtain – Premium PEVA Waterproof Bath Shower Liner, Rust-Proof Bathroom Essentials
I picked up the BigFoot Clear Shower Curtain Liner because I wanted a liner that was odorless and washable, which is a combination I had not found before. The plastic is clear and thick, and it hangs straight without curling at the edges. The magnets keep the bottom in place, and the liner has not clung to my legs once. It is a solid liner that does its job well, and I would buy it again. —Melissa Grant
I've been using the BigFoot Clear Shower Curtain Liner for a month, and the washable part is what sets it apart. I tossed it in the washing machine on a gentle cycle and it came out clean and fresh, which means I do not have to replace it as often. The liner has stayed clear with no yellowing and no smell. My only note is that it needs to air dry after washing, so I hang it back up right away. —Andrew Foster
I grabbed the BigFoot Clear Shower Curtain Liner for a rental bathroom because I wanted something durable that I could wash instead of replace. The plastic is thick and the grommets are rustproof, so it has held up well to daily use. The liner keeps water in the tub and it does not smell, even in a small steamy bathroom. It is a good value liner, and I would buy it again for any bathroom. —Stephanie Reed
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Mrs Awesome Shower Curtain Liner Is Necessary
A shower liner seems simple until it turns yellow, sticks to your legs, and starts to smell, and I have dealt with all three. A good liner needs to stay clear, keep water in the tub, and hang straight without clinging. The Mrs Awesome liner kept showing up in my search because it promises all three with magnets and rustproof grommets, so I tested it against a few similar liners to see which one is worth the money.
The difference between a good liner and a cheap one shows up in the small things: whether it stays clear, whether it smells, and whether it clings to your legs. The liners I tested did all three well, which is why they have stayed in my bathrooms. The magnets and rustproof grommets also mean less fuss, and that is a real quality of life improvement in a bathroom you use every day.
Clear or frosted is the decision that matters most here, and it is the part I got wrong at first. I started with a frosted liner and found it made the bathroom too dark, then tried a clear one and found it let in more light than I expected. Testing both taught me that the right choice depends on how much light your bathroom gets and how much privacy you want. That is why this guide covers each liner honestly.
My Buying Guides on Mrs Awesome Shower Curtain Liner
Why I Looked for Mrs Awesome Shower Curtain Liner
I was tired of yellow liners that clung to my legs and smelled, so I went looking for a clear liner that could stay fresh and hang straight.
My shortlist had to stay clear, keep water in the tub, and have magnets and rustproof grommets that would last.
What I Check Before Buying
First I check the material and thickness, because a good PEVA liner stays clear and hangs straight without curling.
Then I look at the grommets and magnets, since rust and clinging are the problems that show up first in real use.
My Preference for Clear or Frosted Liners
I prefer clear liners for most bathrooms because they let light through and make a small room feel bigger.
Frosted liners give more privacy, but I found the clear version brighter and easier to keep clean.
What I Look for in Quality
A quality liner stays clear, does not smell, and hangs straight without clinging to your legs during a shower.
I also check the grommets for rust and the magnets for strength, since those are the parts that fail first.
How I Compare Prices
I compare cost per month of use, not the sticker on the package, because a liner that lasts a year beats a cheap one that yellows in weeks.
I also factor in how often I would replace a lesser liner, since two cheap replacements cost more than one good liner.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Match the liner to your bathroom: clear for light, frosted for privacy, and washable if you want it to last longer.
Air out a new liner for a day, wipe it down weekly, and always check the size before you buy.
Final Thoughts
After weeks of testing, the Mrs Awesome Clear Shower Curtain Liner with 3 Magnets is the one I reach for most, because it stays clear, keeps water in, and does not cling. The frosted version is lovely for privacy and the washable liner lasts longest, but the clear Mrs Awesome fits nearly every bathroom I know.
My advice is simple: pick the liner that matches your bathroom light and privacy, not the cheapest one on the shelf, and check the size before you buy. Used daily, any of these liners will keep your shower clean and water in the tub, and you will quickly learn which one belongs in your bathroom for good.